Moderator: Community Team
jiminski wrote:Ray Rider wrote:Hound wrote:Based on the ratings I'm seeing, the average seems to be around 4.6 or 4.7 and that's mostly because we have two camps, those that rate 5 unless you do something asinine and those that use 3 unless you deviate either good or bad.
Exactly; and the combination of those to systems has skewed the ratings. I was all in favor of this new feedback system when it was in the works, but now that we have it, I see that there are some fairly major problems with it.
you would just never be happy with whatever system!
suggs wrote:lt.pie wrote:i love the medal idea but im friggin sick of pm"s from players who don"t like the ratings i left them
Yes, but they are completely separate. Keep the medals/gimmicks, and ditch the ratings.
Isn't it a completely random, inexplicable co=incidence how there are all these server problems since the new system was put in place? Most unfortunate
zimmah wrote:JoshyBoy wrote:zimmah wrote:i gave this person all 3's (like most of the other players i meet) and this is his reply:DARCOGOAL wrote:zimmah why did you rate me with 3 stars to all? ok it's your rate but attendance 3? why ? have i missed any turn? i don't think! in fact i doubt that there is a single player in CC who has lost just a round so far and this in my first freestyle game!!!!!
i told him, 3 stars is just fine for a normal player and he said:DARCOGOAL wrote:what a bad humor! never mind though! hope not meeting you again!
But yeah come on zimmah! 3 out of 5! Thats giving somebody 60 percent in a test. When the person did everything 100 percent correct you know... i tend to say good luck, chat, and say good game all in my games so that deserves 5 stars for attitude... as much as some one who says gl and gg at the beginning and end of a game and do NOTHING wrong. An overall rating of 3 stars is quite hurtful to some folk when they havent even put a foot wrong
my opinion.. lol which i'm entitled to as everyone is
dude, 3 out of 5 is fucking average average means good enough! 3 is perfectly fine. so live with it. complain and you'll get a 2 the next game for attitude
nearly everyone says good luck, dosn't deserve a 3 in my opinion, as long as they don't do anything out of the ordinairy they don't disserve a 5, it's not even the mods intention to hand of 5 all arround, go read it everywhere on the forum. you should not expect all 5's especially not from me
btw, why does everyone says good luck, but nearly noone sais have fun? about a few years ago on every online game i played everyone said at least 'GLHF' (good luck + have fun. now all you get is 'gl'. i thought a game was still supposed to be fun also? i don't consider anyone wishing you luck AND fun, an above average attitude, let alone an excellent player.
remember:
3 is the standard, if you do nothing to improve it, you'll stay at 3, if you do something good (and not something everyone does like saying gl, gg, or not missing turns, since everyone does that anyway, that's what you're kinda supposed to do) then you'll get a 4, if you do really good, you get a 5 even.
likewise if you do something bad like missing turns or being rude, you'll get a 2, and if you do something really bad you'll even get a 1.
it's as simple as that. a 3 just means you wasn't impressive. nothing wrong with that. if you want a better rating try to impress me first.
drunkmonkey wrote:I honestly wonder why anyone becomes a mod on this site. You're the whiniest bunch of players imaginable.
Ron Burgundy wrote:Why don't you go back to your home on Whore Island?
marpesia wrote:Okay, so maybe I'm new, or slow, but where do the medals appear when you receive them?
AndyDufresne wrote:We hear you guys, don't worry. Stay tuned and perhaps we can craft a system that fits everyone's needs and wants.
--Andy
Magiw wrote:Nice suggestion Blitz, should toss it in the suggestion section so it doesn't get lost in the mud.
Four20 wrote:thanks for nothing punk. Nice ratings ya leave me bitch, i'll smoke your ass anytime in this game. You suck
Four20 wrote:my fairplay, attendance and attitude were excellent, f*ck you
Mr_Adams wrote:Four20 wrote:thanks for nothing punk. Nice ratings ya leave me bitch, i'll smoke your ass anytime in this game. You suck
This is what I get for leaving somebody 11/15 stars. This is why the new rating system sucks.
and thenFour20 wrote:my fairplay, attendance and attitude were excellent, f*ck you
AndyDufresne wrote:We hear you guys, don't worry. Stay tuned and perhaps we can craft a system that fits everyone's needs and wants.
--Andy
Trouserpants wrote:Wow, I got my first retaliatory rating today for anyone who thought the system disallowed it. The guy obviously knew I wasn't happy with him and that I was going to rate him lowly, so he whacked me with 1 stars all round pre-emptivly. I did nothing wrong in the game. Brilliant.
bayou wrote:This just gives the ability for a player pissed off because you beat him to rate you low without having to explain it.
And we have no chance of calling the player on it because there is no place for feedback.
Return to Announcement Archives
Users browsing this forum: No registered users