Yo Ho, A Pirate's Life! [2/16] Endgame: Pirates Win!

[SPARTACUS1974]

I'm surprised to see I'm in the middle of the Isaiah votes? Did I only fos first?
And heck, cabin boy seems scummy itself as well, I never imagine them to really be happy with their jobs. Maybe a menial power role is possible as well in the vein of investigative watcher or similar I guess? But I don't understand why he seemed so sketchy with his responses?

And what are you talking about, no pressure Spartacus? l-4/3 should be too close enough for comfort?

he was at l4 when he claimed and if you read back there was no real presure at all , you know you would wait till it got to l2 to claim and then at least claim your role and not cabin boy lol .
if he had claimed his true role ie tracker 1 of us would have a role to protect him on the first night so there was no need at all to claim cabin boy that just looks scummy to me .

[isaiah40]

We were close to a hammer to test his claim but now you guys are jumping toward someone who is just against isaiah's claim like I am.

Let me point out a few things I saw for the 'bout past page and a half.

Well I have never seen someone do that
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT
Ok so if ur tracker town wouldnt vote for you considering town outnumbers mafia there is no need to lie so for this reason my vote stands

So if you are town, you would be willing to lose a tracker who could find out who the mafia are? If you aren't town then you must be mafia, which now I believe you are, or else you would have unvoted. Something interesting to think about. I think we have uncovered one mafia!! So I will now unvote vote Some7hingCLEVER!

Some7hing's post is yet still unclear to me, but I do believe he just means if you were a tracker why would you try to hide it at L-2/L-1. As for your voting isaiah it's all over the place, you have no case against anybody and your willing to just randomly vote against anyone who votes you.

I'm surprised to see I'm in the middle of the Isaiah votes? Did I only fos first?
And heck, cabin boy seems scummy itself as well, I never imagine them to really be happy with their jobs. Maybe a menial power role is possible as well in the vein of investigative watcher or similar I guess? But I don't understand why he seemed so sketchy with his responses?

And what are you talking about, no pressure Spartacus? l-4/3 should be too close enough for comfort?

Yes I am Town, and I fibbed when I said I didn't have a role. I am a tracker, so if those who are town, decide to go ahead and make me walk the plank then you will be fighting blind. I was hoping to try and protect my role from mafia as long as possible. Technically Gilligan unvoted but forgot to place his "unvote" in color. So Doc, I will need protection tonight!

Sully shame on you for being razzed at possibly lynching me!!

unvote we can test his claim if needs be.

Well I have never seen someone do that
WHY WOULD YOU DO THAT
Ok so if ur tracker town wouldnt vote for you considering town outnumbers mafia there is no need to lie so for this reason my vote stands

Do you have any reason to believe he is not a tracker?

Do you believe isaiah's claim this quickly? Do you have any reason to believe his claim?

As for the testing the claim, I do not wish to let him off today with a feeling he might try to strike me in the night for leading the case against him. But if he does make it through the night I say he tracks me and tells everyone what I am, if he's wrong he's dead...

Like I said, I'd rather not even give him that chance because I might not make it through the night if he's mafia.

I would gather then that you are town then. So jak, would you be willing for town to be without their tracker for the rest of the game? Would you be willing to have me tell you if anyone had visited you during the night? Oh I don't retaliate against those who lead a claim against me, that is unless they really are mafia! So me being in this position has revealed a few clues.

1. Some7hingCLEVER is mafia,
2. jak111 is town,
3. Leehar, Gilligan, hippo a few who I have suspicions of being mafia themselves as they have been way too quiet.

