Deadwood Mafia Its all over! Thanks for playing

[ExplainThis]

I think you should state..Might be useful to someone else. Unless you think it would be disadvantageous to.

There is absolutely no reason for him to claim. The scummiest thing I've read so far in the whole game.

Vote: Clive

Your wrong here. I'm not saying him claiming is right but its not so easily dismissed of an idea, he's already drawn a connection between himself and 2 others, generally partial claims are bad business.

[Anarkistsdream]

I think you should state..Might be useful to someone else. Unless you think it would be disadvantageous to.

There is absolutely no reason for him to claim. The scummiest thing I've read so far in the whole game.

Vote: Clive

Your wrong here. I'm not saying him claiming is right but its not so easily dismissed of an idea, he's already drawn a connection between himself and 2 others, generally partial claims are bad business.

The part that really bothered me about it was this:

"Might be useful to someone else."

If it is useful to someone else, then let them ask. Just saying, "Someone else might like to know" just makes you look like you are pushing for a claim...

[ExplainThis]

I think you should state..Might be useful to someone else. Unless you think it would be disadvantageous to.

There is absolutely no reason for him to claim. The scummiest thing I've read so far in the whole game.

Vote: Clive

Your wrong here. I'm not saying him claiming is right but its not so easily dismissed of an idea, he's already drawn a connection between himself and 2 others, generally partial claims are bad business.

The part that really bothered me about it was this:

"Might be useful to someone else."

If it is useful to someone else, then let them ask. Just saying, "Someone else might like to know" just makes you look like you are pushing for a claim...

I read that someone else as "someone whos not you (nagerious)" as opposed to "Someone whos not me(clive)" which is how I think you are reading it, he even says that if nagerious thinks its not benefial then not to do it. Out right dismissing an idea is almost always better for the scum then discussing it.

[Anarkistsdream]

Sorry, but I stick by that vote... For now, at least.

I'm sure something will change it.

[ExplainThis]

Sorry, but I stick by that vote... For now, at least.

I'm sure something will change it.

Is there an ignore function on this forum? I'm rather convinced that anarkistsdream is only really bad at this game, not scum, but every time I read one of his posts I have to spend 5 minutes re-convincing myself that its the case.

[Anarkistsdream]

Sorry, but I stick by that vote... For now, at least.

I'm sure something will change it.

Is there an ignore function on this forum? I'm rather convinced that anarkistsdream is only really bad at this game, not scum, but every time I read one of his posts I have to spend 5 minutes re-convincing myself that its the case.

Hmmm... Wow... I suppose if your opinion carried any weight at this site, that might hurt me. But I can tell you are really just a jackass, so I sort of pity you.

Just so you know, you won't be playing many more games here run by good mods, of that I can assure you.

If you aren't here to play Risk, than fuck off.

[Clive]

Yeh you are right ET, except that I was refering to Talapus, Nag just fastposted me.

[ExplainThis]

Sorry, but I stick by that vote... For now, at least.

I'm sure something will change it.

Is there an ignore function on this forum? I'm rather convinced that anarkistsdream is only really bad at this game, not scum, but every time I read one of his posts I have to spend 5 minutes re-convincing myself that its the case.

Hmmm... Wow... I suppose if your opinion carried any weight at this site, that might hurt me. But I can tell you are really just a jackass, so I sort of pity you.

Just so you know, you won't be playing many more games here run by good mods, of that I can assure you.

If you aren't here to play Risk, than fuck off.

I'm only reciprocating towards you the attitude you show towards me. I've also started playing risk here though I admit I came for the mafia.

[Anarkistsdream]

Showed you attitude...? By making a joke about how I would change my vote?

By not unvoting someone just because you expected it?

You have shown yourself to be whiny and rude in nearly every post.

If you don't like the way people play Mafia here, then leave, but grow up and stop with the critique of everyone's game play.

You are obviously very lonely, which is why you feel like such an elitist about an internet forum game.

It's mafia. It's a game. It's meant to be fun.

