Moderator: Cartographers
Evil DIMwit wrote:putting together a shortlist just three entries long from a wide open field of three entries.
Victor Sullivan wrote:C is alright and fairly unique, but I'm not convinced the palaces are in evenly guarded spots.
MrBenn wrote:Victor Sullivan wrote:C is alright and fairly unique, but I'm not convinced the palaces are in evenly guarded spots.
All the maps have identical gameplay :-/
MrBenn wrote:Map B: The bonuses are too difficult to work out from the colour-bar. Either similar values need to have similar colours, or you need to find a clearer way of matching the area to a square.
dolomite13 wrote:As for the bonuses I think Sully is right and I noticed that the west africa area on the sample map doesn't have a territory marked to start neutral like all other territories. To make it so there can be no bonus drop at all one of those should start neutral.
Entrant C wrote:Donethere is a main square in each city, and the city names are all short, I would suggest renaming each "Main Square" by the city name. For example, "Tayt Square", "Aery Square", etc. That way, the cities would be easier to tell apart but you wouldn't have to find room somewhere else in the city to "label" itFixedin the legend, "The palace can be assaulted only through the main square of the city where the building" is not a complete sentenceOkfor a title, how about something along the lines of "Middle Ages"?sky and labels addedmay benefit from a sky-ish feel to it? It would be nice to have each village/town named somehow.FixedShould Tower F be connected to Tower E? Also, I agree that each city should have its name on the map, not just in the legend, so people don't have to keep looking back and forth. Particularly colorblind people.Fixedit doesn't make sense that markets on the other side of the map attack each other. Why not catapults, alchemists or evil witches instead?but the graphics look like they come out of some sort of fantasy mapping software program.Everything is freehand drawn. I also have sketches if there are any doubts.it looks like it was created from a pro-fantasy type app
Evil DIMwit wrote:Entrant C would also like to ask: Are the bonuses easier to understand with different colors for houses? Does the community like the colored houses? Is the text in the legend readable?
Evil DIMwit wrote:Entrant C would also like to ask: Are the bonuses easier to understand with different colors for houses? Does the community like the colored houses? Is the text in the legend readable?
Users browsing this forum: No registered users