Funkyterrance wrote:3.Yes, if you choose to continue to live there.
4." "
5.Yes, if you willingly lived there up until you were drafted.
For 3. you wrote that it is a voluntary exchange if you choose to continue to live there. But in the US if you said "I don't want to pay these taxes so I'm leaving". Leave you do to another country, but due to the way the US runs it's tax code, by
citizenship and not by residency, even if you leave you are still required to file tax returns. Because you are a US citizen. You'll pay the taxes of the nation you live and still be required to give the US it's "fair share". Even if you don't live there.
You could give up your citizenship, but you'll pay the fees and could face an expatriation tax. Not to mention you'd have to lie about
why you are giving up your citizenship. If you state that you are giving it up because you don't want to pay the taxes provided in the example, which you state is voluntary
so long as you can leave, then you'll find yourself charged, arrested and imprisoned for tax evasion.
That French actor, if he'd tried that stuff in the US he'd have been charged with tax evasion and tossed straight into prison.
And you still think it's voluntary?
Same applies to #4.
In #5, if you were born a US citizen and on your first day of life you and your family move to Mexico or somewhere else and you stay an American citizen and never return, within 30 days of your 18th birthday you are still required to register for the draft and you can still be drafted if the draft was ever enacted. Even though you'd spent but a single day of your life in the US, you'd still be drafted. Leaving the country doesn't matter, you must also renounce your citizenship. refusal to register for the US selective service is punishable by up to 5 years in prison and up to $250K in fines. No one has been charged with dodging the draft since the 80's though, being in another country you'd probably get away with it but if an actual draft ever came around it'd be a different story.
The draft is a heavy thing, you are probably too young to remember, but it was a huge problem for the Vietnam war. Some were convicted of actual draft dodging, but it was a touchy thing for the government. They couldn't crack down too hard or else they'd turn the citizens against the nation.
Being forced to be inducted into the military, given a rifle, shipped to the other side of the world and told to risk your life when you never actually volunteered is anything but voluntary. It's laughable that you say "Yes, if you willing choose to live there till then" when it doesn't even matter if you don't live here, if you are a US citizen then you are required to register and can be drafted, even if you don't live here.
The government understands that a draft isn't voluntary, that's why it's called a draft. That's why the penalties for not reisgering for the Selective services is so severe. You won't go to prison most likely if you don't register, but there are other consequences for not registering that display the involuntary nature of the arrangement. If you don't register you won't ever be eligible for Federal Student loans, Federal assistance and virtually ever Federal program and service that you will still have to pay taxes to fund, but won't ever be eligible to receive.
Your naive notion of simply moving some where else would change the nature of these involuntary exchanges is funny. The American citizen is economic property of the United States. There is no doubt about that fact unless you choose not to see it. Doesn't change the fact, though, that the US citizen is a cow and Big Brother is the farmer.