So quit subjecting people to your arrogant and flippant remarks.

Nobody asked you here.

[Anarkistsdream]

My comments in BOLD

Showed you attitude...? By making a joke about how I would change my vote?

By not unvoting someone just because you expected it?

To me you come off as arrogant and conceited in every post you make. I'm fine with you not having unvoted there, I couldn't really care what your end decision was, what pissed me off about it was that you didn't put forth any counter point at all, it came off as "I'm gonna keep my vote where it is so f*ck you"

Well, you misperceived it... Not my fault. I even put the wink in there to show you I was joking. Maybe you need to learn to chill out, eh?

You have shown yourself to be whiny and rude in nearly every post.

I honestly don't think this to be true but without some sort of example showing why you feel it to be true I cant very well argue against it.

Read through everything you have said. In both Wrong Turn mafia and in Deadwood, all you have done is been an ass. I feel no compunction n to show you, as others have already alluded to the same thing in those same threads. Maybe you should try reading some of them.

If you don't like the way people play Mafia here, then leave, but grow up and stop with the critique of everyone's game play.

I've said numerous times that I don't care that you guys play differently. What I do care about a bit is that you respect the game. I think most people here do, you however I don't get that feeling from. As far as critiquing play goes, how else are people to get better?

Let them play the way they want... They'll get better through time, not browbeating them.

And I don't give a shit how you think I feel about the game, or how you feel about me. Everyone on this forum will vouch for me, so your opinion is pointless and nonsensical.

You are obviously very lonely, which is why you feel like such an elitist about an internet forum game.

This seems like it was clearly intended as only a dig at me cause I can't draw any logical connection between the two, that aside I think I'm knowledgeable when it comes to mafia but I don't think I'm an elitist, there is a difference.

It's mafia. It's a game. It's meant to be fun.

Hockey is a game, its meant to be fun. Im sure some people find it fun to brawl in hockey, its a common enough, this doesn't mean people should brawl in hockey as hockey doesn't allow for it. Not quite the analogy as was looking for but my point is that you may have fun playing the way you do but that doesn't mean others enjoy the way you play.

YOU are the one who doesn't enjoy how any of US play... How's that for an analogy? Maybe you should realize that YOU are the problem, and not us.

So quit subjecting people to your arrogant and flippant remarks.

If I come off as arrogant its because I've played a LOT of mafia and I really do know what I'm talking about for the most part, especially when dealing with generalities.

Guess what? So have I... So have a lot of us here. And you still don't see us with your level of rudeness. When you come to someone else's house to play a game, you respect them. You don't come in there acting like you are the teacher.

Nobody asked you here.

I can relate with the fact that you don't like some new guy showing up and telling you how to do things, but anything I say is open for debate and is only a suggestion, its not concrete.

You certainly do not act like that, so maybe you should show it, and not just say it.

If you want to know why I think something should be done someway ask me and I'll do the best to explain to you.

I hope this can help clear up any misunderstandings between us and not side track the game thread at the same time.

And I think that everyone in this thread needs to read this...

[ExplainThis]

My comments in BOLD

Showed you attitude...? By making a joke about how I would change my vote?

By not unvoting someone just because you expected it?

To me you come off as arrogant and conceited in every post you make. I'm fine with you not having unvoted there, I couldn't really care what your end decision was, what pissed me off about it was that you didn't put forth any counter point at all, it came off as "I'm gonna keep my vote where it is so f*ck you"

Well, you misperceived it... Not my fault. I even put the wink in there to show you I was joking. Maybe you need to learn to chill out, eh?

You have shown yourself to be whiny and rude in nearly every post.

I honestly don't think this to be true but without some sort of example showing why you feel it to be true I cant very well argue against it.

Read through everything you have said. In both Wrong Turn mafia and in Deadwood, all you have done is been an ass. I feel no compunction n to show you, as others have already alluded to the same thing in those same threads. Maybe you should try reading some of them.

If you don't like the way people play Mafia here, then leave, but grow up and stop with the critique of everyone's game play.

