[Official] Team CC Mafia [Finished]

[Hank44Soccer]

@jonty: I know what you mean. I also have difficulty picking the scum out in this large of a game.

Is this the first thing I've done right in this game?

other than voting for scummy Metsfanmax?

[DoomYoshi]

Again, I'm not trying to start a bandwagon against safari. I do think he didn't explain well why he immediately thought cult recruiter when there was only an implication of a third party, but for all I know that's just because that's how it works in most mafia games. However, assuming he is indeed the experienced mafia player that he claims to be, I really doubt that if he is part of a cult, he would make such an obvious mistake and give that away on page one, which is why I'm not pursuing the case.

I'm not sure safari jumped immediately to cult recruiter. I think it is certainly interesting that that is the part of his fairly lenghty post that you picked up on. However, I cannot vote you for the same reason that you are voting saf. That would be ironic at best, hypocritical at worst.

The second half of your argument borders on WIFOM. Maybe it is an interesting cult that wins by dying? I am not saying that it is likely but that there are a lot of possibilities and he can be playing exactly like you expect him not to.

FOS metsfanmax

@jonty again: it's difficult to define right.I make a lot of mistakes. In general, keep in mind that the goal of the mafia is to spread confusion and bounce around the place. The goal of us townies is to figure out who scum is.

[Metsfanmax]

May I remind you that this is the entire content of the "fairly lengthy" post?

vote Hank44Soccer until he decides that posting more than once per mafia day is acceptable. Seriously.

Also, just looking at the scene, I think there's a possible cult recruiter out there.

...

Could be McGill, could be the FW peeps, but we should definitely be aware of this.

So yeah, I'm pretty sure he did immediately jump to cult recruiter, as in fact this was his first post in the thread.

[DoomYoshi]

May I remind you that this is the entire content of the "fairly lengthy" post?

vote Hank44Soccer until he decides that posting more than once per mafia day is acceptable. Seriously.

Also, just looking at the scene, I think there's a possible cult recruiter out there.

...

Could be McGill, could be the FW peeps, but we should definitely be aware of this.

So yeah, I'm pretty sure he did immediately jump to cult recruiter, as in fact this was his first post in the thread.

Oh yes, my bad. I was looking at his explanation of roles post. I see what you mean.

[jonty125]

FOS safari based on these last two posts.

[shieldgenerator7]

I agree with jonty. Vote Safariguy

[jonty125]

unvote vote: safariguy5 not for the 1st time.

[Metsfanmax]

Unvote

Vote Hank44Soccer who seems to have had a strange vendetta against me from the beginning.

[shieldgenerator7]

Mets, hank only thought you were suspicious for voting the mod (you gotta admit, that was kind of cheesy).

[Metsfanmax]

Mets, hank only thought you were suspicious for voting the mod (you gotta admit, that was kind of cheesy).

Right, and we were still in the jokevoting part at that time. But we're well past that phase now, and he's still making comments like

Is this the first thing I've done right in this game?

other than voting for scummy Metsfanmax?

[firth4eva]

Originally I had voted since I was suspicious. The only reason I hadn't unvoted yet was because I didn't have a better candidate yet. And just to mess with saf also. The second vote can hardly be called bandwagoning. Although I am leaning towards an unvote as I see Hank is actually playing like he normally does.

Last night, I was extremely tired but unable to sleep. I'm sorry if my vote for Hank didn't make a lot of sense - I am having trouble justifying it to myself even.

@jonty: I know what you mean. I also have difficulty picking the scum out in this large of a game.

what? blatant contradiction?
WHAT?! scummy as hell!

fos jonty fos shield, vote staying on yoshi though but if we're still at a point of no lynch at the deadline I would not mind lynching either of these

[firth4eva]

Players

# Haggis McMutton
# Victor Sullivan
# Bleed_Green.
# Gilligan
# commander9
# jrh_cardinal
# Pancakemix

Then again, my suspiscions are not worth much with this many players not posting for so long. Anyone else think they should be prodded?

