Conquer Club

Master Bush wrote:I dont feel that there anyone left in the game, who is not adding to it.

In that case geegel is mafia too, because he is obviously lurking.

I am much more sure that geegel is mafia than Senfive or Cblake.

unvote CBlake

Vote Geegel

Yeah, I look scummy, so what?

Machiavelli wrote:

Master Bush wrote:I dont feel that there anyone left in the game, who is not adding to it.

In that case geegel is mafia too, because he is obviously lurking.

I am much more sure that geegel is mafia than Senfive or Cblake.

unvote CBlake

Vote Geegel

Yeah, I look scummy, so what?

unvote fircoal vote geegel

goddamn you all and your frequent posting. i have no idea what's going on since i don't wanna read the recent replies. so let's go with the majority:
vote CBlake

Vote Count

• [4] CBlake -- (fircoal, chessplaya, houssam, hitman079)
• [2] geegel -- (machiavelli, cblake)
• [1] fircoal -- (senfive)
• [3] Not Voted -- (geegel, slim_jesta, rev_kyle)

6 Total Votes are needed for a Lynch or No Lynch

I just got in and read A few pages, but If I can get a explanation from houssam on why he is voting Cblake(a summary) and one from mach on why he is voting geegle and one from senfive on why he is voting fircoal I believe I can form some opinions and make an educated decision.

Master Bush wrote:I dont feel that there anyone left in the game, who is not adding to it.

MB said that, but Geegel has definetely not been posting, so he must be mafia lurking.

I was suspicious of him earlier too, MB's post practically confirms my previous thoughts

Machiavelli wrote:

Master Bush wrote:I dont feel that there anyone left in the game, who is not adding to it.

MB said that, but Geegel has definetely not been posting, so he must be mafia lurking.

I was suspicious of him earlier too, MB's post practically confirms my previous thoughts

I honestly don't feel bad that Mach, Fircoal, and Hos are all Mafia. I don't care because they have the townies wrapped around there fingers. As soon as I picked up on Fircoal, I was voted for by Mach. Then Hos says that Fircoal is a mason withhim self. I highly suggest that if you are townie you do not lynch the insane cop just yet. I suggest we hit fircoal, then if that isn't a hit, which I swear on my mothers grave that it will be, we go after CBlake. If you are townie Please Band Together with me. The Mafia is preying on the non active members using crap logic to persicute them. This is my last plea cause I hate being in a game where the Townies are retarded and listen to crap logic then Evidence that is right in front of there faces.

reverend_kyle wrote: houssam on why he is voting Cblake(a summary)

I don't have a HUGE case against CBlake. but there are a few things that I can't reconcile. Two things especially - we had discussed all the different scenarios that could result in everywhere being a townie even though CBlake (our cop) investigated and incriminated him. Those scenarios had 3 possibilties where CBlake would think he would be telling the truth, and 4 where he would be lying. Yet, once the death scene was posted, he acted shocked and surprised, posting protests in the night time, as if there was NO WAY everywhere could have been a townie, even though as I said, we had discussed multiple ways he could.

The second thing was how he voted for himself - I saw this as an act of desperation, so I posted that, to which he immediately followed up saying "exactly" which made it sound to me that this might have been a technique to defray suspicion to start with..

The third thing was when he reported that MB told him he was "lying" to him! I guess he meant by this he was an insane cop - but it's a strange way to report what the mod told him. MB would never have told him "yeah, I am lying to you!"

Now, all of the above is highly circumstantial, but convincing to me. However, here is where I struggle:

1. I think it is waaay to ballsy from him to come out and lie about his role - and not fear the real cop coming forward. We (Fircoal actually) had a theory that maybe the guy you replaced was the cop, and that somehow CBlake used his absence to claim safely (perhaps he is a mafia cop). Now, while rather unlikely (too sophisticated for him in my opinion) it is at least possible - that is, until you stepped in to replace the guy. This is why I was asking you earlier you were the cop. Which you clearly are not.

2. If CBlake is not the cop, or even if he is an insane cop, then where the hell is our cop? Because if MB has a 17 player game with no cop, then we should all be voting Mfreakin'B!

So that's my dilemma right now!

ON A RELATED NOTE - maybe one of the best things we have right now, is having a fresh pair of eyes (you) in the game. I think we are losing sight of the forest by focusing on trees here. If you have the time to go back and read the thread from an outsider perspective, maybe you can bring some clarity..

