LOST Mafia - Day 5 - cena-rules abducted!

[Anarkistsdream]

I think mandy was away the last few days but I think theres enough pressure on him now for him to talk to us. I don't think his silence is actually scummy to be honest, more that hes just been busy. If he doesn't respond soon a mod prod may be in order

Prodded

[jnd94]

I still think its suspicious that he's posted in all the other threads, but completely ignores this one

Tons of people do that. Lynching would be a waste of a lynch.

[gimpyThewonder]

speaking for myself i voted mandy to get him to participate. If he's sick then that'd be why he's not responded. if he is indeed ACTIVE on other threads then there is more to his silence. Active is the key word, a stray post doesn't really count.

get well soon buddy, if indeed you are sick

[Ditocoaf]

I just thought I'd repost this comment of mine, since I really have nothing new to say, but I want to revive this thought.

anyway, I'm refraining from voting Mando for now, since I'm usually against voting people for just submarining. If they're town, they could become active later, and we'd have lost a potential asset. I'm waiting until someone incriminates themself.

[nagerous]

I think Jnd94 ought to be replaced, seeing as he NEVER contributes in any game ever and won't this time round either...

[nagerous]

If he's posting though, its fine

Just annoyed right now..

[Anarkistsdream]

I think Jnd94 ought to be replaced, seeing as he NEVER contributes in any game ever and won't this time round either...

DID YOU HEAR THAT JND!!!??? CONTRIBUTE!

[cena-rules]

so who shall we lynch?

[Anarkistsdream]

*YAWN*

[pmchugh]

Ok i re-read the entire thread looking for scum and guees who i think it is? yeah still William18, here is why...

Vote Gimpy


No, lynching people at random doesn't benifet the town.

First he gets on the Gimpy bandwagon, he was the third person on it and the person that changed it from a few half joking votes into a real bandwagon.

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT!

(2) animorpherv1 - LSU Tiger Josh, jnd94
(7) Gimpythewonder - Lord Voldemort, rebelman, william18, animoprherv1, dittoeevee8888, ditocoaf, Sentinel XIV
(1) Mandalorian2298 - Fircoal
(1) ditocoaf - cena-rules
(1) cmckinney - pmchugh
(1) Fircoal - Mandalorian2298


With 21 alive it takes 11 to lynch!

here is the gimpy banwagon at its greatest, as said before the first two were random/jokes, then william, then the next two or three are relatively new players, sentinal is a strange one fos there.

and despite being active after the next 4 votes came in, he did not unvote unlike Lovo and rebel did when they came back, he did not unvote until it became clear that the bandwagon was dead and nothing would happen there.

Do you have any idea of what the names of the pridomenant "Others" are.

FOS: Everyone who was naming possible scum roles
"oh hey lets give the scum faction a list of names not to claim so they can blend in."

I think this is what william is doing, not everyone who was naming others was doing it for this reason, but it was william that started it and as i previously pointed out kept trying to come off as the good samaritan.

I say we lynch possible deadbeaters.

here is the start of his wanting to lynch deadbeaters/ submariners note he isnt just wanting them to come out and start talking but actually lynch them and that makes it completely random whether they are town or scum so why would you want to kill them, what if they return and have a pro-town power role.

No it must not, then everyone will vote me, and I want to survive a little bit, I might tell on day 3 or higher, so keep me around, and I'll tell you then.

I bet it's SK.

Now animo is beggining to drop major scum tells and william bets he is an SK why is this? because he is scum and therefore does not think that amino is, since he is acting like he can kill people and isnt pro-town he must be an SK.

For those of you that dont know.

Juliet is a pregnancy doctor, she was brought to the island by the others and joined their ranks. Ben loved her and put Goodwin in a place where he knew goodwin would be killed because she was having a relationship with him. She was the one who spoke to jack when he was kidnapped, she loves jack, jack loves kate but is settling for juliet. Juliet is left behind by the others and goes off with the townies as a spy, she is meant to mark the tents of the pregnant women so they can be abducted she betrays the others and many of them die because of it.

it seems as if she is a traitor to the others, but he also has the power to revive them from the dead, which seems a bit of a contradiction to me, animo do you have to use this power?

