NCIS Mafia: Mafia Win!!

[new guy1]

Lol, I hate making hard decisions, but I think I know who I will shoot... possibly...

[thechuck51]

There is no reason saf wouldnt have been able to stop the lynch and I feel he hasn't even tried to explain it.

I am ready to hammer unless anybody objects...

[safariguy5]

Seriously? Does nobody find it odd that an overeager vig failed to kill me? I might add also that overeager vig is basically a textbook SKer fakeclaim. Add that to the fact that new guy "conveniently" forgot he's a mason means I think he's SKer.

vote new guy

[new guy1]

Seriously? Does nobody find it odd that an overeager vig failed to kill me? I might add also that overeager vig is basically a textbook SKer fakeclaim. Add that to the fact that new guy "conveniently" forgot he's a mason means I think he's SKer.

vote new guy

I shot at you saf, the kill didnt go through, hence no sig saur or accent. I might also add that overeager vig is basically a textbook overeager vig calim. And Im sorry, Ive had many busy days so I didnt remember every detail of my role. And why the hell would I claim that I could also talk to chuck if I knew I couldnt back it up. You dont need to take my word for it, I would have been stupid to mention it when I couldnt back it up.

[thechuck51]

Seriously? Does nobody find it odd that an overeager vig failed to kill me? I might add also that overeager vig is basically a textbook SKer fakeclaim. Add that to the fact that new guy "conveniently" forgot he's a mason means I think he's SKer.

vote new guy

Quite honestly I don't trust either of you.

Ok Time to claim

I am Jimmy Palmer Town Doctor

IB, who did you protect each night?

fastposted by new guy

[new guy1]

Quite honestly chuck, I dont see how you dont trust me. All the times I said I believe chucks claim and have pretty much no doubt hes lying. And if it had come down to you possibly being lynched I would have come out earlier about it. I was about to when I believe it was IB said the vig should claim if they are a vig, but then I thought he might be mafia and didnt claim cause I didnt want to be a target. I would also like to know who IB protected, because you are ironically the assistant of ducky that I mentioned near the start of the game if I do believe.

[thechuck51]

Ok from the flavor there has to be at least 1 mafia left (kill was an explosion)

If NG is an Sk that means in 16 player game there were 4 mafia, a Cult Recruiter, and a Serial Killer. Seems like too much to expect town to overcome.

[new guy1]

EXACTLY MY POINT. I made that same point yesterday (in game). I said I believed the shooter (me) to be a Vig because of the recruiter and mafia. I was trying to give enough hints without making it too obvious...

[thechuck51]

I know I am town and I think Isaiah is town based on strike wolf's lynch. That leaves 3 question marks.

If we lynch saf and he is town then new guy vigs IB which hopefully leaves 2 town alive tomorrow.

If we lynch saf and he is scum but we still go into night whoever survives votes new guy and town wins.

If we lynch saf and he is town and new guy is SK we are fucked.

[chapcrap]

Day 5: First Official Vote Count:

Iron Butterfly:
isaiah40:
new guy1: safariguy5
safariguy5: Iron Butterfly, isaiah40 (L-1)
thechuck51:

With 5 alive, it takes 3 to lynch. Deadline in about 156 hours.

[isaiah40]

I know I am town and I think Isaiah is town based on strike wolf's lynch. That leaves 3 question marks.

If we lynch saf and he is town then new guy vigs IB which hopefully leaves 2 town alive tomorrow.

If we lynch saf and he is scum but we still go into night whoever survives votes new guy and town wins.

If we lynch saf and he is town and new guy is SK we are fucked.

We could go lynch ng and then go after Ib or saf tomorrow.

[new guy1]

Yeah, but then you dont get the chance to have 3 people instead of 4, and so I believe it would be better to have 3 because then theres not as many choices... Get what Im saying?

[isaiah40]

Yeah, but then you dont get the chance to have 3 people instead of 4, and so I believe it would be better to have 3 because then theres not as many choices... Get what Im saying?