HoussamTheGreat wrote:

reverend_kyle wrote: houssam on why he is voting Cblake(a summary)

I don't have a HUGE case against CBlake.

BLAH

BLAH

BLAH

ON A RELATED NOTE - maybe one of the best things we have right now, is having a fresh pair of eyes (you) in the game. I think we are losing sight of the forest by focusing on trees here. If you have the time to go back and read the thread from an outsider perspective, maybe you can bring some clarity..

We are talking about RK here.

Senfive wrote: I honestly don't feel bad that Mach, Fircoal, and Hos are all Mafia. I don't care because they have the townies wrapped around there fingers. As soon as I picked up on Fircoal, I was voted for by Mach. Then Hos says that Fircoal is a mason withhim self. I highly suggest that if you are townie you do not lynch the insane cop just yet. I suggest we hit fircoal, then if that isn't a hit, which I swear on my mothers grave that it will be, we go after CBlake. If you are townie Please Band Together with me. The Mafia is preying on the non active members using crap logic to persicute them. This is my last plea cause I hate being in a game where the Townies are retarded and listen to crap logic then Evidence that is right in front of there faces.

2 things in the above

1. I said that Fircoal and I were masons as early as day 2! I even had a long discussion with Mach (yesterday) about the possibility of 2-faced masons, that we ruled out. I don't know whether you haven't read this, or whether you have and are ignoring it, but I am not liking either option!

2. I agree that an insane cop is useless AS A COP - but he would still be a townie, right? he counts as a body if nothing else! If we all agree that CBlake is an insane cop, we should really be lynching someone else! Wait I just reread - and that's kinda what you are saying. Forget 2. then!

Machiavelli wrote:CBlake is not a real cop!!!

He is either mafia or insane. If everyone was a miller it would have said "miller" next to his name when he was lynched.

To that point, we lost our doctor day 2 - and it does not say Doctor next to their name.

Mod can we please review the list on page 1 to make sure that whatever is there is what you want to be there - no accidental ommissions?

In the meantime

unvote

An Insane cop gets the opposite results as the regular cop, so an insane cop would be useful. Yet, if he gets scum on a townie, then innocent on a townie, he can't be insane, he can't even be a cop. There are no cop roles that give out 2 different results for 2 pro-towns. So that means CBlake was to be scum.

Also, look at how many people are being thrown out as possibilities without a strong case trying to get them lynched.

Fircoal wrote:An Insane cop gets the opposite results as the regular cop, so an insane cop would be useful.

So an insane cop gets the opposite consistently or just random results. Cause if it's the opposite then we know 100% that CBlake is lying. no question about it.

HoussamTheGreat wrote:

Fircoal wrote:An Insane cop gets the opposite results as the regular cop, so an insane cop would be useful.

So an insane cop gets the opposite consistently or just random results. Cause if it's the opposite then we know 100% that CBlake is lying. no question about it.

opposite results, that's how it's said. Unless...

But really it's opposite results. The only unless is if MB misunderstood the role.

HoussamTheGreat wrote:To that point, we lost our doctor day 2 - and it does not say Doctor next to their name.

My mistake....fixed.

Vote Count

• [3] CBlake -- (fircoal, chessplaya, hitman079)
• [2] geegel -- (machiavelli, cblake)
• [1] fircoal -- (senfive)
• [4] Not Voted -- (geegel, slim_jesta, rev_kyle, houssam)

6 Total Votes are needed for a Lynch or No Lynch

Master Bush wrote:

HoussamTheGreat wrote:To that point, we lost our doctor day 2 - and it does not say Doctor next to their name.

My mistake....fixed.

QFE - no miller has been added.

Machiavelli wrote:CBlake is not a real cop!!!

He is either mafia or insane. If everyone was a miller it would have said "miller" next to his name when he was lynched.

That's "everywhere," dumbell.

hey all just checking in will read the thread tomorrow(it is midnight here) just wanted you all to know i am replacing qeegel.

***ANNOUNCEMENT***

Trestain has replaced Geegel in the game.

When I said that I was fine with the players in the game, I was under the idea that everyone was posting enough and active enough. But geegel, although had made a lot of post early on, has not posted in this thread since friday night. That's unaccpetable in my mind.

I dont mind player who lay low in my games, but you cant go 4 days without posting.

I'll still be a replacement!!!!

wicked wrote:I'll still be a replacement!!!!

Ok, you can replace Roger Dodger.

Master Bush wrote:You're dead...stop posting.

ROTFFLMFAO!!