Quentin Tarantino Mafia Night 3 (Mafia Win!)

[Haggis_McMutton]

Hm. This is only my second game here, so I'm not quite sure whether mandy is acting suspicious or if that's just they way he is.

I have to agree with ga7, I would like to hear some more from karel (and to a lesser extent Haggis) because they haven't posted that much. Maybe they're busy in rl? Or trying to lay low?

Anyways I'll reserve my vote until I hear some more, maybe from someone who knows what happened in the night.

-TG

Just not that much to say in day one(also i'm not very active during the weekends, and 5 pages of day 1 were during the weekend i think).

Anyway, 2 people killed, what do you guys think? mafia + sk?. 2 mafia's seem like too much for this, and if it's a vig, that was a pretty bad move, no?

[Army of GOD]

It was pretty stupid. It's pretty much like a first-day lynch for the vig and now we're down 3-townies and this is too small of a game for mafia, I think.

[Fircoal]

I say sk or dumb vig.

Now let's move on from things that don't matter.

[Army of GOD]

Sks are 3rd party, right? How do they win?

[edocsil]

Kill everyone!

[spurgistan]

Kill everyone!

Hmm.. moderately scummy opinion, there, ?

[edocsil]

Kill everyone!

Hmm.. moderately scummy opinion, there, ?

No, its just one of the only roles I have ever managed to win with, Sk is easily my fav role. I was just elaborating with enthusiasm on the win reqs of a typical SK

[Army of GOD]

Kill everyone!

Hmm.. moderately scummy opinion, there, ?

No, its just one of the only roles I have ever managed to win with, Sk is easily my fav role. I was just elaborating with enthusiasm on the win reqs of a typical SK

O RLY?




Where were you on the night of the first!

[edocsil]

Kill everyone!

Hmm.. moderately scummy opinion, there, ?

No, its just one of the only roles I have ever managed to win with, Sk is easily my fav role. I was just elaborating with enthusiasm on the win reqs of a typical SK

O RLY?




Where were you on the night of the first!

Hard to say, it hasn't happened yet!

"These violent delights have violent ends
And in their triumph die, like fire and powder,
Which as they kiss consume."

[safariguy5]

Inactive killed during night, no talk of modkill.

Nobody was inactive. I was late getting the night scene out because I pulled a groin muscle on Sunday playing basketball and I am in some pretty severe pain...Sorry bout the delay, I should be 100% hopefully by the end of the week.

[edocsil]

Inactive killed during night, no talk of modkill.

Nobody was inactive. I was late getting the night scene out because I pulled a groin muscle on Sunday playing basketball and I am in some pretty severe pain...Sorry bout the delay, I should be 100% hopefully by the end of the week.

Sorry, I meant someone decided to kill a player who hadn't been talking much.

[TA1LGUNN3R]

I say sk or dumb vig.

Now let's move on from things that don't matter.

I'd say whether we have an overzealous vig or sk matters a lot actually. Or are you being sarcastic?

I can't tell so FOS on Fircoal.

[Fircoal]

I say sk or dumb vig.

Now let's move on from things that don't matter.

I'd say whether we have an overzealous vig or sk matters a lot actually. Or are you being sarcastic?

I can't tell so FOS on Fircoal.

No I'm nawt, think about it, with there being two kills there are different possible ways that it could come about but at this point it does not matter. It's Day 2, we're not going to find out everything about a 16 player game then. Anything would just be speculation that we don't know. It's not like my current game which had it be 7 left on Day 2 and it's pretty important. AT this point we really need to buckle up and find scum. Discussing what setup he used wil not do that. Really it's just a shallow discussion that people can contribute to and smile because they're contributing to the "Discussion."

[karelpietertje]

Ok, just finished Jackie Brown. Great movie...different than most Tarintino films though. Only one person dead in the first hour or so! =O

I know right? I remember I enjoyed it less than the other movies... of course, I wasn't sober watching it, but w/e

@ga7, nagerous: Do you remember any game in which I was on top of it all, playing the game a 100%? No.
So that's definitely not a hint of me being mafia.