Seems more like a traitor to me. Does this role only limit you to revive mafia or can you revive town. I bet their is something in his win condition that ties into the revival thing. Perhaps conciquences will happen if he doesn't revive so that what I think he means by I want to revive mafia. But then again you could revive the Godfather, which is really bad.

Vote Animorph
This ability is too dangerous to keep alive.

read the red bits he says i think he is a traitor of some sorts, then votes for him, he also wants to know if he can revive town i.e. if he is a threat.

Mando is pretty quite back there.

subtle hint ot try start a bandwagon without being on it.

Vote Mando


He is submarining. And one thing I learned, submariners arn't good for the town.

as it doesnt take off the way he wanted it too he votes to try start the wagon rolling. and about what he said what if the submariners come back and have good pro-town roles?

Why are you insisting on voting me when everyone is trying to get info. Or are you just trying to not vote your scum buddy mando.

here he is trying get more people to bandwagon mando and failing that deflect attention off of himself and onto me.

All of that confirms my gut feeling, unvote vote william18

[cena-rules]

makes sense

vote will

[Ditocoaf]

Hmm. I see what you're saying, definite FoS on Will. But so far it seems like a lot of it is just out-there speculation, so I'm going to wait for Will's reply first. All together, it adds up to being pretty suspicions, though.

[mandalorian2298]

I think mandy was away the last few days but I think theres enough pressure on him now for him to talk to us. I don't think his silence is actually scummy to be honest, more that hes just been busy. If he doesn't respond soon a mod prod may be in order

Prodded

Prodded I have been. Sorry for not participating guys, but I had a drinking engagement. Since 27 pages are more then enough room for someone to slip up, I plan to deliver you a scum in between 1/2 and 1 hour (I have to re-read).

[Neoteny]

I think mandy was away the last few days but I think theres enough pressure on him now for him to talk to us. I don't think his silence is actually scummy to be honest, more that hes just been busy. If he doesn't respond soon a mod prod may be in order

Prodded

Prodded I have been. Sorry for not participating guys, but I had a drinking engagement. Since 27 pages are more then enough room for someone to slip up, I plan to deliver you a scum in between 1/2 and 1 hour (I have to re-read).

Psh, and we all thought you were sick...

I retract my pity...

[nagerous]

Prodded

Prodded I have been. Sorry for not participating guys, but I had a drinking engagement. Since 27 pages are more then enough room for someone to slip up, I plan to deliver you a scum in between 1/2 and 1 hour (I have to re-read).

Psh, and we all thought you were sick...

I retract my pity...

QFT

Also, I think pmchugh makes a strong argument against William here.

Unvote Vote William.

[Neoteny]

What the hell. Let's hear from him.

Unvote: Vote Will

[mandalorian2298]

Bah a lot of apples, not many candies. Still, here are my top three candidates:

1)Ditcoaf

is there a nooby we can bandwagon and move on to day 2? i'm just saying...

Yeah, I'm sure you'd love to waste the first lynch and start with night. FoS gimpy

A wasted lynch is a terrible thing. Ditcoaf obvoiusly plans to think long and hard before deciding whom to lynch...

GIMPY'S QUOTE ABOUTE LYNCHING NEWBS (I had to write it this way because of the Quote-in-qoute rule)

Yeah, I'm sure you'd love to waste the first lynch and start with night. FoS gimpy

this one or animorph

vote titocaf

Whew, thank god that's not me!

Big Fos on Cena for going with gimpy's idea right after it's been made clear that it's NOT a very pro-town plan. But since there's already more votes on gimpy, vote gimpy.

Then again, he might jump on the first bandwagon to save himself time. What I find particulary scummy in this post is the notion that Cena should be Fosed for going against public oppinion. Observe that Ditcoaf's argument for voting Gimpy and not Cena is "because he has more votes on him". Looks like bandwagoning to me.

pmc- It's odd, I'm a doc with and ABILITY on the mafia side. I see if you want to vote we know.

oh my god, did someone just blatently admit to being a power role, and pro-mafia?

Vote Animorpherv1.

C'mon. No asking "Why would a Scumster claim to be Scum?", no "What could this possibly mean?", just plain old "Oh look, a guy who isn't on the list of my scumbuddies can be lynched, yay! Lets kill him quick!"

