Busted SD -robertleo, ky-wc, bmw2021[ES]

[Donelladan]

Accused:

robertleo
ky-wc
bmw2021



The accused are suspected of:

Conducting Secret Diplomacy - ( actually a bit more than just secret diplomacy, they blatantly team up from the beginning of the game, in many games, and probably would keep doing so, just so that robertleo got a higher score).

I hope they aren't simply blocked from playing each other but actually get kicked like multi's.


robertleoand ky-wc played 36 games together. robertleo won 35 of them
34 of those games they played togehter where multiplayers games with 4 or more players.
2 of them were double where ky-wc was opposant and lost.

That's an amazing win % for robertleo.

bmw2021 and ky-wc played 19 games together. For 8 of them robertleo was playing too and he won all of them
The remaining 11 games that bmw2012 and ky-wc played together were all multiplayers games. ky-wc won 2 of them, and bmw2012 won 9 of them. 100% wins for them.

Also note that in all those games, the 3 accused joined one after another.

I am putting only couples of games, I can provide more evidence if necessary but I think that should be enough.


1st Example of robertleo and ky-wc cheating.

The first multiplayer game that roberleo and ky-wc played together is :

Game 14804099

This game show very suspicious moves by ky-wc and robertleo. I am going to explain the whole log for that one, after I'll make it shorter.


First attack of the game, ky-wc goes out from Portugues to Dutch

show

roberleo follow him from Mapuch to ducth

show

yellow ( jurisnik, 3rd player, was on Dutch) counter roberleo

show

Then both accused player attack yellow, without attacking each other

show

Then red and yellow fight each other elsewere.

robertleo and ky-wc have borders in Mapuche/Dutch, but then ky-wc decide to attack red ( osvajalec ) and robertleo does the same.

show

No chat explaining why they don't attack each other. They see each other but both decide to go through neutral region to attack a 3rd player.
At this point it could still be smart play, though a bit weird seeing as both player are extremely agressive but not against each other.

Then ky-wc eliminate red and attack yellow too. Robertleo start attacking ky-wc.
ky-wc doesn't retaliate against robertleo but keep attacking yellow and eliminate him.

See :

show

Just after ky-wc eliminated yellow, he then start to attack NEUTRALS :

show

Those attack against neutrals have no sensible explanation, especially since he was able to attack robertleo. For example he took dutch 2 and dutch 3, while robertleo ( last remaiming player) is actually on mapuch, thus those attacks don't make any sense. ky-wc is actually suiciding his troops against neutrals so that robertleo eliminate him easily.

Then they "pretend" to fight for a few turns.


2nd example of robertleo and ky-wc cheating.

Game 16175220

Elimination summary from that game is already self-explanatory

2015-12-12 20:38:57 - ky-wc eliminated wimdevilder from the game in round - 1
2015-12-12 23:45:39 - robertleo eliminated properbo77777 from the game in round - 1
2015-12-13 03:16:55 - ky-wc eliminated tommyko from the game in round - 1
2015-12-13 19:04:23 - robertleo eliminated ky-wc from the game in round - 1

They eliminate everyone then robertleo eliminate ky-wc.

Last turn of ky-wc :

show

He deploys 10 troops but he put 2's everywhere, rather than making the only logical thing, deploy all to attack the only remaining player at the time : robertleo.
I am assuming he took alps from Corsica succeeding a 2vs1, he was actually making 2vs1 everywhere to suicide.



3rd example of robertleo and ky-wc cheating.

Game 15274251

Again they attack every other players but each other. At the end ky-wc sit idle while roberleo wins the game.

2015-02-11 03:34:12 - ssj4stefv2 was kicked out for missing too many turns in round - 1
2015-02-15 00:05:23 - robertleo eliminated meno71 from the game in round - 1
2015-02-15 00:48:57 - ky-wc eliminated madmom from the game in round - 1
2015-02-15 02:52:55 - robertleo eliminated ky-wc from the game in round - 1

Examples of bmw2021and ky-wc cheating.


Those are 3 players games.

Game 17998569 won by ky-wc
Game 17998570 won by bmw2021

well just going through the log for a second is enough to see that they are very obviously cheating.

Red has no bonus, both have tons of bonus, but they both attack red :

Game 17998569

show

Same in this one
Game 17998570

show

[Lord Arioch]

And thats how u file a report!

[riskllama]

tl ; dr

[Evil Semp]

Taking a look at this.

[Mad777]

And thats how u file a report!

Indeed, pretty impressive !

[Evil Semp]

I have BUSTED the accused. It looks to me that these accounts started out by different people that robertleo has taken over ownership of all three accounts.

[MagnusGreeol]

I have BUSTED the accused. It looks to me that these accounts started out by different people that robertleo has taken over ownership of all three accounts.

Nice work Don & Semp!

Cleaning up CC's streets! '')>

[Evil Semp]

I have BUSTED the accused. It looks to me that these accounts started out by different people that robertleo has taken over ownership of all three accounts.

Nice work Don & Semp!

Cleaning up CC's streets! '')>

Don gets the credit for this. I just needed to be sure that that I thought he took over the other accounts.