These are my observations. So if I am lynched now, you won't get any information come tomorrow about who visited who during the night. Of course this means that whoever is the doctor will need to protect me or else I'm dead.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

How in the world do u think im mafia
Cause I say that I dont believe a claim?
Now you are just coming up with BS reasons to get the attention off you

hold on let me break this down more
U think im mafia cause im willing to lynch a claimed tracker
When the claim is so sketchy and here is why
1.) u fake claimed when u are town
a.) is that normal? Im new so I dont know
b.) and the. When pressure got really strong you claimed tracker and I can't be sure if this is real claim without a counterclaim which were probably not gonna get considering thats a pretty big role...maybe this is why he chose it to fake claim with?
2.) u claim with little to no pressure in my opinion
a.) to try to bring pressure off you fast
b.) you got scared and panicked
3.) then you use ridiculous accusations to try to pull attention of yourself by saying im mafia for not believing a claim?

And thats why my vote stands Isaiah

[Leehar]

I would gather then that you are town then. So jak, would you be willing for town to be without their tracker for the rest of the game? Would you be willing to have me tell you if anyone had visited you during the night? Oh I don't retaliate against those who lead a claim against me, that is unless they really are mafia! So me being in this position has revealed a few clues.
These are my observations. So if I am lynched now, you won't get any information come tomorrow about who visited who during the night. Of course this means that whoever is the doctor will need to protect me or else I'm dead.

Or you could just be mafia and this is your fake claim after you realized cabin boy didn't cut it and stole a similar tracker suggestion off me...
However, since it does still gel with the role name, I am inclined to believe you but this whole 'if you lynch me you'll be worse for it' is often scummy in itself as well...
But again, you've claimed a fairly useful power role, and if there aren't any counter claims, and no evidence other than what you say to dispute it, we might as well avoid lynching you when you can still be of use. Unvote

You did however did have a good point on inactivity, tho I'm curious why you're putting me onto that list since I'd assume the only way you'd remember me is because you did actually see me active here. And again, the fact that you're omgus'ing again on those who voted for you continues to be scummy. It's theoretically impossible that we can all be mafia, so just accusing us left, right and centre does you no good.
As I said tho, your inactivity point has merit, so FoS NoS and Ghostly I think, and Vote Kiwi3

[kiwi3]

and what reason for voting for me? I am sitting back watching and taking all this in.

[Nebuchadnezer]

and what reason for voting for me? I am sitting back watching and taking all this in.

Ummm...that would be exactly why. Participate. Contribute. Don't lurk.

I can't figure out Clever's playing style at all. However, I also think he's trying to contribute in his own weird way. That's the whole point of pressuring the inactives. If you let the mafia sit back and do nothing, they will. While the town tears each other up.

Why people are still voting isaiah is beyond me.

[jak111]

and what reason for voting for me? I am sitting back watching and taking all this in.

Ummm...that would be exactly why. Participate. Contribute. Don't lurk.

I can't figure out Clever's playing style at all. However, I also think he's trying to contribute in his own weird way. That's the whole point of pressuring the inactives. If you let the mafia sit back and do nothing, they will. While the town tears each other up.

Why people are still voting isaiah is beyond me.

And why wouldn't we still be pressuring him? How many games have you been in that mafia tell you they are mafia? Hmm?

[SPARTACUS1974]

and what reason for voting for me? I am sitting back watching and taking all this in.

Ummm...that would be exactly why. Participate. Contribute. Don't lurk.

I can't figure out Clever's playing style at all. However, I also think he's trying to contribute in his own weird way. That's the whole point of pressuring the inactives. If you let the mafia sit back and do nothing, they will. While the town tears each other up.

Why people are still voting isaiah is beyond me.

And why wouldn't we still be pressuring him? How many games have you been in that mafia tell you they are mafia? Hmm?

im with you Jak he claimed way to easy and then tried changing his claim to a power role when if he just claimed tracker from the start he would be protected , as it is its way to scummy

[jak111]

and what reason for voting for me? I am sitting back watching and taking all this in.

Ummm...that would be exactly why. Participate. Contribute. Don't lurk.

I can't figure out Clever's playing style at all. However, I also think he's trying to contribute in his own weird way. That's the whole point of pressuring the inactives. If you let the mafia sit back and do nothing, they will. While the town tears each other up.

Why people are still voting isaiah is beyond me.

