/ wrote:If you all want to see what's behind the mask, just ask, I warn you though... The ladies tend to swoon.
Well, time to get serious, or as serious as I can be. Which isn't very much.
Jonty isn't the top of my list for scumminess, but at least we've got a nice chain to unweave once we've woven this tangled web we surf. Wait, chains are links right? Well then we'll find the missing link once we click the weak link that breaks the chain. Yeah, that makes sense, nailed it!
Anyways, unvote vote jonty
I think we should hold off on more until we're sure that there aren't a bunch of roles that mess with votes or something.
/ wrote:If you all want to see what's behind the mask, just ask, I warn you though... The ladies tend to swoon.
Well, time to get serious, or as serious as I can be. Which isn't very much.
Jonty isn't the top of my list for scumminess, but at least we've got a nice chain to unweave once we've woven this tangled web we surf. Wait, chains are links right? Well then we'll find the missing link once we click the weak link that breaks the chain. Yeah, that makes sense, nailed it!
Anyways, unvote vote jonty
I think we should hold off on more until we're sure that there aren't a bunch of roles that mess with votes or something.
Irony. Except jonty hadn't claimed yet.
Makes me think you are scum.
vote /
It's an interesting curiousity but I dont find it very vote worthy and I feel more comfortable lookimg into possible connections from yesterday.
Beyond that. *Happy dance*
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
Very interesting. I'm quite sure I'll be pretty high on the list of people to look at, given that Jonty was scum. Boy did I make a bad choice to unvote him.
Hooray, two scum down, though I wasnt in the original, so I dont know if we're almost done or not. Dont know why Aage posted "boom" as night started, so I would like to start there and question, why?
Nebuchadnezer wrote:Very interesting. I'm quite sure I'll be pretty high on the list of people to look at, given that Jonty was scum. Boy did I make a bad choice to unvote him.
I cant promise I wont ultimately believe you are scum overall by your play but I stick to my opinion that Edoc and Aage's case about the no lynch comment was witch hunt bullshit.
That being said, you could always try finding a worthwhile case yorself.
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
Interesting. Mafia roleblocker dead already. Does anyone think follow the cop could work at this moment? Or are there still anti town roles that can put a spanner in the works?
safariguy5 wrote:Interesting. Mafia roleblocker dead already. Does anyone think follow the cop could work at this moment? Or are there still anti town roles that can put a spanner in the works?
safariguy5 wrote:Interesting. Mafia roleblocker dead already. Does anyone think follow the cop could work at this moment? Or are there still anti town roles that can put a spanner in the works?
Well, here's my question: Is Haymitch Abernathy some type of bulletproof, or "reflector"? The scene makes it sound like Draven's attack was reflected back at him. Not only is this useful, but Haymitch is most likely a town role (yes, he could be 3rd party, as well). What do we do with this? Anything? Given that mafia knows who he is, they shouldn't attack him anymore...but now town is in the dark as to who this confirmed "non-mafia" person is. I guess there is the chance that Haymitch was just the target of someone using their "reflection" power on him, and is therefore still vulnerable. However, it might be useful to put town on the same information footing at mafia at this point...
It has me confused.
And yes, I could make a case, and most likely will, but after my failed attempt yesterday, I'm a little gun shy. I will wait to hear what everyone has to say.
safariguy5 wrote:Interesting. Mafia roleblocker dead already. Does anyone think follow the cop could work at this moment? Or are there still anti town roles that can put a spanner in the works?
Busdriver.
Possibility. Of course it will screw with the results, but this depends on the busdriver actually targeting the person the cop is targeting. Which given the large numbers, is a bit unlikely at this point. But it's a valid point, too many unknowns to consider that now.
safariguy5 wrote:Interesting. Mafia roleblocker dead already. Does anyone think follow the cop could work at this moment? Or are there still anti town roles that can put a spanner in the works?
Why would you bring this up when there hasn't been a cop claim yet? We don't even know if there is a cop at all.
safariguy5 wrote:Interesting. Mafia roleblocker dead already. Does anyone think follow the cop could work at this moment? Or are there still anti town roles that can put a spanner in the works?
Busdriver.
