Hey Pika, just because I haven't posted doesn't mean I'm not here reading. As I said, I would have more to go on personally D2 for various reasons. Not to mention, I've only played small 8/9 player forum ones and the speed in which people are playing / posting here I'm having a hard time keeping up just reading due to my RL schedule. Call it scum, call it whatever. People on CC know what my CC volunteer schedule is like and should probably understand more then just a mafia player here.
The game started around Page 3 (Sept 9th) and I volunteered Page 6 (Sept 12th). In 11 days since then theres been 12 PAGES of posts. That was not the speed in which I expected and caught a bit off guard. By the time I read something and formulate something, theres half a page of long new posts to consider. For a newer player its a bit of a shock.
So yeah, sorry about my inactivity. I have been keeping pretty diligent notes and expect to have more insight and reactions in D2. IDK how that warrants a vote, I mean if you value activity so much in order for tells, why would you vote the inactive player when you have other posts to be working off and getting those tells?
Anyway fwiw:
Game mechanics speculation (poorly thought out/researched speculation at that).
Yep, you guys had been going on for awhile and I read through the posts and asked a question that was immediately shot down by you. When in fact others have posted similar things to what I said before, and since, which you didn't really address. For the very little interaction I've had in this game, you seem to be happy to aim / correct at me.
Gandalf was addressing the 13 hoods worn by the 13 Dwarves who had arrived, and his own wizard hat in addition. Bilbo had no hood, as he had not expected to be going on an adventure at all. I would not read any more into that opening paragraph, as that would lead us to believe we have 13 dwarves as the town side and no Bilbo...
This was your reaction to my D1 take on the story provided. When you read the D1 story, it says nothing about bilbo not having a hood or not. So I dont know how you can speculate he wasn't part of the group. IDK how it can be poorly thought out or researched when literally its based off a 3 paragraph introduction. But sure. Whatever floats your boat.
Call for a No-Lynch, swiftly followed by a now-classic of The Hobbit mafia: the "I have suspicions but I won't tell you who or why", and an odd attempt to discredit madmitch for not pre-emptively voting IcePack under the assumption they would make the very post in which they attempt to do said discrediting, because you know, that makes sense...
On the contrary, I did say why. I said I wanted to see how the people on my FOS list reacted to today. I wasn't trying to discredit madmitch, I simply asked him a question to gather more info on why he did something. Again, a very strange way to twist what I said / did. But whatever.
Nothing of import.
Nothing of value.
Sort of like your posting here and vote? My question about whether game mechanics / story about a jester imo is important, because as I said, if we suspected a jester bcuz it appeared someone was trying to get lynched, it certainly would be important to know so you
DONT LYNCH A JESTER. Pretty easy to deduce that mate.
Anyway, I'm doing what I can to keep up. I basically started the 13th, and have made some minor attempts to get some additional info / clarification on items that I noted. (5 posts in 10 days, in which I said I would be more active the next day anyway) so I dont see how again, you would expect me to be wildly busy responding to things when I specifically said I would be more active D2.
I mean, I could very understandably be judged if D2 comes along and I'm just as quiet. Feel free to judge me on my actions and activity at that point. To do so before then I find curious, at best.
Posted: Sat Sep 23, 2017 2:12 pm