aage wrote:I have two remarks.
Personally I believe that Jak was the one casting the vote, therefore we should assume Jak's alignment is what matters.
Secondly, Jak, you struck VioIet off the list immediately. Why?
Because of what she said, I can only assume she has a near same pm as I for win condition, etc. I didn't mention what it said when she said it and she was dead on with a few things changed as to not copy role pm. So hence, she is more cleared in my mind for now.
chapcrap wrote:All that matters is whether or not we need to include VS in the list. My inclination is no because he isn't the one who voted.
This is my train of thought as well, I believe Victor's vote whether he's non town or not would not show up because I used his vote.
Very little going on since I last posted, but I will address JG, I'm busy, I spend the time I got posting or sending in actions if it's night time. I was looking at the wrong list (multiple tabs with two games open) and sent in the wrong name without thinking later about it until the day started and I was told he wasn't in the game so I would not receive his vote.
Then you ask why I take myself off of it? Why not? I know I am clear to myself and if I were anti town I wouldn't be as open as I've been so far, you've played with me long enough to know that.
The biggest worry I have at the moment is Chap's results being tampered with or being flawed in some way. However it seems like a reasonably balanced role that is only effective with multiple results (like trying to narrow down who is scum).
If we have a protection role, I suggest they be on Chap and we go for a lynch today. It will either FORCE scum to group up again or start weeding out people. For example.
We narrowed it down to 10 people (9 for my gut feeling), 4 of which are non town in the lynch. Now tomorrow we get to find out how many either stayed or retracted. For example, say tomorrow we find only 2 non town in the lynch with roughly the same people on the list. We can effectively then conclude that two of the people NOT in the lynch that was in the lynch D2 are in face scum. Now, if they work together and try to have 4 in it again, we can start semi-clearing town off as they are not on the lynch and not part of the four non town.
Either way, we either get the few stragglers trying to avoid it, or the group huddled together trying to avoid being found as a straggler. Interesting eh?