Yo Ho, A Pirate's Life! [2/16] Endgame: Pirates Win!

[jak111]

sorry for double post but sully you better do a full claim before they lynch you i think your at l1 and mafia could say it was a mistake so clear up your role for us

Spartacus, unless you have some evidence on Sully's town role. What if the parrot wasn't on from the start? You're assuming he was. Also no one counter claimed the cabin boy, so I assume he is the cabin boy, eh?

[SPARTACUS1974]

he may well be cabin boy but on the same as your saying he could be scum eh? cabin boy doing mutiny
on the first night he got blocked so we still have no real evidence that he is town all im saying is that untill cabin boy is checked out and sully gives full claim lets not dive in for the lynch

[TeeGee]

Thanks to all the well wishers, the flood threat to me has now passed and all is good... there is lots of catching up to do, not just here but also in RL.. but luckily here night falls soon and i will read and re-read, then give my thoughts in the morning (day 3). i just had a quick skim, but as yet am not willing to say what i think as I want to be sure before i open my mouth

[soundman]

Vote Count:

SPARTACUS1974
isaiah40
thehippo8
Victor Sullivan - jonty, isaiah, jak - (L4)
Some7hingCLEVER
TeeGee
new guy1
ghostly447
DoomYoshi
kiwi3 - Neb - (L6)
jak111
jonty125 - clever - (L6)
Nebuchadnezer

With 13 alive it takes 7 to walk the plank.

Day ends with no one walking the plank.

[soundman]

Ship's Log, July 18th, 1712
Today be an odd day. There be some fighting among the crew but fore we could send someone to Davy Jones the sun went down. I pray we survive the night...

It is now Night Two. Please send in your night actions.

[isaiah40]

*Yawn!! Good night everyone*

[soundman]

Ship's Log, July 19th, 1712

Two separate gunshots when off last night. This morn we found one of the local people we had pressed into service laying in a pool of blood. He was holding a knife in his hand and looked to have been on his way back from the crew's quarters. We found the other body by another crew member that looked to have taken a knife wound. The wound had been cleaned and bandaged, but the one who saved him was dead from a bullet in the back of the head.

Jonty - Pirate Victim (Serial Killer) - Was killed
Kiwi - Boatswain (JOAT) - Was killed

It is now Day Three!

[jak111]

Alright Isiah. Start speaking before we make you swim with the fishes today!

[Victor Sullivan]

Weeeeee! I mean, *brawk!*

-Sully

[thehippo8]

backswain te borrogarh the serial killer is swimming with the fishes!!

Bugger the Joat is gone ..,. time to point fingers!!

[ghostly447]

I need role claims of 2 players. But first, VS, I assume you have a power role? If so, what did you get from last night?

[isaiah40]

I need role claims of 2 players. But first, VS, I assume you have a power role? If so, what did you get from last night?

I tracked Sully, and boy was it a boring night he didn't go anywhere or visit anyone!

[ghostly447]

Isaiah, you are lying unless the watcher only gets to see 1 person who visited.

I claim Watcher, Ship Rigger.

I watched CM5 night 1, and knew Leehar visited. I stayed low on D2 to avoid being NK'ed. Last night I watch Mr. Victor Sullivan, and New guy1 is the one who visited him. I suspect New guy1 to be mafia (based on what Sully says he got, etc) and I beleive Isaiah to be third party, or a terrible town player.

So, Sully, claim. New guy1, claim. FOS Isaiah and I will prepare to vote the scummiest of you guys.

[ghostly447]

Sorry Isaiah, forget what I said about you, I am not sure I would see the tracker???

Lol. Forgot your claim, etc, So now its narrowed to VS and NG1.

[DoomYoshi]

Sorry Isaiah, forget what I said about you, I am not sure I would see the tracker???

Lol. Forgot your claim, etc, So now its narrowed to VS and NG1.

Why wouldn't you see the tracker?

Also, if nearly half the town wanted VS to claim yesterday but he didn't, what makes you think you can just demand a claim? From him or from new guy? Victor isn't dead, so you can't say that new guy is likely to be mafia or whatever. Quite frankly it's none of your business what either of their roles are.

Also, I am just trying to figure out if there is a mafia roleblocker. Did you block me last night clever? If so, why?

If not, we need to keep our eyes out for a mafia roleblocker.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Sorry Isaiah, forget what I said about you, I am not sure I would see the tracker???

Lol. Forgot your claim, etc, So now its narrowed to VS and NG1.

Why wouldn't you see the tracker?

