Conquer Club

Well, I have to be honest... I haven't re-read through this entire thread.

Due to that, I definately want to hear from Exile.

Damm, why kill me!

I investigated Sierra, who came up as Ranger (vig) - evidently right, but meh.

As far as my $0.02 goes though, I think Iliad is scum based on his posts, probably chaos judging by the faction balance, though I haven't had the chance to check it since I couldn't in good faith allow sierra to pull another athkatla That said, he's probably also right about the endgame.

Thus, I'm going to suggest we purge iliad.

However, it's also nearly midnight, I've walked many many miles today, and I'm tired and hungry, so if I've missed something important, please do tell me.

The1exile wrote:I investigated Sierra, who came up as Ranger (vig) - evidently right, but meh.

As far as my $0.02 goes though, I think Iliad is scum based on his posts, probably chaos judging by the faction balance, though I haven't had the chance to check it since I couldn't in good faith allow sierra to pull another athkatla That said, he's probably also right about the endgame.

Thus, I'm going to suggest we purge iliad.

However, it's also nearly midnight, I've walked many many miles today, and I'm tired and hungry, so if I've missed something important, please do tell me.

hmm. I do not see how I am scummy. I know you're a cop but please do not try to kill of a townie. We must be careful now. Looks like the endgame is very near. Especially since 3 pro-town players were added

The1exile wrote:I investigated Sierra, who came up as Ranger (vig) - evidently right, but meh.

As far as my $0.02 goes though, I think Iliad is scum based on his posts, probably chaos judging by the faction balance, though I haven't had the chance to check it since I couldn't in good faith allow sierra to pull another athkatla That said, he's probably also right about the endgame.

Thus, I'm going to suggest we purge iliad.

However, it's also nearly midnight, I've walked many many miles today, and I'm tired and hungry, so if I've missed something important, please do tell me.

exile please could you post everyone you've investigated/cleared every day. I do not have enough time to check.. Is it just Josh Tiger LSU that is alive?

vote illiad I'll go with exile's best guess since I do know that he is a true cop. I know that he also cleared ga earlier, but ga is dead while the other investigations i think found scum we killed.

PURGE COUNT
Iliad (2) - The1exile, LSU Tiger Josh

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch.

Even tho he is a cop, a guess is still just a guess.I'd like to see a complete list of investigations before I make a move.

I'm not 100% on this, but as close as i can get:

Night 5: Sierrra
Night 4: josh
Night 3: kalish - chaos scum
Night 2: ga7
Night 1: PCM - orc scum

I've read through iliad's posts, and I would be very surprised if he's not scum. His insistence on it being an endgame reinforces my belief.

Okeydokey.

The three newcomers shouldn't be scum unless our mod decided to throw in a twist.

Exile is cleared cuz I doubt he's that lucky of a guesser (or some kind of mafia cop but that is tremendously unlikely.)

LSU is semi-cleared as the possibility of a godfather still exists but the investigation is enough for him to be cleared at least for today.

That just leaves Dom, Iliad koesen, and myself as possible lynch choices.

I am up for lynching anyone but myself

If you are so sure that iliad is scum I am willing to trust you since the choices are narrowed down so much.

purge iliad

PURGE COUNT
Iliad (3) - The1exile, LSU Tiger Josh, kwanton

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

The1exile wrote:I'm not 100% on this, but as close as i can get:

Night 5: Sierrra
Night 4: josh
Night 3: kalish - chaos scum
Night 2: ga7
Night 1: PCM - orc scum

I've read through iliad's posts, and I would be very surprised if he's not scum. His insistence on it being an endgame reinforces my belief.

I only think that it's the endgame because
a) Skittles added 3 pro-town people
b) he pretty much told me

kwanton wrote:Okeydokey.

The three newcomers shouldn't be scum unless our mod decided to throw in a twist.

Exile is cleared cuz I doubt he's that lucky of a guesser (or some kind of mafia cop but that is tremendously unlikely.)

LSU is semi-cleared as the possibility of a godfather still exists but the investigation is enough for him to be cleared at least for today.

That just leaves Dom, Iliad koesen, and myself as possible lynch choices.

I am up for lynching anyone but myself

If you are so sure that iliad is scum I am willing to trust you since the choices are narrowed down so much.

purge iliad

Your reason is flawed. Yes obviously some of the people who were here from the beginnning are scum. However you are suddenly bandwagoning without any evidence and right now it seems like you're just trying to lynch a townie. Scum.

LSU Tiger Josh wrote:vote illiad I'll go with exile's best guess since I do know that he is a true cop. I know that he also cleared ga earlier, but ga is dead while the other investigations i think found scum we killed.

But why me?

