Sherwood Forest Mafia - Game Over, Town Wins!

[mandalorian2298]

Alrighty then. I dont understand lynching mando because he confuses some people basically. He has unearthed more lines of thought (though some are probably only to lead astray) than half hte game put together. It makes little sense to lynch him on day 1, and not find out whether or not either of his lines were actually correct. I am of the opinion that if mando is lynched, a large portion of this day 1 has been usless to the town. I can understand not lynching selin as hes claimed and theres not going to be a counterclaim on day 1. Still the bandwagon will move somewhere soon, as it has all game, and its quite possible mando gets the short end of the stick. I think that its quite possibly by their play that, Aegnor, LSU, and Guilty are all scum by the way that they have behaved. The last two arent as connected to mando, but seem like they could be a decent chance to be scum. Aegnor would tell us a fair deal about mandos scum detector. The whole, we should lynch him now because he wants to be dead before the archery contest makes little sense...because im certain he will do the town more good in day 2 than anyone else would have gotten a reprieve by having mando lynched.

Agreed. unvote
vote Aegnor

Tommorow we lynch me, regardless of Aegnor's alligment. But, if he is Scumm, them I get to talk before you lynch me

[AK_iceman]

That doesn't make sense GT.

Mandy points fingers at 2-3 people. If we lynch one of those 3 people and he turns out to be guilty, that doesn't exactly clear Mandy. If we lynch one of them and it turns out to be innocent, that doesn't clear Mandy.

Why not lynch Mandy, find out what side he's on, and that will give us a way better start for tomorrow. If Mandy's guilty we got ourselves a kill and we know that Mandy's 3 suspects are probably innocent. If Mandy's innocent, we target one of his suspects.

Mandy has specifically said that he needs to die before Day 3 to be helpful to the town. I think lynching him today will help us the most in the long run.

[pancakemix]

I agree with mandy. He's too scummy not to lynch, but we should at least test his theory first.

Vote Aegnor

Aimless, could we get a vote count?

[spinwizard]

i agree with AK

unvote
vote-mandy

[hecter]

That doesn't make sense GT.

Mandy points fingers at 2-3 people. If we lynch one of those 3 people and he turns out to be guilty, that doesn't exactly clear Mandy. If we lynch one of them and it turns out to be innocent, that doesn't clear Mandy.

Why not lynch Mandy, find out what side he's on, and that will give us a way better start for tomorrow. If Mandy's guilty we got ourselves a kill and we know that Mandy's 3 suspects are probably innocent. If Mandy's innocent, we target one of his suspects.

Mandy has specifically said that he needs to die before Day 3 to be helpful to the town. I think lynching him today will help us the most in the long run.

That makes sense, and we have no way of knowing what will actually happen when he gets to day 3. I think I'll be voting him (again).
Vote Mandy

[Aegnor]

I still think Mandy should not be lynched until we get further info and get a grasp of what his role might be. On the other hand, Selin could be scum or town just the same, only we know he's a power role.
I think lynching a power role whose allegiance is unclear will hurt the town more than it could help it. Sure, if he's mafia we got one down, but say he's a townie, we just lost a power role.

LSU's defense on the other hand is based on the "Whoever votes me is stupid". I don't buy it.

[mandalorian2298]

That doesn't make sense GT.

Mandy points fingers at 2-3 people. If we lynch one of those 3 people and he turns out to be guilty, that doesn't exactly clear Mandy. If we lynch one of them and it turns out to be innocent, that doesn't clear Mandy.

Why not lynch Mandy, find out what side he's on, and that will give us a way better start for tomorrow. If Mandy's guilty we got ourselves a kill and we know that Mandy's 3 suspects are probably innocent. If Mandy's innocent, we target one of his suspects.

Mandy has specifically said that he needs to die before Day 3 to be helpful to the town. I think lynching him today will help us the most in the long run.

Fine be that way. The 3rd scum is Ak_Iceman and the 4th one is wicked. (Asumming that Selin is the 2nd. I am only about 70% sure about Selin)

I don't belive that Narc is scum, I think he is an angry Peasant (wich is no more then you can expect from an Anarchist living in Feudalism )

[AK_iceman]

I still think Mandy should not be lynched until we get further info and get a grasp of what his role might be. On the other hand, Selin could be scum or town just the same, only we know he's a power role.
I think lynching a power role whose allegiance is unclear will hurt the town more than it could help it. Sure, if he's mafia we got one down, but say he's a townie, we just lost a power role.

LSU's defense on the other hand is based on the "Whoever votes me is stupid". I don't buy it.

Well... if Mandy would be kind enough to role-claim and explain why he needs to be lynched on Day 2 instead of Day 1, I'm all ears. He wants the mafia to night-kill him, probably to scare them away from trying.

Whats your role Mandy and what does it do?

[spinwizard]

i am suspitious of wicked and it would b interesting 2 see what haperns tonight

[Aegnor]

Mandy is clearly not helping the game, I think his character's purpose is to plant confusion and mess everyone up. He could be unaffiliated with either scum or town..

Ignoring whatever he says should be the right way to go.

[mandalorian2298]

I still think Mandy should not be lynched until we get further info and get a grasp of what his role might be. On the other hand, Selin could be scum or town just the same, only we know he's a power role.
I think lynching a power role whose allegiance is unclear will hurt the town more than it could help it. Sure, if he's mafia we got one down, but say he's a townie, we just lost a power role.

LSU's defense on the other hand is based on the "Whoever votes me is stupid". I don't buy it.

Well... if Mandy would be kind enough to role-claim and explain why he needs to be lynched on Day 2 instead of Day 1, I'm all ears. He wants the mafia to night-kill him, probably to scare them away from trying.

