Dunes of Shakuras Mafia ~ Continue game in Brood War Mafia

[LSU Tiger Josh]

you know maybe I should change my vote for you since you are seeming to be overprotective of Tres. If he is scum he could very easily just reading in here and then helping decide on who to kill off at night. In fact

UNVOTE
VOTE Cola since we can learn A LOT by YOUR lynch. If you're scum then it can be safely assumed that Tres is scum to by the way he is defending him.

[Colaalone]

Trestain has had exactly 2 posts if I counted correctly since his confirmation. one was to say he didn't realize the game had started back on may 13th and then a 2nd post that day putting a fos on everyone. He has posted about 12 or so times since then in other threads with his last post being on may 17th. As such my vote stands and FOS on cola for trying to protect someone that is obviously a submariner.

2 posts per day? Sounds like he may be busy and not have time to keep up with all his mafia games at the moment. Okay, I'm not protecting anyone. Further down the line if Trestain was STILL submarining (this would require him to pop in every once in awhile and post; submarining is during from being absent) I would consider lynching him. I'm trying to show that lynching submariners on day two hurts the town.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

He has posted several times in the simpsons game and in some other threads as I looked up on his profile to see when he last posted. This game was on his 2nd page so he has been aroun even if he just hasn't posted here. I'll have a FOS on Tres, but you talked your way into my vote for defending him.

[Colaalone]

VOTE Cola[/b] since we can learn A LOT by YOUR lynch. If you're scum then it can be safely assumed that Tres is scum to by the way he is defending him.

I'm not protecting anyone; I'm stating a a believe that applies to anyone at any particular time should they happen to not participate for Days 1-3ish.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Game days have been spaced out not to mention he hasn't posted anything of substance wtih just a i didn't know the game had started yet and then fos on everyone. both scumlike behavior when coupled with not saying anything since.

[Colaalone]

but you talked your way into my vote for defending him.

And please explain to me WHY anyone would defend a mafia partner who isn't contributing at all? It would be stupid.

[Colaalone]

Game days have been spaced out not to mention he hasn't posted anything of substance wtih just a i didn't know the game had started yet and then fos on everyone. both scumlike behavior when coupled with not saying anything since.

How is that scumlike behavior? How do you know he DIDN'T know the game had started, hmm? And it wasn't a FOS against everyone, just everyone pushing against Diddle. And I would agree with that! It snowballed quick, and within 'everyone pushing against diddle' there would be without doubt at least one single mafia member (if not more)

[The1exile]

Josh, tres is inactive atm, I already tried to speak to him on msn earlier. He should be back soon enough.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

And please explain to me WHY anyone would defend a mafia partner who isn't contributing at all? It would be stupid.

I was in a game with fircoal once as scum. one player kept coming after him in a game and fircoal and i went ahead and killed him under the guise of fircoal "wouldn't be stupid enough to kill off at night someone that was obviuosly only targetting him" end result was town believed it as they did think someone was trying to frame him and we won. My point is "stupid behaviour" can sometimes be used just from the fact that it would be "too obvious" for anyone to really do it.

LSU Tiger Josh wrote:
Game days have been spaced out not to mention he hasn't posted anything of substance wtih just a i didn't know the game had started yet and then fos on everyone. both scumlike behavior when coupled with not saying anything since.


How is that scumlike behavior? How do you know he DIDN'T know the game had started, hmm? And it wasn't a FOS against everyone, just everyone pushing against Diddle. And I would agree with that! It snowballed quick, and within 'everyone pushing against diddle' there would be without doubt at least one single mafia member (if not more)

If you read what I said "coupled with not saying anything since" it is scumlike behavior. It can very easily happen not realizing a game starts but once it has then that is no longer a viable excuse. Fact tres has posted multiple times in other games and non games in the forum since May 13th. Fact of those 2 posts tres made neither was really groundshaking although I will agree that I'm sure at least one or two scum did vote in it.

[spiesr]

Oh an also, two kills?
If its a serial killer, f*ck YOU!
If its a Vig, calm down buddy. Dont take shots unless your more than 75% sure.

Xenhu was modkilled FOS Colaalone for skimming!

[LSU Tiger Josh]

edit by way of post.


last sentence should be I agree with you that i'm sure at least one scum member maybe more did vote against diddle.

[Colaalone]

Oh an also, two kills?
If its a serial killer, f*ck YOU!
If its a Vig, calm down buddy. Dont take shots unless your more than 75% sure.

Xenhu was modkilled FOS Colaalone for skimming!

Go to hell spieser lol.

[Colaalone]

I was in a game with fircoal once as scum. one player kept coming after him in a game and fircoal and i went ahead and killed him under the guise of fircoal "wouldn't be stupid enough to kill off at night someone that was obviuosly only targetting him"

THAT WAS ME IN A REALTIME GAME!

...lol


And yeah I do realize that tactic. But in this case, voting for Tres early and advocating his lynch would help me disguise myself and be trusted by most (if I were mafia). I think we have talked this subject to death... and there really isn't anymore points I can make. So yeah.

[spiesr]

24+ hours!

[autoload]

Take your Vote off Colaalone LSU...

Colaalone brings up a valid argument for why we should not be voting trestain. Normally I would FoS you for changing your vote to Colaalone for reasons of trying to start an opportunistic bandwagon, but I believe you are probably just a townie with faulty logic in this matter.

If Colaalone is scum, this would not be a reason to prove it.

[red bull]

vote spiser LETS TALK !!!

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Unvote
Vote Spiesr as I'm about to leave for a crawfislh boil and probably won't be back in time to do it later

[spiesr]

unvote
FOS redbull...
Whydid you vote for me?
FOS LSU Tiger Josh...
What is your deal?

[diddle]

a lot of fos' not much action, lets have a more productive day then last time, lets show those mafia what we're made of!

[autoload]

a lot of fos' not much action, lets have a more productive day then last time, lets show those mafia what we're made of!

Agreed. Why don't you start things off then and give us your top suspect and why...

[pancakemix]

I'm personally suspicious of LSU right now. Red bull voted to start conversation. Why would he vote for spiesr immediately after that?

[spiesr]

I think that he was bandwagoning so someone would be lynched...

[Colaalone]

I'm personally suspicious of LSU right now.

I agree. He seems a bit (as auto put it) 'oppurtunistic'

[dwightschrute]

I'm personally suspicious of LSU right now.

I agree. He seems a bit (as auto put it) 'oppurtunistic'

yea he made that vote to spiesr without any evidence

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Town needs a lynch as we failed in the first go round. Only person that I'm sure of as townie at this point is myself. Everyone else I am up in the air about and I was about to head out. Whether other people chose to join in on a vote there or not was their choice but a few people had talked about spiesr so he was the one I put the vote on.