Page 4 of 8
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 12:11 am
by Fircoal
Victor Sullivan wrote:ga7 wrote:kwanfirm.
On my first read I thought the winning ticket was Medefe-Edocsil. That thing at the beginning where Medefe overreacts and Edoc just backs down freaking quickly feels staged. Then Medefe OMGUS votes Fir, thus overreacting more. Fishy.
On my second read I feel Aage might be on to something about Victor that is just waiting without making waves, having his vote placed already. I find Edoc slightly more suspicious though as he seems to act more opportunistic. However I want to hear from Fir for now since he's at lynch -1. And btw, let's not make l-2 the new l-1

Vote already, ga7!
That sounds awfully opportunistic. I didn't even claim yet. x3
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 4:49 am
by MeDeFe
Fircoal wrote:Victor Sullivan wrote:ga7 wrote:kwanfirm.
On my first read I thought the winning ticket was Medefe-Edocsil. That thing at the beginning where Medefe overreacts and Edoc just backs down freaking quickly feels staged. Then Medefe OMGUS votes Fir, thus overreacting more. Fishy.
On my second read I feel Aage might be on to something about Victor that is just waiting without making waves, having his vote placed already. I find Edoc slightly more suspicious though as he seems to act more opportunistic. However I want to hear from Fir for now since he's at lynch -1. And btw, let's not make l-2 the new l-1

Vote already, ga7!
That sounds awfully opportunistic. I didn't even claim yet. x3
Seeing how you're at L-1 you probably should.
So... noone else vote for Fircoal until we have a roleclaim.
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 5:26 am
by Victor Sullivan
Fircoal wrote:Victor Sullivan wrote:ga7 wrote:kwanfirm.
On my first read I thought the winning ticket was Medefe-Edocsil. That thing at the beginning where Medefe overreacts and Edoc just backs down freaking quickly feels staged. Then Medefe OMGUS votes Fir, thus overreacting more. Fishy.
On my second read I feel Aage might be on to something about Victor that is just waiting without making waves, having his vote placed already. I find Edoc slightly more suspicious though as he seems to act more opportunistic. However I want to hear from Fir for now since he's at lynch -1. And btw, let's not make l-2 the new l-1

Vote already, ga7!
That sounds awfully opportunistic. I didn't even claim yet. x3
I wasn't prodding him to vote you, Fircoal. I just merely want to see what his stance is on everything, like if he thinks MeDeFe is scum or something.
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 7:58 am
by aage
Victor Sullivan wrote:Fircoal wrote:Victor Sullivan wrote:ga7 wrote:kwanfirm.
On my first read I thought the winning ticket was Medefe-Edocsil. That thing at the beginning where Medefe overreacts and Edoc just backs down freaking quickly feels staged. Then Medefe OMGUS votes Fir, thus overreacting more. Fishy.
On my second read I feel Aage might be on to something about Victor that is just waiting without making waves, having his vote placed already. I find Edoc slightly more suspicious though as he seems to act more opportunistic. However I want to hear from Fir for now since he's at lynch -1. And btw, let's not make l-2 the new l-1

Vote already, ga7!
That sounds awfully opportunistic. I didn't even claim yet. x3
I wasn't prodding him to vote you, Fircoal. I just merely want to see what his stance is on everything, like if he thinks MeDeFe is scum or something.
He did in the post you've been quoting there. It's bold now. What more do you want to know, except you really really really are eager to lynch Fircoal?
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 10:43 am
by Fircoal
MeDeFe wrote:Fircoal wrote:Victor Sullivan wrote:ga7 wrote:kwanfirm.
On my first read I thought the winning ticket was Medefe-Edocsil. That thing at the beginning where Medefe overreacts and Edoc just backs down freaking quickly feels staged. Then Medefe OMGUS votes Fir, thus overreacting more. Fishy.
On my second read I feel Aage might be on to something about Victor that is just waiting without making waves, having his vote placed already. I find Edoc slightly more suspicious though as he seems to act more opportunistic. However I want to hear from Fir for now since he's at lynch -1. And btw, let's not make l-2 the new l-1

