Moderator: Community Team
/ wrote:One think about the character Ra's al Ghul, does anyone who has played the game think he's likely to be "town" regardless of role?
jonty125 wrote:This seems a straight Town vs. Mafia game.
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
spiesr wrote:So, I haven't weighed in for a while now, so I will drop by and post again. I am still in favor of lynching Gillipig today, and nothing that has been mentioned since then really changes anything. We also seem to be stalling out here, so maybe we need to just get it over with already?
Hey lord voldemort, what is the status of replacing Illiad and doing whatever with the other inactives?
spiesr wrote:So, I haven't weighed in for a while now, so I will drop by and post again. I am still in favor of lynching Gillipig today, and nothing that has been mentioned since then really changes anything. We also seem to be stalling out here, so maybe we need to just get it over with already?
Hey lord voldemort, what is the status of replacing Illiad and doing whatever with the other inactives?
What do we have to lose? Well, if we don't end up lynching anyone today then we have basically wasted it, again. Exactly how bad of a thing that would be depends on how likely you think it is that Gillipig is scum. If you really think he is town, then yeah not lynching him today isn't so bad, just a day where nothing was accomplished, but nothing was lost either. If you really think he is scum then not lynching him today looks like a really stupid decision, we through a bunch of our resources to confirm something that wasn't that hard to see in the first place, we don't get anything done today, we have all these actions tied up trying to test him tonight, and he gets to use any scum powers he could have for one more night. Basically we just give the scum an extra night for no good reason. But, if you really are sure he is town I could see why you don't agree with that.betiko wrote:exactly what do we have to lose if we let gillipig a chance to prove he is town tonight? we won't get 2 people killed according to night 1.
I think you deserve a brighter spotlight today my friend.
vodean wrote:spiesr wrote:So, I haven't weighed in for a while now, so I will drop by and post again. I am still in favor of lynching Gillipig today, and nothing that has been mentioned since then really changes anything. We also seem to be stalling out here, so maybe we need to just get it over with already?
Hey lord voldemort, what is the status of replacing Illiad and doing whatever with the other inactives?
scummariner. and hypocrite?
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
spiesr wrote:So, I haven't weighed in for a while now, so I will drop by and post again. I am still in favor of lynching Gillipig today, and nothing that has been mentioned since then really changes anything. We also seem to be stalling out here, so maybe we need to just get it over with already?
Hey lord voldemort, what is the status of replacing Illiad and doing whatever with the other inactives?
aage wrote: Maybe you're right, but since we receive no handlebars from the mod I think we should get some ourselves.
edocsil wrote:Silence has more value then foolish posts.
jonty125 wrote:edocsil wrote:Silence has more value then foolish posts.
I'd rather people to post foolish posts than not posting at all.
vodean wrote:jonty125 wrote:edocsil wrote:Silence has more value then foolish posts.
I'd rather people to post foolish posts than not posting at all.
id appreciate it if people didnt make posts that are scummy beyond their meta
vodean wrote:it is true that i didnt visit anyone, however im not sure that i want to believe his claim even now... a no visit would be quite likely N1, im guessing. CM5 would not really be able to accurately fake that claim, unless he and nag are coordinating (scumbuddies, etc.). im leaving my vote, and FOSing ghostly for trying to distract us with the following:ghostly447 wrote:* ghostly's big post against Nendreel, see here if interested viewtopic.php?f=213&t=176208&p=3904013#p3903802
vodean wrote:im believing gilli's claim less and less. i realize that he is inactive for a reason right now, but its just poor timing. also, the odds of there being two trackers is incredibly low. im not sure, but i think we might want to kill him to be sure... that sounds really scummy, but im exhausted and dont have the mental energy to put it nicely. otherwise, we need to move on to another case for today. anyone have one?
vodean wrote:spiesr wrote:So, I haven't weighed in for a while now, so I will drop by and post again. I am still in favor of lynching Gillipig today, and nothing that has been mentioned since then really changes anything. We also seem to be stalling out here, so maybe we need to just get it over with already?
Hey lord voldemort, what is the status of replacing Illiad and doing whatever with the other inactives?
scummariner. and hypocrite?
Well, since I am town aligned it is in my interest to do things which help the town win. Thus, it is only in my interest to lynch Gillipig (or whomever) if I feel that person has at least decent odds of actually being scum. If I didn't think Gillipig was scum I would direct my attention elsewhere.betiko wrote:and spiesr, i understand that it's the best option for you to lynch gillipig, as you are the second player with the most vote.
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
I was considering the link with gillipig, particularly with a newbie it may be tempting to state false results that can't be disproven (known variables with scummates to back up). Working under this assumption, it would also make sense that vodean try to distance himself from having defended gillipig by promoting his lynch early instead of waiting for the inevitability of a failed result.betiko wrote: He always ends up being lynched and resulting town in the 3-4 games i've been with him. but hey, he's gotta be scum once in a while right?just a while back he used to come up mafia godfather like half the time.strike wolf wrote:Vode could be interesting. He was called out day 1 for not voting anyone and I'll admit there's some contradiction in his more recent posts. That last post can be considered a bit scummy as well. He's also tied up in Gillipig's claim which could prove interesting.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users