None of you have any evidence why I'm the scum while purging me. i know exile aint scum but now I'm not sure about kwan or LSU

You don't know about LSU? How bout exile's investigation? Skim much?

Can you explain to me how my reason is flawed? To me there are only four choices for a lynch now. You me dom and koes. Exile is pretty much winning the game for us right now so I'm more than willing to follow him. If I hadn't narrowed it down i wouldn't vote you. But with 9 alive and four lynch choices I'm more than happy to since the probability of catching scum is so high. Where else can we get a 1 in four(at least) chance of catching scum without being in LYLO?

kwanton wrote:You don't know about LSU? How bout exile's investigation? Skim much?

Can you explain to me how my reason is flawed? To me there are only four choices for a lynch now. You me dom and koes. Exile is pretty much winning the game for us right now so I'm more than willing to follow him. If I hadn't narrowed it down i wouldn't vote you. But with 9 alive and four lynch choices I'm more than happy to since the probability of catching scum is so high. Where else can we get a 1 in four(at least) chance of catching scum without being in LYLO?

but he hasn't investigated me. He is only voting me on a hunch. First of all:
dom and koes are submarining.

Second of all: why me? Why not dom and koes?

That is why I am suspicious of you. You're bandwagoning

Iliad voted for Cena, LSU did not. I'd be more inclined to vote LSU, but I haven't played the whole game. So.... I'd be open to voting whatever.

LSU was investigated but he could be godfather. If he is then' we're in afor a treat
purge LSU

PURGE COUNT
Iliad (3) - The1exile, LSU Tiger Josh, kwanton
LSU Tiger Josh (1) - Iliad

With 9 alive it takes 5 to lynch.

To those that only came into the game recently, please re-read (I know it's a bother, I wouldn't do it) but it would keep you up to date with everything that's happened.

Iliad wrote:LSU was investigated but he could be godfather. If he is then' we're in afor a treat
purge LSU

Godfathers come up as a different role.

The1exile wrote:

Iliad wrote:LSU was investigated but he could be godfather. If he is then' we're in afor a treat
purge LSU

Godfathers come up as a different role.

Depends on the mod.

From games I've played if a godfather is investigated he shows up as town. I dunno what skittles does. Actually could you tell us if you get the role or just alignment? I dunno if you've already said this but it would be helpful somewhat.

Oh and sry if I confused anyone but when I said dom I really meant syz. I forgot that he was replaced.

Honestly iliad, I was bandwagoning on you. But I had a good reason IMO. dom and koes are submarining but the haven't done anything scummy. You on the otherhand are voting for a semi-confirmed townie. the chance of LSU being the godfather is definitely there. I even said so myself. But it is a small enough chance that we can let it go right now. What struck me as odd was the fact that you chose to vote him based on only the off chance he would be the godfather instead of voting one of the people you stated as scummy (me for bandwagoning and koes for submarining)

I had a legit reason for voting you in my eyes. And unless you can convince me otherwise, you seem like the best choice.

kwanton wrote:

The1exile wrote:

Iliad wrote:LSU was investigated but he could be godfather. If he is then' we're in afor a treat
purge LSU

Godfathers come up as a different role.

Depends on the mod.

From games I've played if a godfather is investigated he shows up as town. I dunno what skittles does. Actually could you tell us if you get the role or just alignment? I dunno if you've already said this but it would be helpful somewhat.

Oh and sry if I confused anyone but when I said dom I really meant syz. I forgot that he was replaced.

Honestly iliad, I was bandwagoning on you. But I had a good reason IMO. dom and koes are submarining but the haven't done anything scummy. You on the otherhand are voting for a semi-confirmed townie. the chance of LSU being the godfather is definitely there. I even said so myself. But it is a small enough chance that we can let it go right now. What struck me as odd was the fact that you chose to vote him based on only the off chance he would be the godfather instead of voting one of the people you stated as scummy (me for bandwagoning and koes for submarining)

I had a legit reason for voting you in my eyes. And unless you can convince me otherwise, you seem like the best choice.

Exile can get roles if I remember correctly from his investigation of GA as he stated that he wouldn't state GA's role unless ga wanted him to. Exile as such would be aware of strange happenings within this game.

I am not submarining, I am busy, as announced in other threads. As for my supposed scummyness, look at my vote for Kalishnikov: it was based on him lying about the marine win condition, which I know.

McSnipe wrote:Vote: Illiad

cue laughter.

kwanton wrote:

McSnipe wrote:Vote: Illiad

cue laughter.

<voicetimbre="Nelson">haa-haa!</voicetimbre>

Vote iliad


Looks to me like mcsnipe knows hes dead and is trying to clear his scum buddy by appearing to vote for him. A noobish and lame cheater tactic nonetheless. If mcsnipe thought he was still alive he would have posted more often until suddenly now and would have given a reason too.