[DoomYoshi]

Yes, they should be prodded. I don't even know who Bleed or jrh are... which shows how much they are active;)

What is the blatant contradiction? The reason I hadn't unvoted safariguy before I did was that I had yet to have a better candidate. The only reason I haven't unvoted Hank yet is that I still do not have a better candidate. If it will make you happy unvote.

As for messing with saf, he was explaining to me that the whole point of voting is to get them to roleclaim, so I responded by keeping my vote on him to force him to roleclaim. It was a joke. Not a particularly funny one, but a joke nonetheless.

[Hank44Soccer]

Mets, hank only thought you were suspicious for voting the mod (you gotta admit, that was kind of cheesy).

Right, and we were still in the jokevoting part at that time. But we're well past that phase now, and he's still making comments like

Is this the first thing I've done right in this game?

other than voting for scummy Metsfanmax?

Yah Sorry for being out of hand Vote SafariGuy5

[Victor Sullivan]

Psh, prodded... I don't need to be prodded...

Frankly, the cases on both safariguy and hank seem good. I'll unvote for now and think about who I believe is more scummy.

[pancakemix]

Players

# Pancakemix

Then again, my suspiscions are not worth much with this many players not posting for so long. Anyone else think they should be prodded?

lolwut?

[firth4eva]

You hadn't posted since page 7 at least.

[safariguy5]

So let me get this straight, the bandwagon on me is for a perceived belief that I picked up on the possible cult aspect and therefore I'm the recruiter? This is a WIFOM argument, plain and simple. Maybe, since I'm not the cult recruiter, I'd point it out because it's too obvious if I was. But then, if I was the cult recruiter, maybe I'd point it out so you all don't think I am the cult recruiter. Circular reasoning at its best.

I agree with jonty. Vote Safariguy

unvote vote: safariguy5 not for the 1st time.

I'm going to unvote, vote shieldgenerator for bandwagoning and Fos jonty for doing the same. Seriously, the "case" on me has no logical grounding, and given the way the day scene was written and the size of the game, having some sort of cult element is not out of the realm of possibility.

[Haggis_McMutton]

The case on safari is ridiculous.

An experienced player gets a cult leader role so his first act is to interpret a debatable sentence in the scene as evidence of the existence of a cult? Do you guys realize how silly that sounds? Everyone on his bandwagon is suspicious imo.

Out of those shield pops up, because of this statement:

I agree with jonty. Vote Safariguy

This in response to:

FOS safari based on these last two posts.

which is in response to

May I remind you that this is the entire content of the "fairly lengthy" post?

vote Hank44Soccer until he decides that posting more than once per mafia day is acceptable. Seriously.

Also, just looking at the scene, I think there's a possible cult recruiter out there.

...

Could be McGill, could be the FW peeps, but we should definitely be aware of this.

So yeah, I'm pretty sure he did immediately jump to cult recruiter, as in fact this was his first post in the thread.

Oh yes, my bad. I was looking at his explanation of roles post. I see what you mean.

You had already voted for safari specifically because of that exact post.

vote Hank44Soccer until he decides that posting more than once per mafia day is acceptable. Seriously.

Also, just looking at the scene, I think there's a possible cult recruiter out there.

Day 1

Andy looked out over his new dominion... All felt, well just right. What they didn't know was that AndyDufresne was a more than apt name for him, as a convict he had decided to take a new walk of life, and decided that he liked it. He liked the Power of Red and he wanted more. He supposed the other reason was that Lack had a thing for Peanut Butter and with his nut allergy it just wasnt working, Bananas on the Menu!!!

Clapper PMed him his usual briefing report, her ride to Red had been pretty slick as well, all slick and ready to go, except for that pesky Lackattack and TheSaxlad causing the usual bother, also I've heard reports of another group, but nothing too big, we'll crush them easily. All Of them. Andy sat back, he couldn't remember it ever being this good.

On the other hand Lack and his Team were preparing for that day, "script?" Check. "Cybergun?" Check. "Fake Banana?" "No but ive got this thing that..."

Day 1 Begin!

Could be McGill, could be the FW peeps, but we should definitely be aware of this.