I've said numerous times that I don't care that you guys play differently. What I do care about a bit is that you respect the game. I think most people here do, you however I don't get that feeling from. As far as critiquing play goes, how else are people to get better?

Let them play the way they want... They'll get better through time, not browbeating them.

And I don't give a shit how you think I feel about the game, or how you feel about me. Everyone on this forum will vouch for me, so your opinion is pointless and nonsensical.

You are obviously very lonely, which is why you feel like such an elitist about an internet forum game.

This seems like it was clearly intended as only a dig at me cause I can't draw any logical connection between the two, that aside I think I'm knowledgeable when it comes to mafia but I don't think I'm an elitist, there is a difference.

It's mafia. It's a game. It's meant to be fun.

Hockey is a game, its meant to be fun. Im sure some people find it fun to brawl in hockey, its a common enough, this doesn't mean people should brawl in hockey as hockey doesn't allow for it. Not quite the analogy as was looking for but my point is that you may have fun playing the way you do but that doesn't mean others enjoy the way you play.

YOU are the one who doesn't enjoy how any of US play... How's that for an analogy? Maybe you should realize that YOU are the problem, and not us.

So quit subjecting people to your arrogant and flippant remarks.

If I come off as arrogant its because I've played a LOT of mafia and I really do know what I'm talking about for the most part, especially when dealing with generalities.

Guess what? So have I... So have a lot of us here. And you still don't see us with your level of rudeness. When you come to someone else's house to play a game, you respect them. You don't come in there acting like you are the teacher.

Nobody asked you here.

I can relate with the fact that you don't like some new guy showing up and telling you how to do things, but anything I say is open for debate and is only a suggestion, its not concrete.

You certainly do not act like that, so maybe you should show it, and not just say it.

If you want to know why I think something should be done someway ask me and I'll do the best to explain to you.

I hope this can help clear up any misunderstandings between us and not side track the game thread at the same time.

And I think that everyone in this thread needs to read this...

I'm going to continue responding to this via pm, if the mod has a problem with that he can say so.

[mandalorian2298]

I would like to start this post by saying: I told you guys so. I was right. Go me!

So, browng was Mafia. Not only that, he was a Newbie Mafia. This could perhaps lead us to one of his co-workers.

I went to re-read a bit and I found this in the begining of Day 1.

My vote was proper as well, but what the hell...
unvote
vote cena no reason

unvote cena
I'm just not will to vote Fircoal yet...

Everything has a reason. So, what might be the reason for browng to vote and unvote Cena without suplying a reason for either? There was no bandwagon on Cena. This was not his first (and thus possibly random) vote. They traded no insults nor jabs. So, why would an inexpirienced Scum just vote and unvote for someone?

The only thing that browng could have accomplished with these votes is that he could later say: "I had voted for Cena so there is no way that I am part of his Mafia." From this I conclude that browng voted for Cena because Cena is part of the Hearst Mafia too.

vote Cena

Er....cocksuckers.

[Anarkistsdream]

Hell, I didn't even have to add anything to this. You guys can see it for yourself.

Showed you attitude...? By making a joke about how I would change my vote?

By not unvoting someone just because you expected it?

To me you come off as arrogant and conceited in every post you make. I'm fine with you not having unvoted there, I couldn't really care what your end decision was, what pissed me off about it was that you didn't put forth any counter point at all, it came off as "I'm gonna keep my vote where it is so f*ck you"


Well, you misperceived it... Not my fault. I even put the wink in there to show you I was joking. Maybe you need to learn to chill out, eh?

Over the internet it can be hard to perceive how one truly intendeds something to be taken. You should take this to heart as you've misperceived much of what I've said too, later on in this you try and say thats my fault too though, slightly hypocritical if you ask me.

You have shown yourself to be whiny and rude in nearly every post.

I honestly don't think this to be true but without some sort of example showing why you feel it to be true I cant very well argue against it.

