Mafia Family Game **Game Over** Isengard Win

[Telvannia]

Day 1: Pages Start (1)-15
Day 2 start
Day 3 start

list of dead players:

1. Wicked Gollum (Freelancer)Died Night 4
2. trestain Sauron (Godfather of Mordor) Died Night 6
3. Roger Dodger (replaced guia09)
4. XenHu Gimli Died Night 2
5. Master Bush Gandalf (doctor) Died Night 1
7. Puff Boromir (Miller) Died Day 1
8. moz976 Aragorn (Cop) Died Night 3
9. panicker Lurtz (Isengard) Died Night 3
11. The1exile Mouth of Sauron (Mordor) Died Night 4
12. dcowboys055 Frodo Died Day 5
13. Sam Jam Meriadoc Took Died Night 6
14. P Gizzle Legolas (Cop) Died Night 3
15. DIRESTRAITS Pippin Died Day 2
16. Machiavelli Sam (doctor) Died Night 2

Living Players

6. onbekende Grima (Isengard)
10. vgmmaster Saruman (Godfather of Isengard)

[wicked]

Lets get day started ASAP

But it's still night?

[DIRESTRAITS]

Is it usual for Night to take this long?

[wicked]

yes

[reverend_kyle]

spam.


delete this wicked.

[Telvannia]

As the sun rises on Minith Tirith the residents go around there normal duties, moz976 is seen walking and talking with many of the Gondorian residents on his route he stops to talk to trestain who has emerged from the 6th ring of the city. Dcowboys055 is seen in deep conversation with Machiavelli before they bump into Sam Jam and DIRESTRAITS who together walk off to eat breakfast. Over breakfast XenHu begins abuse at P Gizzle who tries to ignore him. The1exile, vgmmaste and Wicked wander of into the city after a quick breakfast to buy some supplies. onbekende just walks away by himself in seemly comfort. guia09 and Puff come running into the room where breakfast is being eating and tell everyone what they have seen, everyone heads to the walls of the 1st ring and lying at the bottom of the walls dead as a doornail his batter form is nearly impossible to recognise lies:
Master Bush Gandalf (doctor)

[DIRESTRAITS]

Aw Crap. That sucks.

[dcowboys055]

well that sucks

[onbekende]

swell, our doc

[panicker]

oh wow . start could not have gone worse

we have 16 players(started) so do you think its safe to assume at least 4 mafia? and possibly 5 ? this is a big kick in the teeth, one of our power roles deceased .

were on the backfoot already

c'mon we got some mafia to get right

[panicker]

that was "lynching" in my previous post , img not working lol

[DIRESTRAITS]

Anyone wondering how the families play in this?

[trestain]

well thats not a good start,

[vgmmaster]

oh wow . start could not have gone worse

we have 16 players(started) so do you think its safe to assume at least 4 mafia? and possibly 5 ? this is a big kick in the teeth, one of our power roles deceased .

were on the backfoot already

c'mon we got some mafia to get right

I don't think I've ever seen a 5 man mafia, so that's out of the question. Also, when you say that this is th worst possible start, you are partially correct. It could have been much worse if the cop was the one found dead, but yes, this is a huge blow to us.

Anyone wondering how the families play in this?

I was wondering the same thing. Personally, I wouldn't be surprised if there are multiple mafia groups just because of the game title.

[trestain]

oh wow . start could not have gone worse

we have 16 players(started) so do you think its safe to assume at least 4 mafia? and possibly 5 ? this is a big kick in the teeth, one of our power roles deceased .

were on the backfoot already

c'mon we got some mafia to get right

I don't think I've ever seen a 5 man mafia, so that's out of the question. Also, when you say that this is th worst possible start, you are partially correct. It could have been much worse if the cop was the one found dead, but yes, this is a huge blow to us.

Anyone wondering how the families play in this?

I was wondering the same thing. Personally, I wouldn't be surprised if there are multiple mafia groups just because of the game title.

If there are mutliple mafia groups wioldn't there have been 2 deaths last night though?

[vgmmaster]

oh wow . start could not have gone worse

we have 16 players(started) so do you think its safe to assume at least 4 mafia? and possibly 5 ? this is a big kick in the teeth, one of our power roles deceased .

were on the backfoot already

c'mon we got some mafia to get right

I don't think I've ever seen a 5 man mafia, so that's out of the question. Also, when you say that this is th worst possible start, you are partially correct. It could have been much worse if the cop was the one found dead, but yes, this is a huge blow to us.

Anyone wondering how the families play in this?

I was wondering the same thing. Personally, I wouldn't be surprised if there are multiple mafia groups just because of the game title.

If there are mutliple mafia groups wioldn't there have been 2 deaths last night though?

Good point. I didn't think about that.

However, one thing I've seen before is that the mafia(s) may alternate kills. Such as one mafia kills on day one, the other mafia on day 2.

But if there is only one group, why would it be called Mafia Family? Perhaps I'm thinking about it too much, but the title of the game leads me to believe that there are 2 mafias. Providing that there isn't a 2nd doctor around, we'll probably find out after the next night if there are 2 killers of some sort.

