Conquer Club

All he said was that he had a pro-town power role. You have to remeber he said he would be totally honest. If he was mafia that would be a lie. He just seems scummy to me. I haven't seen him ever since you guys started off on me. If he was the doc then who was he going to protect all game? Some random person till he had an idea of who the mafia's next target was? You guys are putting way too much trust on a guy who claims he has a pro-town role.

If we have a good cop, I am sure he would inspect him first.


But for day 1, we cannnot take a chance to lynch a power-role. Day two will be different.


As for now, my vote stands.

I did a random vote on page 2 that some how pancake kept missing on the vote counts so i'm just reposting it since pancake couldn't find it even after I said it earlier

Well why are you voting on me? I swear I'm just a vanilla townie and lynching me is not going to help the game at all. Wait a mafia day and fircoal will hopefully confirm I'm Disco Stu. Plus if I live then you have someone who's active and can think these things through later on to help you. Not one of these newbies who comes on once a week to sign up and leave.

LSU Tiger Josh wrote:I did a random vote on page 2 that some how pancake kept missing on the vote counts so i'm just reposting it since pancake couldn't find it even after I said it earlier

Nope..he included it.


Btw..why are you keeping that random vote against me? I would like to know

sheepofdumb wrote:Well why are you voting on me? I swear I'm just a vanilla townie and lynching me is not going to help the game at all. Wait a mafia day and fircoal will hopefully confirm I'm Disco Stu. Plus if I live then you have someone who's active and can think these things through later on to help you. Not one of these newbies who comes on once a week to sign up and leave.

In the case you're not lieing, why would we have to suspect Nagerous of beeing a scum for the fact he could be lieing. The EXACT same happens with you


Like I said, we'll probably know if Nagerous was lieing or not on day 2 aswell, but between you 2, you did the most harm. That's why I am voting for you.

I have a way to confirm though. If fircoal doesn't confirm me then we have a lead that he's scum.

If he is scum then my "damage" was much more helpful than anything we've done thus far. He took the risk in trying to role claim in the first place. I just took advantage to see if he would crack.

sheepofdumb wrote:I have a way to confirm though. If fircoal doesn't confirm me then we have a lead that he's scum.

and how can we possibly automatically trust Fircoal? We don't know who anyone is at this point. Sorry sheep, but that won't work.

He included it after i posted a 2nd time
more then likely though i'll be changing it to dumbsheep for well being dumb.

MountainLion wrote:

sheepofdumb wrote:I have a way to confirm though. If fircoal doesn't confirm me then we have a lead that he's scum.

and how can we possibly automatically trust Fircoal? We don't know who anyone is at this point. Sorry sheep, but that won't work.

If Fir says I didn't send it to him and you lynch me then Fircoal would look pretty scummy once you found I'm telling the truth. I'm going to put some faith in Fircoal. Just give me a chance.

So we have to put faith and you and fircoal, but not anyone else?

WHY would we do that?


We can trust nobody in here. I thought you knew that.

But if both you and Fircoal were scum, all Fircoal would have to do is say he got the PM from you. It won't work. We can't trust you both.

I do believe you're telling the truth sheep, but you never know.

This is a difficult first day especially needing 15 to lynch.

MANY people have confirmed but havint voted...I am keeping them for submarining on day 2 if they don't bring their butts in here.

Just trust me on this. This is a one shot chance to find out if Fircoal is mafia or not. If he comes through for me then I can say that I told you so. If he doesn't then when you lynch me you have a lead. I'm going to ask you to just trust me on this one. You will have the chance to kill me later. I need to go to bed. Night.

sheepofdumb wrote:Just trust me on this. This is a one shot chance to find out if Fircoal is mafia or not. If he comes through for me then I can say that I told you so. If he doesn't then when you lynch me you have a lead. I'm going to ask you to just trust me on this one. You will have the chance to kill me later. I need to go to bed. Night.

I will take that chance then.


Unvote



Vote: --SHEEP--


There...final vote on my part.

nagerous wrote:vote sheep

why are you pushing for a role claim so early????

If I roleclaim it will be harmful for the town as it would give mafia information I don't want them to know, I have already stated that I am pro-town

you yourself were pushing for a roleclaim, and now you turn back on sheep.. HYPOCRITE!
you win my vote ..plus when you said "fine waste your vote on me", well, that earned a FOS from me..but that last quote was a clincher
vote nagerous

sheepofdumb wrote: My roleclaim was harmless though. I'll send a PM to you tonight and pancake can confirm.

i thought only masons could PM others at night :k..he could also be a mafiosa, but i doubt he'd be so determined defending himself that he got careless let that slip out, communicating with his fellow mafia members?

Hey there little Mafia dudes, how's it going ?

Huckleberryhound wrote:Hey there little Mafia dudes, how's it going ?

good.

Vote--Sheep

For putting too much pressure for a role claim during the first day that is just stupid.

I don't think sheepofdumb is scum. He didn't really push that hard & there have been others who have tried to get people to role claim ( trestain on Page 12 ) and as for nagerous claiming to be a power role, anyone can say they have a pro-town power role. GreecePwns also gave no defence against the bandwaggoning comment by sheepofdumb

FOS = nagerous & GreecePwns

We should definately lynch someone, but why lynch a possible townie?

Can we get a vote count & a day deadline?

Kernal_Kronic wrote:I don't think sheepofdumb is scum. He didn't really push that hard & there have been others who have tried to get people to role claim ( trestain on Page 12 ) and as for nagerous claiming to be a power role, anyone can say they have a pro-town power role. GreecePwns also gave no defence against the bandwaggoning comment by sheepofdumb

FOS = nagerous & GreecePwns

We should definately lynch someone, but why lynch a possible townie?

correction kernal kronic, i suggested that we name claim, big difference.

trestain wrote:

Kernal_Kronic wrote:I don't think sheepofdumb is scum. He didn't really push that hard & there have been others who have tried to get people to role claim ( trestain on Page 12 ) and as for nagerous claiming to be a power role, anyone can say they have a pro-town power role. GreecePwns also gave no defence against the bandwaggoning comment by sheepofdumb

FOS = nagerous & GreecePwns

We should definately lynch someone, but why lynch a possible townie?

correction kernal kronic, i suggested that we name claim, big difference.

But I have name claimed. I don't watch the show. I've stated that before and I'll say it again. Why would I claim a vanilla townie when I could look at a character list and claim a power role? I'm telling you I'm being totally honest with you guys. I've got nothing to hide.

trestain wrote:

Kernal_Kronic wrote:I don't think sheepofdumb is scum. He didn't really push that hard & there have been others who have tried to get people to role claim ( trestain on Page 12 ) and as for nagerous claiming to be a power role, anyone can say they have a pro-town power role. GreecePwns also gave no defence against the bandwaggoning comment by sheepofdumb

FOS = nagerous & GreecePwns

We should definately lynch someone, but why lynch a possible townie?

correction kernal kronic, i suggested that we name claim, big difference.

True, but some roles can be deduced from the character's (doc, cop, etc.).

If sheep really is disco stu, he's now a target for any of the night role's (mafia, cult, etc.) and he's active during the day so i don't think he's the right choice for a lynching...

Did this game start on a night phase? If it did, then there was no kills... There are a lot of submarinners(sp?) around.