LOST Mafia - Day 5 - cena-rules abducted!

[rebelman]

[Anarkistsdream]

DAY 3 Begins!

The morning dawns brightly...

As the survivors of flight 815 rise and begin their morning routine, they notice that someone is missing!

SENTINEL XIV - Unknown - Unknown has been abducted during the night! There are no clues as to his whereabouts or who he really was.

With 17 alive it takes NINE to lynch!

[cena-rules]

well desmond is here

i got LSU as town so Im laying a vote nag

and also a fos lsu

[pmchugh]

well desmond is here

i got LSU as town so Im laying a vote nag

and also a fos lsu

I get the LSU part, but why are you voting nag have you already investigated him? I cant remember anything except that he claimed doc and some people didnt believe him despite no counter claims.

[cena-rules]

well desmond is here

i got LSU as town so Im laying a vote nag

and also a fos lsu

I get the LSU part, but why are you voting nag have you already investigated him? I cant remember anything except that he claimed doc and some people didnt believe him despite no counter claims.

he was my night 1 investigation. Got very pissed then claimed jack. But if I got LSU as town and mandy was town and they are both on the boat they must be the same surely???

[pmchugh]

well desmond is here

i got LSU as town so Im laying a vote nag

and also a fos lsu

I get the LSU part, but why are you voting nag have you already investigated him? I cant remember anything except that he claimed doc and some people didnt believe him despite no counter claims.

he was my night 1 investigation. Got very pissed then claimed jack. But if I got LSU as town and mandy was town and they are both on the boat they must be the same surely???

ah im with you now, you investigated nag and got him as scum, we think LSU is town because of madalorian, you got him as town making you a sane cop. Makes sense to me although im still not sure about him as there was no counter claim for a character that is obviously in this game. for now though:

unvote vote nag

[nagerous]

Vote LSU


Let's hear your claim then?

Ya can lynch your doc if you want but as I said no-one has countered me.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

What the hell. I had volunteered my lynch on Day #4 after I had gotten masonship for all on the helicoptor, but some of you idiots insisted on hammering him yesterday (PMC and GT) even after CMC and I pointed out that we were together. Cena then decides to waste his investigation on me despite the fact that Mandy's death should've been a VERY BIG clue as to my alignment (FOS Cenafor that waste of an investigation already and then Nag wants to put the pressure on me when he is the one under question. SUPER FOS Nag for thistryign to shift the attention off of him.

[cena-rules]

What the hell. I had volunteered my lynch on Day #4 after I had gotten masonship for all on the helicoptor, but some of you idiots insisted on hammering him yesterday (PMC and GT) even after CMC and I pointed out that we were together. Cena then decides to waste his investigation on me despite the fact that Mandy's death should've been a VERY BIG clue as to my alignment (FOS Cenafor that waste of an investigation already and then Nag wants to put the pressure on me when he is the one under question. SUPER FOS Nag for thistryign to shift the attention off of him.

I didnt waste it it was to see what type of cop I am. I appear to be a sane cop

[nagerous]

What the hell. I had volunteered my lynch on Day #4 after I had gotten masonship for all on the helicoptor, but some of you idiots insisted on hammering him yesterday (PMC and GT) even after CMC and I pointed out that we were together. Cena then decides to waste his investigation on me despite the fact that Mandy's death should've been a VERY BIG clue as to my alignment (FOS Cenafor that waste of an investigation already and then Nag wants to put the pressure on me when he is the one under question. SUPER FOS Nag for thistryign to shift the attention off of him.

I didnt waste it it was to see what type of cop I am. I appear to be a sane cop

LSU is lying or your a random cop.

[nagerous]

Either that or your a lyncher, does anyone know if cena's character had a grudge against mine at all?

[Ditocoaf]

Either that or your a lyncher, does anyone know if cena's character had a grudge against mine at all?

You're claiming Jack, right? and cena is apparently desomond...Desmond and Jack? No, not at all.

[pmchugh]

Jack just claim already, if you dont soon I will unvote nag and look elsewhere for scum.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Vote Nag Cena's result on me is true as I am town

[cmckinney]

I'm not sure who to believe

I'm reluctant to vote for Nag, considering he is almost confirmed as Jack.

[Ditocoaf]

Well, perhaps Jack doesn't want to come out for fear of being a target? It's impossible to really know.

There are other ways of telling whether nag is scum. The way he behaved around the time cena posted his role pm makes me believe that he is scum. He essentially gave up, until he suddenly came back using a completely new line of defense. This, along with the probability that cena is a sane cop, is why I now vote nag.

[pmchugh]

Well, perhaps Jack doesn't want to come out for fear of being a target? It's impossible to really know.

There are other ways of telling whether nag is scum. The way he behaved around the time cena posted his role pm makes me believe that he is scum. He essentially gave up, until he suddenly came back using a completely new line of defense. This, along with the probability that cena is a sane cop, is why I now vote nag.

unvote we need a counter claim to be sure. Jack dont be afraid to claim, if nag is lying its worth it.

[/]

Perhaps Jack has been.... Kidnapped!

[dittoeevee8888]

Perhaps Jack has been.... Kidnapped!

But how could he be? Sentinel claimed that s/he was a watcher, there would be no need to lie from watcher to Jack because then we would have lynched nag yesterday then...

[cmckinney]

Perhaps Jack has been.... Kidnapped!

We would know. The only person who's been kidnapped is Sentinel, and he's not Jack.

[/]

I guess, but no one wants to claim doc this early, I was just kidding, but this whole situation is very very fishy.
what I also find strange is the fact that our claimed doc here wasn't taken instead of sentinel, heck there's a gold mine of great claimed pro-town roles here, why take the watcher? (unless they are the only one who can be trusted enough to confirm who's scum today.)

[gimpyThewonder]

vote Nag

the logic is there. Nag gets accused by a cop. Cop is 100% role confirmed. Nag throws a fit and says he's taking his toys and going home, he doesn't want to play anymore. Later comes back w/ the line of defense that is sure to out the real Jack when s/he counter-claims (some of us ak Jack to stay hidden a bit longer to not fall into the trap). We now have confirmation that the cop is getting correct results as LSU is confirmed town like we said yesterday.

The only reason to NOT vote Nag is if you are scum or if another cop got a different result. As conventional wisdom goes the next step is to lynch the cops "not town" target to further confirm the role. I don't think Nag is Jack, I never have. He shouldn't be allowed to slip the noose yet another day

[cmckinney]

I think that if someone had the role of Jack, and someone else claimed they were Jack, they would have spoken up.

[gimpyThewonder]

I think that if someone had the role of Jack, and someone else claimed they were Jack, they would have spoken up.

not if they were playing smart

[cmckinney]

I'm gonna go back and read through that whole little scene.