Whats your role Mandy and what does it do?

It doesn't matter if I am lynched on Day 1 or Day 2. And I am not role-claiming. Target me tonight and read my role of my corpse in the morning.

[got tonkaed]

im aware that getting a lynch the good doesnt exactly prove as much on mandos side. However what your suggesting is essnetially, lets lynch the most active player in the game because you dont want to read 40 pages of theories. I dont either. But we could have had 3 different lynches by now so lets not blame mando for the group not being able to come together. I think mando will eventually be killed, but hes probably got more going for town if hes alive on day two than a number of people. Im just not sure how sure we can be of your leaning if you are willing to lynch someone who has claimed merry men, on day 1 when there are other options.

[mandalorian2298]

Mandy is clearly not helping the game, I think his character's purpose is to plant confusion and mess everyone up. He could be unaffiliated with either scum or town..

Ignoring whatever he says should be the right way to go.

Well, there is a pretty good way of finding out if my words should be ignored or not. Lynch Aegnor and read it in red.

[Aegnor]

Mandy is clearly not helping the game, I think his character's purpose is to plant confusion and mess everyone up. He could be unaffiliated with either scum or town..

Ignoring whatever he says should be the right way to go.

Well, there is a pretty good way of finding out if my words should be ignored or not. Lynch Aegnor and read it in red.

I am completely ignoring all your theories, to me you are just a mass spammer whose motives are unkown.

[AK_iceman]

im aware that getting a lynch the good doesnt exactly prove as much on mandos side. However what your suggesting is essnetially, lets lynch the most active player in the game because you dont want to read 40 pages of theories.

Thats not even what I said! Read my most recent post on Mandy, he quoted it at the top of this page.

And just because he is the most active poster right now doesn't make him exempt from being mafia. He started a bandwagon on autoload, then when it gets close to a lynch he unvotes and changes his mind. Thats fine... but he's confusing too many players now and effictively ruining our chances of lynching ANYBODY!

[Aegnor]

And another thing, since you couldn't possibly know for sure anything about anyone at this point, as your claims are based on your fantasies and nothing else, even if one of your claims is right (and you sure made a lot of them), it would only be a lucky guess.

[mandalorian2298]

im aware that getting a lynch the good doesnt exactly prove as much on mandos side. However what your suggesting is essnetially, lets lynch the most active player in the game because you dont want to read 40 pages of theories.

Thats not even what I said! Read my most recent post on Mandy, he quoted it at the top of this page.

And just because he is the most active poster right now doesn't make him exempt from being mafia. He started a bandwagon on autoload, then when it gets close to a lynch he unvotes and changes his mind. Thats fine... but he's confusing too many players now and effictively ruining our chances of lynching ANYBODY!

As I said in my unvote post, I have stoped the lynch on Auto because he is Peasant. I like and hug Peasants. Merry men, I don't like.
Say Ice, aren't you or wicked even going to respond to my claim that you are Mafia. Aegnor, at least, put up a fight.

[mandalorian2298]

And another thing, since you couldn't possibly know for sure anything about anyone at this point, as your claims are based on your fantasies and nothing else, even if one of your claims is right (and you sure made a lot of them), it would only be a lucky guess.

Blame Aimless for giving me to powerfull a role.

[Aegnor]

And another thing, since you couldn't possibly know for sure anything about anyone at this point, as your claims are based on your fantasies and nothing else, even if one of your claims is right (and you sure made a lot of them), it would only be a lucky guess.

Blame Aimless for giving me to powerfull a role.

At least now we know you have a power role.

UNVOTE
VOTE Mandy

[pancakemix]

And another thing, since you couldn't possibly know for sure anything about anyone at this point, as your claims are based on your fantasies and nothing else, even if one of your claims is right (and you sure made a lot of them), it would only be a lucky guess.

Blame Aimless for giving me to powerfull a role.

At least now we know you have a power role.

UNVOTE
VOTE Mandy

He just claimed a power role and you vote him? That doesn't make a lot of sense. Why would you want to lynch someone who claimed power role?

[Aegnor]

He just claimed a power role and you vote him? That doesn't make a lot of sense. Why would you want to lynch someone who claimed power role?

Simple, his power role is going after a townie (me), thus he opposes a threat to town, and must go down.

[pancakemix]

He just claimed a power role and you vote him? That doesn't make a lot of sense. Why would you want to lynch someone who claimed power role?

Simple, his power role is going after a townie (me), thus he opposes a threat to town, and must go down.

So you're claiming townie? What kind of townie?

[mandalorian2298]

He just claimed a power role and you vote him? That doesn't make a lot of sense. Why would you want to lynch someone who claimed power role?

Simple, his power role is going after a townie (me), thus he opposes a threat to town, and must go down.

Very belivable Aegnor. Face it buddy, it's now just a matter of time before AK and wicked jump your throath in hope that, once I'm gone, they'll be able to convince the Town that it was all "a silly missunderstanding "

[Aegnor]

He just claimed a power role and you vote him? That doesn't make a lot of sense. Why would you want to lynch someone who claimed power role?

Simple, his power role is going after a townie (me), thus he opposes a threat to town, and must go down.

So you're claiming townie? What kind of townie?

I've claimed townie 4 maybe 5 times before, I won't roleclaim fearing of becoming a prime target for mafia.

[pancakemix]

He just claimed a power role and you vote him? That doesn't make a lot of sense. Why would you want to lynch someone who claimed power role?

Simple, his power role is going after a townie (me), thus he opposes a threat to town, and must go down.

So you're claiming townie? What kind of townie?

I've claimed townie 4 maybe 5 times before, I won't roleclaim fearing of becoming a prime target for mafia.

Answer my question: What kind of townie.