[panicker]

if the doctor protects on a night , does it count still if he is night killed ?

just in case your theory is right about 2 mafia outfits this may explain that


im just wondering , as im kinda new to online mafia, how many power roles we might have with 16 players , a cop ,im hoping a sane one too, backup medic maybe unlocked now and im very wary of any
spies because of the LOTR theme . dont read into too much im just throwing things out with it being first day and all and writing things down for my benefit

(obviously i dont expect , and hope they dont, power roles to say yup im cop eg lol)

[Puff]

oh wow . start could not have gone worse

we have 16 players(started) so do you think its safe to assume at least 4 mafia? and possibly 5 ? this is a big kick in the teeth, one of our power roles deceased .

were on the backfoot already

c'mon we got some mafia to get right

I don't think I've ever seen a 5 man mafia, so that's out of the question. Also, when you say that this is th worst possible start, you are partially correct. It could have been much worse if the cop was the one found dead, but yes, this is a huge blow to us.

Anyone wondering how the families play in this?

I was wondering the same thing. Personally, I wouldn't be surprised if there are multiple mafia groups just because of the game title.

If there are mutliple mafia groups wioldn't there have been 2 deaths last night though?

Good point. I didn't think about that.

However, one thing I've seen before is that the mafia(s) may alternate kills. Such as one mafia kills on day one, the other mafia on day 2.

But if there is only one group, why would it be called Mafia Family? Perhaps I'm thinking about it too much, but the title of the game leads me to believe that there are 2 mafias. Providing that there isn't a 2nd doctor around, we'll probably find out after the next night if there are 2 killers of some sort.

A good point.

Though I'm not entirely sure that with 16 players there would be room for two groups.

If there is than how many would be in each group(so there can still be enough citizens).

[vgmmaster]

oh wow . start could not have gone worse

we have 16 players(started) so do you think its safe to assume at least 4 mafia? and possibly 5 ? this is a big kick in the teeth, one of our power roles deceased .

were on the backfoot already

c'mon we got some mafia to get right

I don't think I've ever seen a 5 man mafia, so that's out of the question. Also, when you say that this is th worst possible start, you are partially correct. It could have been much worse if the cop was the one found dead, but yes, this is a huge blow to us.

Anyone wondering how the families play in this?

I was wondering the same thing. Personally, I wouldn't be surprised if there are multiple mafia groups just because of the game title.

If there are mutliple mafia groups wioldn't there have been 2 deaths last night though?

Good point. I didn't think about that.

However, one thing I've seen before is that the mafia(s) may alternate kills. Such as one mafia kills on day one, the other mafia on day 2.

But if there is only one group, why would it be called Mafia Family? Perhaps I'm thinking about it too much, but the title of the game leads me to believe that there are 2 mafias. Providing that there isn't a 2nd doctor around, we'll probably find out after the next night if there are 2 killers of some sort.

A good point.

Though I'm not entirely sure that with 16 players there would be room for two groups.

If there is than how many would be in each group(so there can still be enough citizens).

If there are 16 people, let's say that both mafia groups have 3 people. That's 6 mafia and if there are no Serial Killers, 6 total scum. The 10 townspeople outnumber the mafia at the start of the game.

if the doctor protects on a night , does it count still if he is night killed ?

It depends on the game mod. Some people will count the night kill, other people will count whichever one is sent to them first. However, it's also possible that both mafias (providing that there are two) targeted the same person.

[Puff]

that could be true

[P Gizzle]

crap.....well, first off, is there anyone who doesn't like MB, and this could be revenge? this is how i usually start off the first day, making lists

[Machiavelli]

If there are 16 people, let's say that both mafia groups have 3 people. That's 6 mafia and if there are no Serial Killers, 6 total scum. The 10 townspeople outnumber the mafia at the start of the game.

I think that ratio is off. If there are two families it is probably two mafia in each family. If there were three mafia, the town would need to have a bunch of power roles, to even it out.

if the doctor protects on a night , does it count still if he is night killed ?

It depends on the game mod. Some people will count the night kill, other people will count whichever one is sent to them first. However, it's also possible that both mafias (providing that there are two) targeted the same person.

It is also possible that there are two doctors and one of them guessed correctly.

[vgmmaster]

If there are 16 people, let's say that both mafia groups have 3 people. That's 6 mafia and if there are no Serial Killers, 6 total scum. The 10 townspeople outnumber the mafia at the start of the game.

I think that ratio is off. If there are two families it is probably two mafia in each family. If there were three mafia, the town would need to have a bunch of power roles, to even it out.

That's possible as well. I only used the number 3 to explain what I was saying and also since 3 seems to be the average size for a mafia group.

if the doctor protects on a night , does it count still if he is night killed ?

It depends on the game mod. Some people will count the night kill, other people will count whichever one is sent to them first. However, it's also possible that both mafias (providing that there are two) targeted the same person.

It is also possible that there are two doctors and one of them guessed correctly.

It's possibe there are two doctors, but I've never seen a game where both doctors are active at the same time.

[Master Bush]

crap.....well, first off, is there anyone who doesn't like MB

Dont be silly.

Also, I hate this game.

Also, I thought Gandalf couldn't die?

Also, I forgot to protected someone on night 1, so I guess it was only right that I was killed.

Also, Frodo is gay.

[Machiavelli]

Also, I forgot to protected someone on night 1, so I guess it was only right that I was killed.