
The word "theory" seems to have lost its meaning.
Re: the non-confirmers were most likely asked to confirm their roles via PM in order for Charle to make sure that they got them. Instead of guessing at the setup, about which town knows next to nothing apart of each individual's role (and any imnplications of such role), we should start looking at how people act and react.
The most interesting right now, apart from the silent ones, of course, is hjelp seemingly thinking that scum waves around big signs saying: "I'm scum!" However, the sort of superficiality of the inquiry indicates to me at least a willingness to look for scum. I have hjelp as town right now.