thegreekdog wrote:PLAYER57832 wrote:greekdog, you are smarter than that. Sure, we do not need to go by what China thinks, but for you to deny that the right is using erroneous definitions and quite intentionally is disengenuous at best.
We are not talking about opinions here. We are talking about definitions of English language words. The US has no more a lock on those terms than any other English-speaking nation. When the Republicans try to redefine Liberal to mean totalitarian, it serves only to disinform. It is criminal.
I'm not smarter than that.
We're not talking about definitions of English words. We're talking about comparative politics in the United States. In the United States there are two political parties, one generally leans to a more liberal (or left) view, one generally leans to a more conservative (or right) view. On the issue of, for example, gun control, the Democrats are "left" and the Republicans are "right." We... are... talking... about... American... politics. We're not talking about whether President Obama is left of the Canadian prime minster. We're talking about whether President Obama is left of Senator McCain or former President Bush or GabonX or thegreekdog. We're not talking about whether President Bush is right of Kim Jong Il. So, when someone says "President Obama is not a leftist whacko because he's right of center" it's a pointless exercise and, to be cynical, is just a way for our non-US brethren to take a holier than thou attitude with those they don't agree with. So, while we in the US don't have "a lock on those terms," we certainly have a lock on those terms WHEN DISCUSSING U.S. POLITICS!!!
When you lable the Democrats Fascists, you are not talking comparisions, you are using a term that has a standard English definition and, whether you like or dislike any particular policy of the Democrats, saying they are fascist is ridiculous. In fact, the Democrats are not even truly liberal, they are just a bit further to the left than the EXTREMELY right-winged (at present) Republicans.
As for gun control, etc, the issue at hand is socialized healthcare. Claiming that wanting everyone to have coverage cheaper, which is the Democratic "plan", means everything from euthanizing seniors to a fascist or communistic takeover of the US is plain silly.
If you want to say that the Democrats are more liberal than the Republicans, I agree. If you claim that the Democrats are more fascist than the Republicans, you would be wrong, but could say it was about US politics. If you say that the Democrats are communist or socialist or fascist, then you need to show how the party identifies with the commonly accepted English language definitions
There's an irony here. The Republican party was founded by a guy who thought slavery made no economic sense. Now, I am in favor of this bill because our current health care system, letting insurance companies take profit without limit and dictate who they do and do not cover, the terms of our entire medical system (essentially), does not make sense. I suspect the founder of the Republican party would find much more kinship with myself than with most of the current Republican leadership.
It makes no economic sense to have tax-payor funded emergency care and the tax-payor funded Medicaid programs as the only practical alternatives to employer-provided insurance. It makes no economic sense that we let insurers profit from the healthy, while leaving the more expensive truly sick people to be funded by taxpayers. It makes no sense that employers have to lay people off who have sick family members because if they did not, their insurance premiums would get too high. It makes no sense that bankruptcy is the only way that many Americans can hope to get medical coverage for serious illnesses.
Oh, and regarding those credit charges and healthcare... Let me tell you. I pride myself in being honest, but if the only way I could get care for my kids was to declare bankruptcy and divorce my husband so our income was low enough for Medicaid, I would not hesitate to charge up those cards and file! I would feel guilty, sure, but I would do it if I had no other legitimate choice.