Read through everything you have said. In both Wrong Turn mafia and in Deadwood, all you have done is been an ass. I feel no compunction n to show you, as others have already alluded to the same thing in those same threads. Maybe you should try reading some of them.

I don't feel I've gotten any negative feed back in wrong turn. In deadwood I can think of one piece of negative feedback that I got but I already did my best to explain what the true intent of the post the problem was in was.

If you don't like the way people play Mafia here, then leave, but grow up and stop with the critique of everyone's game play.

I've said numerous times that I don't care that you guys play differently. What I do care about a bit is that you respect the game. I think most people here do, you however I don't get that feeling from. As far as critiquing play goes, how else are people to get better?

Let them play the way they want... They'll get better through time, not browbeating them.


If this is the best way for humans to learn why are there even schools?

And I don't give a shit how you think I feel about the game, or how you feel about me. Everyone on this forum will vouch for me, so your opinion is pointless and nonsensical.

Theres no need to be so rude, its largely cause you don't care how I think that I think I perceive you as arrogant.

You are obviously very lonely, which is why you feel like such an elitist about an internet forum game.

This seems like it was clearly intended as only a dig at me cause I can't draw any logical connection between the two, that aside I think I'm knowledgeable when it comes to mafia but I don't think I'm an elitist, there is a difference.

It's mafia. It's a game. It's meant to be fun.

Hockey is a game, its meant to be fun. Im sure some people find it fun to brawl in hockey, its a common enough, this doesn't mean people should brawl in hockey as hockey doesn't allow for it. Not quite the analogy as was looking for but my point is that you may have fun playing the way you do but that doesn't mean others enjoy the way you play.

YOU are the one who doesn't enjoy how any of US play... How's that for an analogy? Maybe you should realize that YOU are the problem, and not us.

You are thoroughly wrong here. I very much enjoy the general mind set this forum has. I think that a lot of you could be better at the game, but I still enjoy the way you play it. You are the only person so far who I feel I've had any problem with.

So quit subjecting people to your arrogant and flippant remarks.

If I come off as arrogant its because I've played a LOT of mafia and I really do know what I'm talking about for the most part, especially when dealing with generalities.

Guess what? So have I... So have a lot of us here. And you still don't see us with your level of rudeness. When you come to someone else's house to play a game, you respect them. You don't come in there acting like you are the teacher.


I'm not intending to come off as rude, nor do I have a 'teacher' mind set. When someone does something I feel to be incorrect I simply attempt to correct them for everyones sake. No matter what it is this is a healthy mind set to hold. The only time I may have come off as a teacher would have been in deadwood between me and the other guy, but he specifically asked for it.

Nobody asked you here.

I can relate with the fact that you don't like some new guy showing up and telling you how to do things, but anything I say is open for debate and is only a suggestion, its not concrete.

You certainly do not act like that, so maybe you should show it, and not just say it.

As I said earlier, you've misinterpreted me. We should both take blame for not being as clear as we could have been and not being more open minded as to how the other could have meant it, dont place all the blame on me.

If you want to know why I think something should be done someway ask me and I'll do the best to explain to you.

I hope this can help clear up any misunderstandings between us and not side track the game thread at the same time.

And I think that everyone in this thread needs to read this...

[ExplainThis]

Hell, I didn't even have to add anything to this. You guys can see it for yourself.

So instead of trying to work out your differences with me you instead only post it (in a place it doesn't even belong) to help in your ostracization of me from the community. If thats the way you want it to be thats the way it will be but let it be known I tried to work out our differences.

[ExplainThis]

I would like to start this post by saying: I told you guys so. I was right. Go me!

So, browng was Mafia. Not only that, he was a Newbie Mafia. This could perhaps lead us to one of his co-workers.

I went to re-read a bit and I found this in the begining of Day 1.

My vote was proper as well, but what the hell...
unvote
vote cena no reason

unvote cena
I'm just not will to vote Fircoal yet...

