Conquer Club

so long story short mitch aint on the lsit as hes being himself if mitch was being differant hed be on the list

Yes, very likely.

I agree activity does not equal alignment mars but activity is how we determine alignment.
Scum love to just coast along,its really the best choice for them D1,as town we cant really allow this,especially as this game is mostly vanilla(even if mafia fully"stacked the deck")
So my vote stands.

I think the way the question was asked to bos was a little weird she is usually open with her answers but that specific question would lead the way for scum to stay under the radar to her by acting opposite of whatever she posted.. Nothing wrong with asking for more info as to why she didn't think Mitch was scummy which she answered.

Pts start was a bit strange towards bos but haven't seen much of him to get any kind of read one way or the other...
Not sure that the time of posts are much to go on as mine will be all over the place I log in at random times throughout the day but this early its definitely good to look at everything and all details so something to consider

Vote count

-Endgame422 (0):
-TimWoodbury (1): marashu
-WingCmdr Ginkapo (0):
-bosaardbeitje (1): ptlowe
-madmitch (0):
-Streaker (1): the white rose
-the white rose (2): dakky21, Endgame422
-Marashu (1): Wing
-Iron Butterfly (1): bosaardbeitje

With 12 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Deadline November 12th 05.00 CC Time.

I know that Endgame is voting White Rose, so I suspect the vote count is incorrect.

WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:I know that Endgame is voting White Rose, so I suspect the vote count is incorrect.

Switched IB's and Endgame's names there. Replaced IB voting on rose by Endgame voting on rose.

Endgame422 wrote:

madmitch wrote:@ End I don't understand your vote unless you are trying to get a result from TWR. also you yourself have not made any clear posts ,so you should vote for your self

Just wanting some action out of rose.
Last game he was town he was very opinionated,here hes just blending in to the wall,which raises an eyebrow from me.

It is true that i have not been as active on this game as yet, but that is really because i have not really anything useful to post. I guess I am being a little distracted with my other games, and perhaps should not play so many games at once.

Having said that, it is only D1 and as yet I have no real reads on anyone, what would you have me do? keep switching my vote with lots of joke votes?

suffice to say I am reading all posts carefully and when i find something scummy i will pounce on it.

WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:
There is something else thats important to D1 this game. Mafia had a N0 so knew when the game was going to start properly. The first three posts were Boss, Mars and Myself. Boss and Mars both posted within 30 mins of Streaker. Now I was willing to give Boss benefit of the doubt as I know posting at 07:00 CC time is normal for her as she is European. However, Mars is American so this is rather odd. Moreover, by the fact that Mars was stalking the mafia forum throughout the previous weekend, odd behaviour for someone not in a game.

Anyone got any thoughts on this?

hmm, very clever wing. It could of course be totally useless, however, its all we have to go on at the moment.....so vote mars

Innocent child-Town player who is confirmed as town at gamestart(typically cannot vote)
Vigilante-Can kill one player each night
Tracker-Can follow one player and see who(if anyone)that player visits
Roleblocker-Blocks a players night actions
Bulletproof-Cannot be killed by normal killing actions
Role cop-Can investigate one player to determine what NAs they can use
Daytalk-Extra thread where scum can plan without town seeing their interactions
Strongman-Cannot be blocked from committing nightkill
Ninja-Cannot be tracked/watched while commiting nightkill[/quote]
number 1,2,3,4 and 5 are town aligned so if Dakky is telling the truth which I now believe , he is town so UNVOTE

madmitch wrote:number 1,2,3,4 and 5 are town aligned so if Dakky is telling the truth which I now believe , he is town so UNVOTE

What???

sorry Dakky was vig in the other game, in this game he is quiet as oh hell which is unusual so VOTE DAKKY

Agreed. Dakky's last post in this game was 4 days ago, that's way too quiet in my opinion. unvote vote dakky

mitch, that is mad, even for you...which statement of dakky's do you believe? and now you vote him......me thinks you are playing too many mafia games at once

RIGHT AS RAIN

I'm silent because didn't expect both games to start the same day.
Need to read this game again, will post something later today.

yep, sympathise with you dakky, i have posted way more than you but still found my way onto some players scumlists, i am in both the games you mention too....but don't really want to D1 lynch you again

Well I was in 4 games and did pretty good in posting with just a minor screw up,now I really think you scummering Dakky.

Marashu wrote: (also, fun fact, most Canadians don't like being called American)

Apologies, I meant it in the North American continent sense. I blame the standard Risk board as it doesnt acknowledge Cananda either.

Three people havent voted yet. We need opinions on the table to work from.