Possibility. Of course it will screw with the results, but this depends on the busdriver actually targeting the person the cop is targeting. Which given the large numbers, is a bit unlikely at this point. But it's a valid point, too many unknowns to consider that now.
I'm more worried about the doc save getting thrown out and having a dead cop next day. Iy's day two and I see no reason to call for a cop claim yet.
This is mere speculation though. I'm pretty sure scum has more aces up their sleeve.
The'boom' referred to a mafia lynch, obviously.
Also, more town info, someone gave me god powers last night, thanks for that whoever you are. From the mod's pm there was no reason to distrust the godpower so I used it, because it let me do my action twice. Not going to disclose anything else, but thought I should mention this.
safariguy5 wrote:Interesting. Mafia roleblocker dead already. Does anyone think follow the cop could work at this moment? Or are there still anti town roles that can put a spanner in the works?
Busdriver.
Possibility. Of course it will screw with the results, but this depends on the busdriver actually targeting the person the cop is targeting. Which given the large numbers, is a bit unlikely at this point. But it's a valid point, too many unknowns to consider that now.
I'm more worried about the doc save getting thrown out and having a dead cop next day. Iy's day two and I see no reason to call for a cop claim yet.
This is mere speculation though. I'm pretty sure scum has more aces up their sleeve.
The'boom' referred to a mafia lynch, obviously.
Also, more town info, someone gave me god powers last night, thanks for that whoever you are. From the mod's pm there was no reason to distrust the godpower so I used it, because it let me do my action twice. Not going to disclose anything else, but thought I should mention this.
So we may have a doubler of sorts or maybe it is just a one night thing. If anyone else gets a notification, I would assume speak up, that way we know its not just an out of the blue thing and we may be able to work it to our advantage. Also, thanks for clearing up the boom thing, I was wondering if it was a bomb effect or something, then I got paranoid cause I thought maybe the first person to mention it got killed and a bunch of other stuff.
/ wrote:If you all want to see what's behind the mask, just ask, I warn you though... The ladies tend to swoon.
Well, time to get serious, or as serious as I can be. Which isn't very much.
Jonty isn't the top of my list for scumminess, but at least we've got a nice chain to unweave once we've woven this tangled web we surf. Wait, chains are links right? Well then we'll find the missing link once we click the weak link that breaks the chain. Yeah, that makes sense, nailed it!
Anyways, unvote vote jonty
I think we should hold off on more until we're sure that there aren't a bunch of roles that mess with votes or something.
Irony. Except jonty hadn't claimed yet.
Makes me think you are scum.
vote /
Meh... It's just standard procedure; if you don't know if there are secret votes, you don't get too close to l-1 Just like if you don't know if your car's going to explode, you always open the door with your less needed hand.
Anyways, on to the main course.
Crazy unfortunately didn't give us much to go one, he pretty much laid low, but was among the seven who didn't vote against Jonty.
The others I will now give my professional psychological analysis of.
Diagnosis: Technically did vote jonty, and that clears him of AAAAALLLL SUSPICION ; LISTEN TO ME AS I DISTRACT YOU WITH BRAINWASHING! *Ahem* I mean, Voted jonty early, before any bandwagon formed. All further posts are lazy jokes and lazy character speculation. Was sure to bring up the fact that he was still technically voting jonty (albeit for weak reasons back in the joke vote stage).
Diagnosis: Desire to pursue the jonty case early on offset by the fact that he was the strongest arguer against jonty's lynch. On the other other hand, my suspicion is allayed by the fact that he enjoys my posts.
Diagnosis: Seems to subtly inject doubt into the jonty case, as well as possibly steering the conversation aside to the Neb V. Aage matter.
Treatment: Further investigation required.
So yeah, to break character back into my character, and then break it again to reach the real world, I'm going to say that Sheep makes me the most suspicious at the moment, followed by safari, and a small gut feeling for DJ.
I'll look at the folks that did vote for jonty later, but don't expect a big post. I will say that as a continuation of my thoughts yesterday, I feel that edoc and aage are acting oddly. Logically I shouldn't be as suspicious as I am now that I've seen that jonty's alignment was, but I still have a gut feeling for some reason.