Everything has a reason. So, what might be the reason for browng to vote and unvote Cena without suplying a reason for either? There was no bandwagon on Cena. This was not his first (and thus possibly random) vote. They traded no insults nor jabs. So, why would an inexpirienced Scum just vote and unvote for someone?

The only thing that browng could have accomplished with these votes is that he could later say: "I had voted for Cena so there is no way that I am part of his Mafia." From this I conclude that browng voted for Cena because Cena is part of the Hearst Mafia too.

vote Cena

Er....cocksuckers.

is ga7 very experienced? I don't like voting someone for only what others have said (baring info roles) and although the few day1 posts cena made were rather scummy, the post he unvoted clive in seemed very townie to me, and ga7 also generally gave me a townie feel. If ga7 is very experienced though I may be willing to chalk it up to experience on his part and pursue cena.

[Koesen]

Isn't anybody going to say something like:

Woe to us! Koesen is dead!

or perhaps:

What a tragic loss! Such a promising pro town hero slain before he could rise to his destined greatness!

or maybe:

This day shall live in infamy!

or how about:

I remember where I was when I heard of Koesen's death... I was just about to surrender my virginity to my playmate next door when the news broke and we just forgot about it...

You don't have to hide your pain, you know...

[Anarkistsdream]

Hey Koesen, how about GOOD RIDDANCE!

[lord voldemort]

is ga7 very experienced? I don't like voting someone for only what others have said (baring info roles) and although the few day1 posts cena made were rather scummy, the post he unvoted clive in seemed very townie to me, and ga7 also generally gave me a townie feel. If ga7 is very experienced though I may be willing to chalk it up to experience on his part and pursue cena.

ah yer...id put him top 3 players on this site
anyway the clive thing he said he fastposted talp about what talp overheard.
not about nag...though unsure if i beleive him. also think talp should only reveal what he knows if really necesarry (confirming claims etc)
ah yer

[Serbia]

Isn't anybody going to say something like:

Woe to us! Koesen is dead!

or perhaps:

What a tragic loss! Such a promising pro town hero slain before he could rise to his destined greatness!

or maybe:

This day shall live in infamy!

or how about:

I remember where I was when I heard of Koesen's death... I was just about to surrender my virginity to my playmate next door when the news broke and we just forgot about it...

You don't have to hide your pain, you know...

I'm rather broke up about it Koesen, I'll miss seeing your Red Maple Leaf.

[Skoffin]

Which one of you cocksuckers bribed me last night?

[gimpyThewonder]

ET & AD please take it back outside. as for inside i expect you both to follow rule#10 (go back and look, I'll wait ).

on a side note Koesen i'm sad you're out

on another side note everyone needs to take a look back over the rules

[gimpyThewonder]

oh and besides lalaland and russianfire is there anyone else who needs prodding?

[F1fth]

I would like to start this post by saying: I told you guys so. I was right. Go me!

So, browng was Mafia. Not only that, he was a Newbie Mafia. This could perhaps lead us to one of his co-workers.

I went to re-read a bit and I found this in the begining of Day 1.

My vote was proper as well, but what the hell...
unvote
vote cena no reason

unvote cena
I'm just not will to vote Fircoal yet...

Everything has a reason. So, what might be the reason for browng to vote and unvote Cena without suplying a reason for either? There was no bandwagon on Cena. This was not his first (and thus possibly random) vote. They traded no insults nor jabs. So, why would an inexpirienced Scum just vote and unvote for someone?

The only thing that browng could have accomplished with these votes is that he could later say: "I had voted for Cena so there is no way that I am part of his Mafia." From this I conclude that browng voted for Cena because Cena is part of the Hearst Mafia too.

vote Cena

Er....cocksuckers.

Wow, this actually makes some bit of sense, Mandy... A fair bit of sense even

Vote Cena

[Clive]

vote f1fth

I still think he's scum.

[Talapus]

vote f1fth

I still think he's scum.

Wow, profound in it's brevity
Just a thought, but would you mind posting an actual opion and facts to back that up. We have the time, lets discuss something. So far all you've done is quote others and agree with others without any real opinion of your own.