spiesr wrote:captainwalrus wrote:william18 wrote:I don't see why anyone is hesitating. He claimed cult. Thats almost like a person claiming godfather. I think ani had a far-fetched idea that we would reason with him.
Claiming cult is not at all like claiming godfather. If you lynch a godfather then that mob is done, but if we lynch just a cult follower then a new follower will just tke his place and we will be worse off, cause there will be less townies. Lynching a cult follower when there are 3 cults is almost pointless.
While I understand what you are trying to say, we need to lynch all cultists and there is no real reason to believe he is not the leader. After all, who would recruit him right on night 1?
Who wouldn't recruit him on night one? The leaders had to recruit someone so why not him? And why would it be in his role that he can't be recruited by green cult if he is already a leader. I agree that so far it is unlikely that he will be very helpfully but what if tonight he finds a cult leader? And I don't know of any role that kills cult followers, only role that kills leaders, so ani is a permanent cop who can't be killed and can just provide info. I see no reason to lynch him. Just because he is a member of a cult doesn't make him a threat.
Also, I seem to be the only one strongly opposed to lynching him, yet it is taking a very long time to get him. He is at L-1 for goodness sake! I think that there need to be some replacements made soon to get more activity.