Who's to say you won't kill a townie?

[new guy1]

Yeah, but then you dont get the chance to have 3 people instead of 4, and so I believe it would be better to have 3 because then theres not as many choices... Get what Im saying?

Who's to say you won't kill a townie?

Whose to say I wont hit mafia?

[isaiah40]

Yeah, but then you dont get the chance to have 3 people instead of 4, and so I believe it would be better to have 3 because then theres not as many choices... Get what Im saying?

Who's to say you won't kill a townie?

Whose to say I wont hit mafia?

Do you know who the scum is for sure? If so tell us now so we can finish him off!!

[new guy1]

Im guessing either Saf or IB, because you seem to give off a town tell to me. Thats why I dont want to get lynched, cause I can shoot whichever one we dont vote.

[isaiah40]

SO drop the hammer then.

[new guy1]

I want to make sure thats what everyone wants. Why rush isiah? The town image is starting to turn to a mafia member's rushing instinct.

[Iron Butterfly]

Im guessing either Saf or IB, because you seem to give off a town tell to me. Thats why I dont want to get lynched, cause I can shoot whichever one we dont vote.

Im a frig-gin DOC. You will not have a game with out a Doc. Period. You go through any archived game and show me a game without a doc.

I have already said I protected Edoscil Night one. Chuk night two. And I protected Isiah the last two nights.
I also started the case to lynch Happyfeet who turned out to be mafia.

I was honestly of the mind that if we lynch Safari it would be game over. Four mafia, two third party including cult followers is already past the 33% ratio for a balanced game.

[safariguy5]

Im guessing either Saf or IB, because you seem to give off a town tell to me. Thats why I dont want to get lynched, cause I can shoot whichever one we dont vote.

Here's the reason why I think we need to kill new guy. We know he is going to kill. Regardless of what he is, he's going to shoot someone, and he's made it perfectly clear that he's willing to shoot the doc. We have a better chance of stopping 1 nightkill than stopping 2 NK's. We can come back and argue about who's the most likely mafia player tomorrow. It's still going to be at least 2 townies vs 1 mafia member if we lynch new guy.

[new guy1]

Im not going to kill the doc, I was just saying he was seeming scummy to me. If you read into a couple previous posts, you would know who my current target is.

[safariguy5]

Im guessing either Saf or IB, because you seem to give off a town tell to me. Thats why I dont want to get lynched, cause I can shoot whichever one we dont vote.

Right. IB claimed doc. You're saying you're going to shoot him. All you really have on your side is scene flavor that says you're using a sig sauer. That and a few kills of anti town roles. Nothing actually confirms you as a vig.

[new guy1]

IK, but I knew how bad the claim would sound and I claimed it. I could have claimed something else so we could discuss who the sk is, since they were obviously fake claiming since they were hiding. But instead I left it up to you guys to see I actually am what I claim. At this point I think it would have been better for me to fake claim, given the amount of grief Im getting from it.

[Iron Butterfly]

IK, but I knew how bad the claim would sound and I claimed it. I could have claimed something else so we could discuss who the sk is, since they were obviously fake claiming since they were hiding. But instead I left it up to you guys to see I actually am what I claim. At this point I think it would have been better for me to fake claim, given the amount of grief Im getting from it.

Remember, just because you know you are Town does not mean anyone else knows your Town. We know we had two kills night one. It was discussed that there would be a vig or sk. I thought perhaps a JOAT as the game wore on. I do not see how you could be a sk with the number of mafia and third party.

Your not getting grief. This is how the game is played. I believe Safari is full of it and his only recourse is to shift focus as he has not been able to explain his inability to stop the lynch of NS.

Why it is taking so long to hammer Safari is beyond me. If someone would hammer him and it should be game over.

[new guy1]

I will sense I saw the chuck was willing to hammer, which means we are all agreed as far as I know. I just wanted to make sure we discussed everything before I ended it, in case he isnt mafia. Vote safari