Re: The Hobbit Mafia [Day 5 - The enemy is coming]
Posted: Thu Nov 09, 2017 2:55 pm
madmitch wrote:I am calling bullshit,I DON;T GIVE A f*ck ABOUT YOUR SO CALLED GIFTS, PROVE IT , WHO DID YOU USE THEM ON?
Prove it?!?!? Is there not enough validation and re-validation going around that convinces you I'm town?
It's you who claimed "I am town and will PROVE it if needed." Yeah, I'm calling you out on it because a backup doc can't prove anything until he's lynched. If you are telling the truth, you are VT until a vacancy opens up. Even when you become the new doc, how would you prove to the rest of us that you are town?... Perhaps on the next day you'd say something like "I protected Thor and he's still alive so that proves I'm town"??? That's what is bullshit. There's no way for you to prove you are town and your claim that you could is either a lie or very poor judgement.
So, that's what you did to bring suspicion upon yourself. Now that you've responded to my "nagging," you've claimed backup doc... which you've been hinting at for a while. Perhaps in a game of 16, a backup doc makes sense... but this game also has a Jailer & an inventor who can give out a one-shot protection... So, a backup doctor sounds a bit overkill to me (4 roles with protection powers of some sort!!!). This mixed with the fact that after 4 nights, there is no solid evidence that a doctor has protected anyone. It's possible, and perhaps even likely, but it's also possible that with a Jailer and an inventor with access to mithril, LoVo felt a pure doc wasn't needed. Even if he did... would he feel the need for a backup doctor too??? Sure, it's possible, but your "I will prove it if needed" statement doesn't jive with your claim at all.
Thorthoth wrote:Question for MudPuppy: So you gave a gift of elven rope to KamakaziJawa on just a hunch that you thought he was town, right? If so, it was a good hunch... and it seems like it should have been enough slow Samlen's hand... KJ never got to use that piece of sting either... unless he could use it the night he was killed?
Yes, at the time (N2), I had a pretty solid town read on KJ largely due to a now forgotten comment he made during the day. But he would have been my #1 scum target today if he were still alive so I am in full agreement with Samlen's choice of targets last night. Not saying I don't have my doubts about his claim but Samlen's choice of targets has nothing to do with any doubts I have.