Page 19 of 39
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2008 8:23 am
by wicked
The mountains do look kinda just thrown in there last minute. I think that's how my 7 y.o. nephew would draw them. There's definitely room for improvement.
Also, can you move over these names to center them in the territory more? Gloucs., Essex, Oxon, Lincolnshire, West Midlands.
Your name/number locations for Strathclyde are different on the small and large maps. Use what you did for the small for both - it looks better.
There's water texture? Where?
I know it's called Lothian & Borders.... but you're telling me if I told an Englishman Lothian, he wouldn't know where I was talking about? Come on now. There's already a Borders in Ireland... switch L&B to just Lothian.
And it's never too late for comments. This map isn't done yet.
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2008 9:31 am
by MrBenn
gimil wrote:The mountians have been passed and accepted by discussing already.
There may have been some discussion about stretching/sizing the mountains on the Welsh border, but I've just read everything from my last post (on p16), and the only comment about the mountains is one from me,with a suggestion about changing the mountains in the South to be the New Forest...
There haven't been any comments about the visual impact of the mountains... I don't have any particular problems with the way the mountains look, but there are others who do...
Discuss...
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2008 9:33 am
by gimil
changing to a forest? must of been a comment i missed ill look into it
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2008 10:15 am
by Jesse710
gimil wrote:Jesse710 wrote:Is the map going to have the country flag's in the background like your other image?
nope there was a strong disagreement towards them from thw commumity so they went
I'd say it looked a lot cooler with them
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2008 4:01 pm
by MrBenn
There were issues with the flags/countries... ie England has 1 flag, but covers 3 'continents'; which made it a little confusing for the eye.
There was also a big hoo-haa about the N Ireland flag, for reasons that are a bit beyond me (they don't currently have an official flag - and the generally recognised one (ie their old flag) has various political connotations which is why it is no longer used )...
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2008 4:01 pm
by gimil
MrBenn wrote:There were issues with the flags/countries... ie England has 1 flag, but covers 3 'continents'; which made it a little confusing for the eye.
There was also a big hoo-haa about the N Ireland flag, for reasons that are a bit beyond me (they don't currently have an official flag - and the generally recognised one (ie their old flag) has various political connotations which is why it is no longer used )...
long story short the flags became a no-no
Posted: Thu Jan 03, 2008 4:29 pm
by rebelman
I it possible to make the Irish "borders" "border counties" instead as that is what they are actually known as
Posted: Sat Jan 05, 2008 12:36 pm
by iancanton
Incandenza wrote:the lake in Northern Ireland seems extraneous.
our map currently shows two lakes in northern ireland.
the larger one is lough neagh, which is an instantly-recognisable feature of any northern ireland map. like lake winnipeg on the canada map, it doesn't have any part in the gameplay, although it serves as a landmark.
the smaller one on the right is strangford lough, which is supposed to have an outlet to the sea at its south-east corner (and therefore isn't actually a lake). can we redraw the irish coastline at strangford lough to reflect this?
http://www.strangfordlough.org/map/context.htm
ian.
Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 1:35 pm
by bonobo`s son
the colors of the map playable now is much better then this one
Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 1:43 pm
by pepperonibread
South England doesn't have a full dark border like the rest of the continents, just a minor problem. If it looks like you'll have to redo a lot of borders to fix it, I say don't bother with it.
Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 2:00 pm
by bonobo`s son
pepperonibread wrote:South England doesn't have a full dark border like the rest of the continents, just a minor problem. If it looks like you'll have to redo a lot of borders to fix it, I say don't bother with it.
because of those things the netherlands isn't quenched so it is a problem what got to be done before quenching.
Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 2:17 pm
by gimil
bonobo`s son wrote:pepperonibread wrote:South England doesn't have a full dark border like the rest of the continents, just a minor problem. If it looks like you'll have to redo a lot of borders to fix it, I say don't bother with it.
because of those things the netherlands isn't quenched so it is a problem what got to be done before quenching.
Netherlands concerns are becasue they can disrupt gameplay and potentially reduce players enjoyment. THese ones dont.
However, as always i will see what i can do, but pep i dont see what your talking about. Can you circles where your concerns lie?
Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 2:45 pm
by bonobo`s son
gimil wrote:bonobo`s son wrote:pepperonibread wrote:South England doesn't have a full dark border like the rest of the continents, just a minor problem. If it looks like you'll have to redo a lot of borders to fix it, I say don't bother with it.
because of those things the netherlands isn't quenched so it is a problem what got to be done before quenching.
Netherlands concerns are becasue they can disrupt gameplay and potentially reduce players enjoyment. THese ones dont.
However, as always i will see what i can do, but pep i dont see what your talking about. Can you circles where your concerns lie?
this won`t help gameplay only graphics
Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 2:46 pm
by gimil
not sure i understand you?
Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 3:29 pm
by pepperonibread
bonobo`s son wrote:pepperonibread wrote:South England doesn't have a full dark border like the rest of the continents, just a minor problem. If it looks like you'll have to redo a lot of borders to fix it, I say don't bother with it.
because of those things the netherlands isn't quenched so it is a problem what got to be done before quenching.
The problem with Netherlands prevented people from seeing the army numbers well, and was noticed by many people throughout the thread (that's the problem we're talking about, right?). This is a very minor fix, one so small that no one has noticed it throughout the 30-page thread.
And for gimil, here's the problem:
The place I outlined should contain the rest of the dark outer edge of South England. I'd guess that the layers for the other continents are on top of the layer for South England. If that's true, then you'd probably have to redraw the continent to exactly line up with the others. It might even end up looking worse. So unless it's an easy fix, I say leave it as is. No point in wasting a bunch of time to fix something only a few people will ever notice.
Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 3:37 pm
by gimil
This has been discussed before and decided it was better without
Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 4:31 pm
by pepperonibread
Cool... I vote quench then.
Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 6:16 pm
by wicked
pepperonibread wrote:Cool... I vote quench then.
Nope! Still a lot being discussed!
Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 6:33 pm
by gimil
wicked wrote:pepperonibread wrote:Cool... I vote quench then.
Nope! Still a lot being discussed!
nothnig being discussed the communities actually awaiting an update
Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 8:15 pm
by wicked
right, to see if you added our comments!
Posted: Sun Jan 06, 2008 8:18 pm
by gimil
wicked wrote:right, to see if you added our comments!
which for the most part wont be your double names. . .
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 12:11 am
by Coleman
gimil wrote:wicked wrote:right, to see if you added our comments!
which for the most part wont be your double names. . .
Why?
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 6:08 am
by gimil
Coleman wrote:gimil wrote:wicked wrote:right, to see if you added our comments!
which for the most part wont be your double names. . .
Why?
Becasue the double ames in scotland are the actual names of those ares and so far as i know there isnt any other relevent usable name.
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 6:12 am
by rebelman
rebelman wrote:I it possible to make the Irish "borders" "border counties" instead as that is what they are actually known as
Posted: Mon Jan 07, 2008 6:13 am
by gimil
rebelman wrote:rebelman wrote:I it possible to make the Irish "borders" "border counties" instead as that is what they are actually known as
Ill surprise you