And why wouldn't we still be pressuring him? How many games have you been in that mafia tell you they are mafia? Hmm?

im with you Jak he claimed way to easy and then tried changing his claim to a power role when if he just claimed tracker from the start he would be protected , as it is its way to scummy

Keep note as to who's trying to fend us AWAY from him. They trust someone too easily on here.

[SPARTACUS1974]

oh i forgot
vote isaiah

[Nebuchadnezer]

and what reason for voting for me? I am sitting back watching and taking all this in.

Ummm...that would be exactly why. Participate. Contribute. Don't lurk.

I can't figure out Clever's playing style at all. However, I also think he's trying to contribute in his own weird way. That's the whole point of pressuring the inactives. If you let the mafia sit back and do nothing, they will. While the town tears each other up.

Why people are still voting isaiah is beyond me.

And why wouldn't we still be pressuring him? How many games have you been in that mafia tell you they are mafia? Hmm?

How many games have you been in that you lynched the player that acted the scummiest on D1, and he was actually mafia? Remember, it is day 1. Mafia is not sticking their necks out there on Day 1. They are most likely all turtled up and hiding in the background, perhaps throwing an obligatory post with no real meaning.

[thehippo8]

and what reason for voting for me? I am sitting back watching and taking all this in.

Ummm...that would be exactly why. Participate. Contribute. Don't lurk.

I can't figure out Clever's playing style at all. However, I also think he's trying to contribute in his own weird way. That's the whole point of pressuring the inactives. If you let the mafia sit back and do nothing, they will. While the town tears each other up.

Why people are still voting isaiah is beyond me.

And why wouldn't we still be pressuring him? How many games have you been in that mafia tell you they are mafia? Hmm?

How many games have you been in that you lynched the player that acted the scummiest on D1, and he was actually mafia? Remember, it is day 1. Mafia is not sticking their necks out there on Day 1. They are most likely all turtled up and hiding in the background, perhaps throwing an obligatory post with no real meaning.

Or throwing up stumbling blocks in a depserate attempt to throw people off the scent.

My vote remains because IMHO neither of the claims (cabin boy or tracker) are verifiable and really good scum lies. Cabin boys are not always good things, often pilfering stuff, leaving doors open for crooks and double-crossing whoever if it means that they'll get a meal or not have their snotty noses broken! Tracker is a great deceptive lie. If we are to believe that then he'd make up all sorts of nonsense and have town, as you say, tearing themselves apart. That he is a liar there is no doubt, he accepts that. IMHO we cannot accept a tracker who lies because we cannot trust anythign they say. He's lynched himself in my book, well at least he can take his chances at sea with the Cracken!

[jak111]

and what reason for voting for me? I am sitting back watching and taking all this in.

Ummm...that would be exactly why. Participate. Contribute. Don't lurk.

I can't figure out Clever's playing style at all. However, I also think he's trying to contribute in his own weird way. That's the whole point of pressuring the inactives. If you let the mafia sit back and do nothing, they will. While the town tears each other up.

Why people are still voting isaiah is beyond me.

And why wouldn't we still be pressuring him? How many games have you been in that mafia tell you they are mafia? Hmm?

How many games have you been in that you lynched the player that acted the scummiest on D1, and he was actually mafia? Remember, it is day 1. Mafia is not sticking their necks out there on Day 1. They are most likely all turtled up and hiding in the background, perhaps throwing an obligatory post with no real meaning.

Well since this is my 2nd game where I've started on day 1... that didn't happen my first game, we voted for a person because he was inactive. GUESS WHAT! He was a power role <.< on town side...

So this time I'd like to go after someone who's leaving so many scum slips in the first day it's funny to think otherwise.

[new guy1]

sorry i was innactive two days as i was playing paintball (should be in the vacation forum). im reading up and most likely will not be able to post a case tonight as i must read my other forums and then sleep (got 3 hours last night).