Also, if nearly half the town wanted VS to claim yesterday but he didn't, what makes you think you can just demand a claim? From him or from new guy? Victor isn't dead, so you can't say that new guy is likely to be mafia or whatever. Quite frankly it's none of your business what either of their roles are.

Also, I am just trying to figure out if there is a mafia roleblocker. Did you block me last night clever? If so, why?

If not, we need to keep our eyes out for a mafia roleblocker.

ya i think not seeing someone while watching is a ninja role

[new guy1]

I will not claim on a whim of yours. There is no logical reason for you to believe that I am mafia. Why would you think im mafia if VS isnt dead. What support do you have to go off of that anything I did affected him last night?

Fastposted- ninja role? Lol

[Some7hingCLEVER]

I will not claim on a whim of yours. There is no logical reason for you to believe that I am mafia. Why would you think im mafia if VS isnt dead. What support do you have to go off of that anything I did affected him last night?

Fastposted- ninja role? Lol

uh you could have visited him for
mafia tracker
mafia watcher
mafia cop
mafia roleblocker
so ya there is a logical reason

and the ninja role is in the power roles game

[ghostly447]

Sorry Isaiah, forget what I said about you, I am not sure I would see the tracker???

Lol. Forgot your claim, etc, So now its narrowed to VS and NG1.

Why wouldn't you see the tracker?

Also, if nearly half the town wanted VS to claim yesterday but he didn't, what makes you think you can just demand a claim? From him or from new guy? Victor isn't dead, so you can't say that new guy is likely to be mafia or whatever. Quite frankly it's none of your business what either of their roles are.

Also, I am just trying to figure out if there is a mafia roleblocker. Did you block me last night clever? If so, why?

If not, we need to keep our eyes out for a mafia roleblocker.

Thank you for connecting yourself to NG1, and also confirming my beliefs. Let me explain.

Power Roles mafia, I am currently being connected to 2 other players so with this strong of a hint I think I can connect you two.

Hers the thing. Tracker is watching the suspect. If they were visible, wouldnt the mafia shoot them? It is my belief that the watcher cant see the tracker, and vise versa. THEREFORE, I would not have see Isaiah. NOW (hold on, its going to be a bumpy ride), you are claiming to have been RoleBlocked. VS soft claimed a power role somewhere (I believe he said he WASNT a VT. Correct me if Im wrong). SO, it is my belief we have a mafia roleblocker, and townie one (CLEVER claimed it and may have blocked you last night. CLEVER, correct me if I am wrong). Therefore, it leaves one more to have blocked sully from going anywhere last night. I claimed Watcher, so that leaves one more visitor last night. NG1.

IF VS, is a power role, and got role blocked last night, we need only test 1 of 2 claims being true. Ng1 versus CLEVER for the roleblocker claim. One is lying, and if it is NG1, then I immediately connect you to him for giving off such a strong defense for him that it is nearly impossible to deny you 2 are connected.

Get it?

[Some7hingCLEVER]

ya i did block doomyoshi

[ghostly447]

ya i did block doomyoshi

So all we need is confirmation that VS is in fact a power role (VS, claim your role if you are going to claim a power role to see if you get CC).

So if that happens, then NG1 is suspect number 1, DoomYoshi suspect number 2.

[new guy1]

I can agree with your case strongly. I will highly think about claiming, though it is unlikely unless VS claims to be a powerrole (dont want to claim unless completly nessessary). As for connecting me to Doom, he obviously doesnt think im scummy. You cannot connect us like that when hes just talking about someone who he doesnt think is scum, total crap there.

Fast posted by cluster f*ck (x3)

Clever, he also asked why.

[DoomYoshi]

ya i did block doomyoshi

So all we need is confirmation that VS is in fact a power role (VS, claim your role if you are going to claim a power role to see if you get CC).

So if that happens, then NG1 is suspect number 1, DoomYoshi suspect number 2.

So I am suspect number 2 for what reason?

If VS is a power role, why wouldn't he already have said that he was roleblocked?

[ghostly447]

ya i did block doomyoshi

So all we need is confirmation that VS is in fact a power role (VS, claim your role if you are going to claim a power role to see if you get CC).

So if that happens, then NG1 is suspect number 1, DoomYoshi suspect number 2.

So I am suspect number 2 for what reason?

If VS is a power role, why wouldn't he already have said that he was roleblocked?

Well because you defended ng the second he was accused. Plus I do not beloeve there was a Mafia kill was there? 2 Mafia left by my guess and if mg role blocked VA and clever blocked you that means you are both Mafia.

[DoomYoshi]

I defended him right away because I was online right away.

What makes you think there was no mafia kill last night?

Your leaps of logic are astronomical in their girth.