Anyone else find Boss' bandwagoning with Mitch on Dakky curious? Given up on IB already after feeling so strong about it before.

we have 3 days to decide on a lynch and agree i see the concensis thus far is dakky buthe claims to have not realized game started or something so im gonna let him read and after he posts ill throw a ote out

WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:

Marashu wrote: (also, fun fact, most Canadians don't like being called American)

Apologies, I meant it in the North American continent sense. I blame the standard Risk board as it doesnt acknowledge Cananda either.

Three people havent voted yet. We need opinions on the table to work from.

Anyone else find Boss' bandwagoning with Mitch on Dakky curious? Given up on IB already after feeling so strong about it before.

im one of the ones who dont have a vote i thought i had one but appearently i had unvoted

Sorry for the lack of posts, my parents came to stay over the weekend, and they only just left. Didn't realise it'd been so long since I posted... Finally read through everything.

--------

I'm surprised at the flak bosaa received for the response to IB. It was a pretty strangely worded question from IB, asking "how to and how not to get onto your scum list", instead of asking simply about mitch, whom bosaa sort of indicated having a seemingly distinct set of criteria for. Though looking closely at those who chided bosaa for her response - Mars, IB and Wing - they weren't attempting to use the situation as a cheap way to pin suspicion on bosaa either, since they didn't list her on their suspect list, and IB explicitly said it isn't necessarily scummy behaviour. So at least it doesn't seem like they weren't making a scum move.

I think bosaa's vote on IB is rather strong a reaction though. If I recall, IB isn't exactly the most tactful of people, so I wouldn't see his phrasing of the question as a scummy move at this point.

--------

I'm rather hesitant on the case built based on the timing of posts... How does mafia having a N0 mean that they'd know the exact time that Streaker would make the game opening post? Sure, they might have known that the game would start after they'd told him their decision, but how would that mean they knew the exact time Streaker would make the post, and be so enthusiastic as to wake up earlier and check the forums at 07:00 CC? Wouldn't Streaker still have had to send out the roles to the villagers, since he had to know how the scum stacked the deck before sending town roles out? So yea, I honestly don't think the post timing is any indication.

--------

Haven't played with TWR before, so I've no point of reference; can't really comment on that at the moment. Shall wait to see what dakky says before I can size him up. I also note that PT hasn't posted for 3.5 days now... further back than my last post, in fact, but he didn't get prodded. Wonder what's going on there...

-------

The one that's raised my eyebrows the most for now is actually rizky. Aside from the confirmation and joke vote stuff, his only posts have been:

rizky quotes

rizky_biznezz wrote:i can't make much from what we have so far... not inclined to think mitch is scum as yet but like everyone has said not much to work with

Repeating what bos said about mitch, then says he doesn't know what else to think - which at that point was fair enough I guess.

rizky_biznezz wrote:I think the way the question was asked to bos was a little weird she is usually open with her answers but that specific question would lead the way for scum to stay under the radar to her by acting opposite of whatever she posted.. Nothing wrong with asking for more info as to why she didn't think Mitch was scummy which she answered.

Agreeing with all sides of the arguments - that the question was weird, but that bos's reaction to it was weird, then repeats bos's explanation her reaction.

rizky_biznezz wrote:Pts start was a bit strange towards bos but haven't seen much of him to get any kind of read one way or the other...
Not sure that the time of posts are much to go on as mine will be all over the place I log in at random times throughout the day but this early its definitely good to look at everything and all details so something to consider

Acknowledges PT's post as strange, but doesn't add anything more. Says that post timing may not be indicative... but then again may be indicative so let's keep looking at it.

The posts seem like fine examples of how to say something without really saying anything... Most of the opinions - each of which he only briefly mentions - are mostly repetitions of what has been said earlier, and sometimes even sees him equally taking both sides of the argument.

Vote rizky_biznezz

FP'ed by Wing, Tim

WingCmdr Ginkapo wrote:

Marashu wrote: (also, fun fact, most Canadians don't like being called American)

Apologies, I meant it in the North American continent sense. I blame the standard Risk board as it doesnt acknowledge Cananda either.

Three people havent voted yet. We need opinions on the table to work from.

Anyone else find Boss' bandwagoning with Mitch on Dakky curious? Given up on IB already after feeling so strong about it before.

I still believe it was a very strange question to ask and I will definitely keep it in mind. As I said earlier, it is also possible I misinterpreted the question. People seem to be divided about it, some say it was a good or simple question, some say it was a strange question, but no-one really believes it was a scummy question, so I am not going to be stubborn about it.

Right now I give priority to hearing from all 12 people in here. Dakky caught my attention for not posting for so long. I find his first post after returning not convincing. He díd post for the first 2 days, but disappeared after that. Now he's saying that he didn't expect both games to start at the same time. Okay, but is that a good enough reason for not posting anything at all for 4 days? Other people are involved in more games and manage to post in here.