Two roles that haven't been mentioned that I believe should be: king maker and bomb man.
1. The king maker. In mafia hands it could be used for all sorts of mischief. It would be a risky play, but they could give it to a townsperson who would use it to kill off a mostly random person, who if turns up town would instantly give the rest of the town a reason to turn on that killer, so if used properly, the mafia could cause two deaths in a day while eliminating the lynch. However it is risky as a smart town would not use it or could kill scum. The more I think about it, the less I think it should it should be banned though, for those risks. Any thoughts?
2. The bomb man. I definitely think this should be banned and am currently leaning towards it heavily. If scum have it and use it properly (eg picking town and a codeword that is unlikely to be said early but could be pushed out later in the game) then it is essentially an extra kill per night, even though it wouldn't show up until all at once later in the game. The only reason I'm not certain they'd choose is that it could easily be wasted by either the targets dying or the codeword being stated immediately.
If I'm being totally honest here, I thought that CPR doc could be a great help to the town if used properly, I hadn't even thought that scum could use it. But at this point, definitely should be banned. (This point meaning it is very unlikely that a good townie would be able to secretly get it and use it)
I do have a couple questions:
For the CPR doc, would someone die if they are targeted for say a mafia kill, but saved but the medic, but also targeted by the CPR doc? Would the order of actions sent in matter? (Ex: If, mafia then cpr then medic, it would be kill,save,save whereas if it went mafia then medic then cpr, it would be kill,save, kill(?))
Not that the answer really matters at this point because it should be banned regardless, I'm just asking for curiosity's sake
The other question:
For the hooker role, the role claims that if the target visits someone else that night they would also get infected. Is this because the hooker would then go with and infect both of them? Or is it truly an infectious disease, where anyone who contacts the infected becomes infected? For example, if Player A is infected night 1 and visits Player B they are clearly both infected, but what about the next night? Do players A and B infect everyone they visit before they die?
This is essentially just a curiosity question as well, since I think the hooker should be banned either way (unless the mafia talking to each other at night means they are "together" and that means if one gets infected they all would
)
So in conclusion (aka tldr version
), I believe that CPR and hooker should be banned for sure. I am currently leaning toward bomb man and godfather for the other two bans
FP'd by pcm