I think you picked up on that especially because you're one of them. Unvote Vote safari

This leaves you 2 options for your reaction:

1. You voted safari the first time without actually reading his post and only read it now, which means you were just looking for an easy lynch.
2. You reiterate your suspicion of safari based on exactly NO new evidence, and are therefore just trying to get any lynch you can while clumsily trying to appear active.

Also, this is more speculative, but the fact that shield would say he agrees with such a weak post by janti + the fact that both of them are new and might make such an obvious slip might mean they actually have linked roles.

Anyway vote shield

[pancakemix]

You hadn't posted since page 7 at least.

Timestamps. That's only a day without posting. Lynch me for going a day without posting.

[jimfinn]

Mets, hank only thought you were suspicious for voting the mod (you gotta admit, that was kind of cheesy).

Right, and we were still in the jokevoting part at that time. But we're well past that phase now, and he's still making comments like

Is this the first thing I've done right in this game?

other than voting for scummy Metsfanmax?

Yah Sorry for being out of hand Vote SafariGuy5

Seriously? Seriously? WOW!!! Saying you were out of hand, and then voting who you think others want you to vote for is Wishy-Washy or Sheeping at least, possibly even allowing yourself to be led for the sake of fitting in, and certainly reeks of trying too hard to find and avoid mistakes/scumtells.

unvote, vote hank44soccer

[safariguy5]

Can we get a vote count? And prod/replace the inactives.

[Rodion]

Haggis' post convinced me there's something fishy going on with shield's behavior.

Shield, I won't be hasty and vote yet because I don't want to see a wagon rise and kill a possible townie, so I'll wait for your next post (which should be your defense vs. Haggis' post). If you don't do a damn fine job of convincing me, I'll vote on you.

[Bleed_Green]

Sorry I have been so swamped at work that I am really getting behind in this game,, I am recalling my joke for saf and hopefully in the next couple will catch up full. I have skimmed through and there are some pretty interesting reads so UNVOTE

[Streaker]

It seems firth is a little overprotective of hank here.

That's one way to get the game going right there. Demanding to start hunting, pointing a player out on a joke vote (ZING!) only to post like 6 or 7 completely meaningless posts straight after. You gotta know what you want, dude. Either you stay in joke vote fase, or you get serious. But don't call people out on joking around when you won't contribute anything yourself. ZING!

This argument is weak at best. It's day one, and hank looks more like he's joking around than trying to waste time in order to benefit the mafia. This doesnt warrant a vote though. So hank, start getting serious. Streaker unvote.

I understand my case isn't very strong, but it is also Day 1. It's free for you to get hank moving, it's completely wrong for you to dictate MY moves. Why would you order me to unvote? I will consider unvoting if hank actually makes a defense, not before that. He seems to be ignoring my post.

Streaker, you have me convinced. To be honest, I had stopped believing the arguments for saf a while ago. I was just staying on him so he would reclaim, which is what he suggested I do . Just stop with the ZING please. Or at least be more careful where you aim that thing.

unvote vote hank

Bandwagoning again? Admitting to voting someone despite not being suspiscious of them(I know it's day one but there is a clear issue on whether it is suspiscious that safari pointed it out)?

unvote vote yoshi

And again with the defense of hank.

In support of my case on hank, here are his latest posts.

@jonty: I know what you mean. I also have difficulty picking the scum out in this large of a game.

Is this the first thing I've done right in this game?

other than voting for scummy Metsfanmax?

Yah Sorry for being out of hand Vote SafariGuy5

So after I called him out on his reluctance of building cases, while he asked himself to get the game going, this is what he gives us. My VOTE will stay with hank, for all these reasons until he gives a proper defense.

FoS firth for not only protecting hank, but telling me what to do.


In other news:

Sorry I have been so swamped at work that I am really getting behind in this game,, I am recalling my joke for saf and hopefully in the next couple will catch up full. I have skimmed through and there are some pretty interesting reads so UNVOTE

Bleed green shows up, admitting to skim the game. FoS Bleed

I'm gonna need to reread the interaction between shield and josty, something is off between those 2.