[isaiah40]

Well since this is my 2nd game where I've started on day 1... that didn't happen my first game, we voted for a person because he was inactive. GUESS WHAT! He was a power role <.< on town side...

So this time I'd like to go after someone who's leaving so many scum slips in the first day it's funny to think otherwise.

Well looks like it will happen to you again.

[crazymilkshake5]

sorry i was innactive two days as i was playing paintball (should be in the vacation forum). im reading up and most likely will not be able to post a case tonight as i must read my other forums and then sleep (got 3 hours last night).

Paintball as in real paintball with guns and such or paintball with on the forums?

[ghostly447]

sorry i was innactive two days as i was playing paintball (should be in the vacation forum). im reading up and most likely will not be able to post a case tonight as i must read my other forums and then sleep (got 3 hours last night).

Paintball as in real paintball with guns and such or paintball with on the forums?

Paintball as in running around firing paintball guns at people getting hit all day for 2 days with 3 hours sleep between. I am in the same boat as him in that I will not have a case to post for a bit.

[new guy1]

sorry i was innactive two days as i was playing paintball (should be in the vacation forum). im reading up and most likely will not be able to post a case tonight as i must read my other forums and then sleep (got 3 hours last night).

Paintball as in real paintball with guns and such or paintball with on the forums?

Paintball as in running around firing paintball guns at people getting hit all day for 2 days with 3 hours sleep between. I am in the same boat as him in that I will not have a case to post for a bit.

confirmity-firm-firm.

sorry , im about to get off as i just read through all of my forums and so i will be on tomorrow.

[soundman]

Vote count:

SPARTACUS1974
crazymilkshake5
isaiah40 - Gilligan, jak111, thehippo, CMS, some7, spartacus - (L3)
thehippo8
Victor Sullivan
Some7hingCLEVER - isaiah - (L8)
TeeGee
new guy1
ghostly447 - newguy - (L8)
NoSurvivors
Gilligan
kiwi3 - Leehar - (L8)
Leehar
jak111
jonty125
Nebuchadnezer

With 16 alive it takes 9 to make someone walk the plank.

Deadline: None yet. We'll see how this day goes.

[isaiah40]

Vote count:

SPARTACUS1974
crazymilkshake5
isaiah40 - Gilligan, jak111, thehippo, CMS, some7, spartacus - (L3)
thehippo8
Victor Sullivan
Some7hingCLEVER - isaiah - (L8)
TeeGee
new guy1
ghostly447 - newguy - (L8)
NoSurvivors
Gilligan
kiwi3 - Leehar - (L8)
Leehar
jak111
jonty125
Nebuchadnezer

With 16 alive it takes 9 to make someone walk the plank.

Deadline: None yet. We'll see how this day goes.

Should Gilligan's vote be removed considering black is a color?

[jonty125]

Do you have any reason to believe that hes not mafia?

Other than mafia's favourite claim being VT, no. But he has claimed something that can be tested, so if he is mafia and begins making up stuff we know we have scum.

[thehippo8]

Do you have any reason to believe that hes not mafia?

Other than mafia's favourite claim being VT, no. But he has claimed something that can be tested, so if he is mafia and begins making up stuff we know we have scum.

How do you propose that he does something that we are likely to know? He's lied once, why would he stop? More's the point, your argument doesn't stack up either. FoS jonty!

[Leehar]

Do you have any reason to believe that hes not mafia?

Other than mafia's favourite claim being VT, no. But he has claimed something that can be tested, so if he is mafia and begins making up stuff we know we have scum.

How do you propose that he does something that we are likely to know? He's lied once, why would he stop? More's the point, your argument doesn't stack up either. FoS jonty!

Because there are other Power roles that can catch him out in a lie?

[kiwi3]

If we are pointing fingers at people who are inactive what about TeeGee? Is that person even on the same ship?

[Leehar]

Yeah, I wanted to mention her/him as well, but tg posted at the end of the page before, so it seemed a bit nonsensical to call out for inactivity that soon even if overall comments have been few and far between