2) William - Actualy Hugh's case against him seems pretty solid, but I would like to add something I found before:

Vote Gimpy


No, lynching people at random doesn't benifet the town.

A noble, pro-town rection to Gimpy's joke...

I say we lynch possible deadbeaters.

is contradicted with his next post.

3) Ditto

vote Gimpy

Well, 12 people haven't voted yet.

Well, now 11 (or less if I've missed anybody since this quote)

It's not like he's a scummy submarriner. Look, he joned a bandwagon!


So, that's all that I have for now. Unvote Vote Ditcoaf, since he seems like the best bet to me at this moment.

[Ditocoaf]

I don't think I contradicted myself at all. Gimpy wanted to lynch someone without care as to whether they were town or not. I thought that was suspicious, but I held out to see if others thought so as well, since I'm new and prone to mistakes of judgment. Others agreed that it was a bad thing for gimpy to say, so I voted him. There's a difference between voting someone on no suspicion, and voting on the only lead you have.

And if you had played with Ani in any other games, you wouldn't suspect him of playing on a deeper level. Knowing Animorpherv, the only possible explanation for that post was that he had slipped up-- he isn't anywhere near good enough to purposely lead us to thinking he had slipped up.

What I find interesting is that all of your Fingers of Suspicion are in defense of Gimpy.

[gimpyThewonder]

What I find interesting is that all of your Fingers of Suspicion are in defense of Gimpy.

So what you are suggesting is that Mandy and myself are allied? Then why would I vot Mandy and start what turned into a mini-wagon (through no fault of my own ) on him. The reason he's bringing those people up is b/c there were surely some scum that hopped onto that early wagon w/ no basis for real voting. FOS on that one ditocoaf, me think he dost protest too much.

[dittoeevee8888]

It's not like he's a scummy submarriner. Look, he joned a bandwagon!

I'm a girl, so I would prefer if you call me "she" instead of "he"

[Ditocoaf]

What I find interesting is that all of your Fingers of Suspicion are in defense of Gimpy.

So what you are suggesting is that Mandy and myself are allied? Then why would I vot Mandy and start what turned into a mini-wagon (through no fault of my own ) on him.

True; the fact that you voted on him when there was no bandwagon does debunk that. It was an observation, one that I now see is a coincidence. Note that I did not even FoS on that.

The reason he's bringing those people up is b/c there were surely some scum that hopped onto that early wagon w/ no basis for real voting. FOS on that one ditocoaf, me think he dost protest too much.

Right, because townies should like being accused.

[mandalorian2298]

In regard to Ditcoaf: Please don't confuse my voting for him with my being sure that he is scum (which is usualy the case, even if I'm wrong ). His initial posts were just the scummiest of the lot.

It's not like he's a scummy submarriner. Look, he joned a bandwagon!

I'm a girl, so I would prefer if you call me "she" instead of "he"

Another post-without-saying-anything. Unvote vote Ditto because SHE is exibiting tipical I-must-post-something-but-scummers-are-my-friends behaviour.

[pmchugh]

In regard to Ditcoaf: Please don't confuse my voting for him with my being sure that he is scum (which is usualy the case, even if I'm wrong ). His initial posts were just the scummiest of the lot.

It's not like he's a scummy submarriner. Look, he joned a bandwagon!

I'm a girl, so I would prefer if you call me "she" instead of "he"

Another post-without-saying-anything. Unvote vote Ditto because SHE is exibiting tipical I-must-post-something-but-scummers-are-my-friends behaviour.

She does seem a litlle scummy but it may just be noobness.

[cmckinney]

I'm suspicious of both Ditto and William. William has been seriously vote hopping and i think that he should really explain himself. Very scummy William
Vote William

[Anarkistsdream]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT!


(4) Mandalorian2298 - Fircoal, GimpytheWonder, William18,rebelman
(1) Ditocoaf - Mandalorian2298
(5)William18-pmchugh, cena-rules, nagerous, neoteny, CMCKinney

With 20 Alive it takes 11 to lynch!


Mandalorian, quit voting and then unvoting to vote them again... One vote will suffice.