Vote already, ga7!
That sounds awfully opportunistic. I didn't even claim yet. x3
Seeing how you're at L-1 you probably should.
So... noone else vote for Fircoal until we have a roleclaim.
Well I didn't really want to roleclaim but I guess I have to...
I'm the angel. ><
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 11:22 am
by ga7
Sigh, I thought your reluctance to claim might mean that but thought you were a bit too proeminent to be the doc. Meh.
Vote Victor scummiest out of my suspects.
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 11:46 am
by edocsil
Fircoal wrote:MeDeFe wrote:Fircoal wrote:Victor Sullivan wrote:ga7 wrote:kwanfirm.
On my first read I thought the winning ticket was Medefe-Edocsil. That thing at the beginning where Medefe overreacts and Edoc just backs down freaking quickly feels staged. Then Medefe OMGUS votes Fir, thus overreacting more. Fishy.
On my second read I feel Aage might be on to something about Victor that is just waiting without making waves, having his vote placed already. I find Edoc slightly more suspicious though as he seems to act more opportunistic. However I want to hear from Fir for now since he's at lynch -1. And btw, let's not make l-2 the new l-1

Vote already, ga7!
That sounds awfully opportunistic. I didn't even claim yet. x3
Seeing how you're at L-1 you probably should.
So... noone else vote for Fircoal until we have a roleclaim.
Well I didn't really want to roleclaim but I guess I have to...
I'm the angel. ><
Well f*ck. I almost hope someone counterclaims, but it isn't going to happen. I really hope you can protect yourself, cans the scum are going to be hard on your ass tonight.
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 1:43 pm
by AceArtemis
-Vote Count-
Fircoal (3)- Victor Sullivan, MeDeFe, edocsil
MeDeFe (2)- colton24, Fircoal
Victor Sullivan (2)- aage, Ga7
Not Voting- (No One)
4 to Lynch.
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 2:48 pm
by Victor Sullivan
ga7 wrote:Sigh, I thought your reluctance to claim might mean that but thought you were a bit too proeminent to be the doc. Meh.
Vote Victor scummiest out of my suspects.
That's not exactly who I was thinking of when I told you to vote... I refuse to make a role claim till L-1 but I think you two are quite mistaken.
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 2:51 pm
by aage
Victor Sullivan wrote:ga7 wrote:Sigh, I thought your reluctance to claim might mean that but thought you were a bit too proeminent to be the doc. Meh.
Vote Victor scummiest out of my suspects.
That's not exactly who I was thinking of when I told you to vote... I refuse to make a role claim till L-1 but I think you two are quite mistaken.
Then what were you thinking of? You couldn't hammer yourself so you should just let a towny do it?
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 2:56 pm
by Victor Sullivan
aage wrote:Victor Sullivan wrote:ga7 wrote:Sigh, I thought your reluctance to claim might mean that but thought you were a bit too proeminent to be the doc. Meh.
Vote Victor scummiest out of my suspects.
That's not exactly who I was thinking of when I told you to vote... I refuse to make a role claim till L-1 but I think you two are quite mistaken.
Then what were you thinking of? You couldn't hammer yourself so you should just let a towny do it?
I just wanted him to vote for anyone but me. I didn't care if he necessarily voted for who I voted - he could've voted MeDeFe and that would've been fine or even someone random, like you, aage. I just wanted to see where he stood.
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 2:57 pm
by ga7
Edoc for not unvoting and skimming & Victor that wants me to vote anyone but him and Edoc sound like a solid guess for the scum team at this point

Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 3:00 pm
by Victor Sullivan
ga7 wrote:Edoc for not unvoting and skimming &
Victor that wants me to vote anyone but him and Edoc sound like a solid guess for the scum team at this point