PS: WTF; why is everyone trying to rolefish on a confirmed mafia target?
Diagnosis: Seems to subtly inject doubt into the jonty case, as well as possibly steering the conversation aside to the Neb V. Aage matter.
Treatment: Further investigation required.
So yeah, to break character back into my character, and then break it again to reach the real world, I'm going to say that Sheep makes me the most suspicious at the moment, followed by safari, and a small gut feeling for DJ.
I'll look at the folks that did vote for jonty later, but don't expect a big post. I will say that as a continuation of my thoughts yesterday, I feel that edoc and aage are acting oddly. Logically I shouldn't be as suspicious as I am now that I've seen that jonty's alignment was, but I still have a gut feeling for some reason.
PS: WTF; why is everyone trying to rolefish on a confirmed mafia target?
This is a great analysis. Of your analysis, I think DJ struck me as the oddest. Why? Well, yes, I got off on the wrong tangent against aage. Trying to dig for something that may have not been there, and perhaps was a little OMGUS-y. However, DJ does seem to seize on my diversion and support it. Was he seriously thinking that aage was being scummy, or was he just trying to continue the diversion of attention from Jonty that I started?
As to the rolefishing...I don't think we are rolefishing, as much as we are trying to just clear Haymitch. Mafia already knows who Haymitch is, so what's the difference if the rest of the town knows who he is? I don't think we need his role or how he avoided death...but it would be nice to know who he is so town has the same info as mafia.
I'm not sure everyone has checked in, but...FOS DJfireside
Although I believe Haymitch (if he is in the game) to be town, I would like to throw in that he could possibly be third party as well just for speculation.
new guy1 wrote:Although I believe Haymitch (if he is in the game) to be town, I would like to throw in that he could possibly be third party as well just for speculation.
Why would he not be in the game?
I believe John Watson's middle name was Haymich or something like it so there's a clue. Since scum targeted him, he is not scum. Neb already said it, the only ones in the dark about this guy are Town. Now, claiming needn't necessarily help so if he doesnt want to, thats okay and i'll just rule out some people who probably aren't him, but the other way is easier.
Also, I was going to try and leada lynch on him once he claimed because all of this is sketchy... But in all likelihood this guy is town and we may want to keep him alive.
I believe Haymitch to be the gift giver as stated earlier with the god power based on the Hunger Games trilogy, Haymitch is the coach who fights to get gifts for katniss.
As for your synapsis /, I agree with most of it, the more I thought about it at the end, the very nature of his role was not good and should have accounted for it. I got wrapped into the fact of proving it and when Neb changed gears it threw me for a loop so I followed it. I wasnt trying to divert it.
I had suspicions on Neb from yesterday but cant find anything other than what was stated so will just have to wait on see and look elsewhere.
Djfireside wrote:I believe Haymitch to be the gift giver as stated earlier with the god power based on the Hunger Games trilogy, Haymitch is the coach who fights to get gifts for katniss.
You know, I love the series, and I didn't even think of that! Very good possibility. (Although you may have gave away what role Haymitch is to the maffers).
aage wrote:
new guy1 wrote:Although I believe Haymitch (if he is in the game) to be town, I would like to throw in that he could possibly be third party as well just for speculation.
Why would he not be in the game?
That's a good question. I believe he is, due to the fact (For those of you who haven't read Catching Fire) that Haymitch killed someone like this when he was in the 50th Hunger Games.
Side note: I'm going on vacation until the 4th. Don't know if I will have interweb access.
Game 1675072 2018-08-09 16:02:06 - Mageplunka69: its jamaica map and TFO that keep me on this site
However, are we 100% sure there isn't another third party? Keeping Haymitch secret is a good way to discourage a possible third party on making a kill.
However, are we 100% sure there isn't another third party? Keeping Haymitch secret is a good way to discourage a possible third party on making a kill.
We haven't encountered a third party..? So what do you mean by "Another third party"? It sounds like you know who a third party is... or you are one.
Game 1675072 2018-08-09 16:02:06 - Mageplunka69: its jamaica map and TFO that keep me on this site
So what do you mean by "Another third party"? It sounds like you know who a third party is... or you are one.