How about we go through our memory, and look at people that, after Day 1 discussion, could have been considered enemies of the victims? colton had a vote on spurgistan, aage had a vote on MeDeFe. This has to mean something.

[aage]

It probably means that whoever killed Medefe wanted you to be suspicious of me, and whoever killed colton wanted us to think Spurgistan is scum. We'd both be the noobest scum around if we were responsible for these deaths.

[ga7]

That's wifom but seeing they were mostly inactive it means one of two things:
-Very careful scum who wanted to be sure to have their kill get through
-Very noobish scum who picked randomly

Hell, I wouldn't be surprised if one was a vig kill ratting out submariners, but I guess in a game this size mafia + sk are likely.

So Karel, your defense comes down to "But I always do that!"? Well you might want to change this lousy way to play then, my vote stays. Won't give you a free pass because you're never active

[karelpietertje]

So yeah, the votes on/by the two victims last night probably say nothing.
What about the votes that got the bandwagon on Violet started? It's very likely there's scum among those who voted Violet.
Not saying everybody is suspect. Hell, I almost finished the lynch myself if somebody else hadn't been quicker. Still, I do feel some people have been pushing the lynch on Violet too much on Day 1.


@ga7: Not really a defense, just saying you don't have a proper offense. Look, I understand why you suspect me. I'm just telling you, lurking has never been part of my strategy, and nor is it now.

[safariguy5]

Vote Count

mandy(1)-aage
karelpietertje(2)-ga7, nag

With 13 alive, it take 7 to lynch.

[ga7]

Fine. If I was right I'm gonna be pissed though
Unvote

[mandalorian2298]

Well, no.

I think I'll vote the hammer of yesterday. vote mandy.

vote aage I think I'll revenge vote you until you give me me a reasoning behind that vote that doesn't look scummy. Let me help you:

a) You voted me because hammering is a a scummy thing to do since No Lynch on Day 1 is sooo good for the Town.

b) You voted me randomly because that a Day 2 random lynch is a good way for the Town to avoid all that pesky discussion.

c) You felt that not voting for anyone would make you look suspicious. (pick c) for irony)

[aage]

No, I'm utilising another argument that says "okay, let's throw something out there, see what they say". Your reaction as I see it here gives me no reason whatsoever to unvote, if I say so for myself... Very over defensive. Especially since no-one has been agreeing with me. You're doing this to get me lynched, right?

[mandalorian2298]

No, I'm utilising another argument that says "okay, let's throw something out there, see what they say". Your reaction as I see it here gives me no reason whatsoever to unvote, if I say so for myself... Very over defensive. Especially since no-one has been agreeing with me. You're doing this to get me lynched, right?

I am voting for your lynch "to get you lynched", that is correct.

[aage]

I am voting for your lynch "to get you lynched", that is correct.

I was referring to the whole "WOOT SOMEONE IS VOTING ME HELP HELP WHAT DO I DO OH I KNOW LETS MAKE A FUSS... OMG HE IS AN IDIOT ILL GIVE 3 REASONS WHY HE SHOULDNT VOTE ME AND OMGWTF HOW CAN I POSSIBLY BE SCUM OMGUS" argument, not the fact that you're voting for me. That obviously is done to get me lynched.

[aage]

I am voting for your lynch "to get you lynched", that is correct.

I was referring to the whole "WOOT SOMEONE IS VOTING ME HELP HELP WHAT DO I DO OH I KNOW LETS MAKE A FUSS... OMG HE IS AN IDIOT ILL GIVE 3 REASONS WHY HE SHOULDNT VOTE ME *** AND OMGWTF HOW CAN I POSSIBLY BE SCUM OMGUS" argument, not the fact that you're voting for me. That obviously is done to get me lynched.

Sorry, forgot something in the description. At the star, insert the following:
*** = "and let's be sarcastic and ironic and all because it'll clearly show i'm not overreacting while i actually am"
Apologies for the inconvenience.

[pmchugh]

mandy is thoroughly confusing me, I think we need to look more carefully into his early claim lol.