No dip, stick. Of course I don't want you to vote for me. Does anyone but a jester want a vote? No. I find your argument weak.
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 3:04 pm
by ga7
Well dude, you've been obviously calling for a hammer and then say you'd have wanted anyone but you and Edoc voted. You say you wanted to know my stance when I had already exposed my suspicions, which you didn't care about since you wanted a vote. That's enough for me to stand by my vote.
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 3:06 pm
by ga7
Btw another scumtell is that neither of the guys on the Chu wagon unvoted, two of them having posted since then. The fact you seem so unconcerned about the doc claiming but about your own case instead is pretty revealing.
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 3:28 pm
by MeDeFe
Fircoal wrote:MeDeFe wrote:Fircoal wrote:Victor Sullivan wrote:ga7 wrote:kwanfirm.
On my first read I thought the winning ticket was Medefe-Edocsil. That thing at the beginning where Medefe overreacts and Edoc just backs down freaking quickly feels staged. Then Medefe OMGUS votes Fir, thus overreacting more. Fishy.
On my second read I feel Aage might be on to something about Victor that is just waiting without making waves, having his vote placed already. I find Edoc slightly more suspicious though as he seems to act more opportunistic. However I want to hear from Fir for now since he's at lynch -1. And btw, let's not make l-2 the new l-1

Vote already, ga7!
That sounds awfully opportunistic. I didn't even claim yet. x3
Seeing how you're at L-1 you probably should.
So... noone else vote for Fircoal until we have a roleclaim.
Well I didn't really want to roleclaim but I guess I have to...
I'm the angel. ><
If what you say is true, it's bad news.
unvote
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 3:44 pm
by colton24
Bullshit fircoal. I am the angel.
unvote, vote fircoal
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 3:46 pm
by aage
colton24 wrote:Bullshit fircoal. I am the angel.
unvote, vote fircoal
Strong counterclaim, and I really can't see how you're lying here.
In that case I wouldnt see any other reason for fircoal to lie except him being a werewolf.
unvote vote fircoal
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 3:49 pm
by colton24
Bye, bye werewolf
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 4:18 pm
by MeDeFe
HOLD IT!
Keep in mind that colton could be the werewolf, the mafia guy with no special powers, and gambling on us lynching Fircoal. If Fircoal is telling the truth and is lynched we're down to 4 town and 2 scum. Without a bodyguard someone definitely dies on night 1, then we're down to 3 town and 2 scum. Colton gets lynched on day 2, 3 town and 1 scum. Someone is killed on night 2, that makes it 2 town and 1 scum on day 3.
Not a good situation at all. If colton is the werewolf, the sorcerer is left and has a chance of blocking the town seer from doing anything useful.
I'm saying we should think carefully about just which order we want to go about lynching colton and Fircoal in. If we get the werewolf today the situation is very different and we pretty much have one confirmed town.
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 4:36 pm
by ga7
You were the only one who unvoted, so it's too late, Fircoal is lynched. Colton could be a werewolf forcing a day 3 LyLo, but it could go either way since Fir's behavior was pretty off if he was really a doc. I think he could have fakeclaimed to not screw the town's chances. One thing is sure, there's little chance for the seer to do anything useful if Fircoal isn't the scum roleblocker.
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 4:41 pm
by aage
What ga7 said. Lynch's done already... lets just hope your scenario doesn't turn up MeDeFe.
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 4:56 pm
by edocsil
This will be interesting. Could he have claimed to pull the doc out into the open? He is easily that devious, curious to see what the lynch brings.
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 4:58 pm
by colton24
Or we could both be doc(BWCS)
Re: Short, Simple Werewolf-Themed Game DAY 1
Posted: Thu Sep 30, 2010 5:00 pm
by edocsil
colton24 wrote:Or we could both be doc(BWCS)
Two docs, perhaps. I don't think so though. If he is a doc you will be lynched.