Coheed & Cambria mafia - Town Winnn.

[Skittles!]

Deadline is now imposed. Day 1 ends on Friday 22nd August, 2008. 4 PM, GMT +10

Edit: Oh, I was fastposted. f*ck you.

[Sierra_Leon]

Come on ya slackers! Let's get some arguements going!
Otherwise, it may be needed Skittles impose a deadline. Actually, I think he should place a deadine because otherwise no one will be enticed to voice their opinions and this will drag on indefinetly.
I think a dano lynch may be reasonable, but I will have a re-read before throwing a vote his way.

I don't agree with a dano-lynch. I would be happy lynching pancake or a submariner.

[Skoffin]

Can I has reasons?

[Sierra_Leon]

Yes, you can has.

vote illiad

I was looking back and checking some stuff out
but I'm pretty sure that Dr. Hohenberger DID indeed die

I'll trust you on that and Unvote (if needed) Vote Iliad

This looks to me like you're saying "I'm going to get Iliad lynched and blame it on danodukebb if he turns up town." Very scummy. Vote PCM.

If PCM is scum and was setting it up to blame Iliad's lynch on dano, that would lead me to conclude both Iliad and dano are most likely town.

[jnd94]

Makes sense actually. Vote PCM

[ga7]

Well, we fortunately have a quite decent deadline and some time still, and the PCM thing looks as good as any so far. If PCM is scum, it might well be very unlikely for Dano to be also, but if PCM is town we learn nothing. Meanwhile I'd like to hear more of Mili and Selin, they're submarining ftw.

[sheepofdumb]

Wait, what's this about trusting canon and expecting the mod to keep to it? If the mafia game could use a Hohenberger role then the mod will make one even if he's dead in the comics or not.

[pancakemix]

So you're assuming that I would blame dano if Iliad was town? Sure, I might hold him accountable, but I wouldn't want his head over it. If I really wanted to, I would look up the theme myself ad make a judgment off of that. All you're doing is imposing your own opinion of my plans on to what I've said. Maybe you're thinking a bit much like a scum yourself, hm?

[Sierra_Leon]

So you're assuming that I would blame dano if Iliad was town? Sure, I might hold him accountable, but I wouldn't want his head over it. If I really wanted to, I would look up the theme myself ad make a judgment off of that.

Of course you say that now, but I read your post (where you voted Iliad) differently.

I also note that you never made any real statement about anyone until I started suspecting you, at which point you immediately started trying to discredit me.

All you're doing is imposing your own opinion of my plans on to what I've said. Maybe you're thinking a bit much like a scum yourself, hm?

I don't feel I'm imposing my opinion on anyone. I'm voicing my opinion, and I try to make people understand why I am of that opinion. I also listen to other people and I don't avoid discussions (like this one, for instance). This is what the game is all about. Please do explain how you feel that's scummy.

[Anarkistsdream]

Sorry, Pancake, but Sierra's reply to you just won me over...

Vote: Pancake

[pancakemix]

Saying I trust him =/= going to lynch him if he's wrong. And it's day one. I never suspect anyone on Day 1 unless they do something scummy. Possible fake claim = scummy.

And I meant by that post that you are thing like a scum would. Thinking up scum strategies is not exactly something a townsperson ought to do. You're deciding what a scum would do, taking what I'm doing one step too far, and trying to get me lynched for it. Don't you think there's something odd about that?

I think it's weird that you're the only one trying to make serious discussions. Often, that's not really a bad thing, but it is here because 1. It's Day 1 and 2. You're pulling them out of nowhere. I can understand the thing with Iliad, but you did discount the fact that he could have been sincerely joking, writing it off like a scum excuse, which was unwise. I only voted him for his claim. There should never be anything wrong with trusting the theme. Right then, as soon as that avenue doesn't pan out, you turn to your next target. I don't see how that ISN'T scummy.

Unvote Vote Sierra because even though it looks OMGUS, I'm convinced he's not pro-town.

[ga7]

Vote Pancake mostly because he seems a bit overdefensive. I don't see much wrong with Sierra's act so far, reading far into things to create leads is something a townie oughta do when there's not many ideas. The whole argument that it's scum thinking is pretty weak. I'm used to think like a townie when scum and think like a scum when town

[danodukebb]

so let me get this right...if PCM turns out scum you all are automatically going to ASSUME I'm scum...

[sheepofdumb]

so let me get this right...if PCM turns out scum you all are automatically going to ASSUME I'm scum...

No, not at all. We'll wait till day 3 and kill you off.

Pancake would look scummy if he blamed dano if illiad turned out to be town and would get lynched as soon as day came around. Sierra jumps on this opportunity in what looks like scummy resolve to me.

I don't like the bandwagon on pancake. Do with it as you please. If he turns out to be town Sierra gets my vote.

[danodukebb]

if they're going to vote for me because I thought that Illiad was scum thats dumb...do you guys not remember me leaving and then unvoting?

[Skittles!]

Vote count:

Sierra_leon (2) - Iliad, pancakemix
Mandalorian2298 (2) - militant, Clive
FloreDelMal (1) - mandalorian2298
Iliad (1) - FloresDelMal
Anarkistsdream (1) - Skoffin
pancakemix (3) - Sierra_Leon, Anarkistdream, ga7
No-lynch (1) - danodukebb

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.

Deadline, Friday 4PM GMT+10

[Skoffin]

Actually Dano, as I understand it if PCM comes up scum they would be more likely to believe you to be town. Skimmar

I don't agree with the PCM bandwagon at all. To me it seems like Sierra is clutching at straws, first jumping on Iliad over a joke and now jumping on PCM on what he assumes PCM was thinking when he voted.
And I can't help but notice Narkyboy is following along with it and not saying a great deal, certainly not the Nark we all know and love eh?

And Pancake, Sierra's the only one making SRS discussion? Hmpf. I made srs assesments on the game just a few pages ago, but it seems like only one person even read it

[danodukebb]

btw i wasn't skimming but i see what your saying about narky and sl...

[Skoffin]

Echo echo echo...

[Selin]

I've just finished rereading/analysing insomniac mafia and will reread this one tonight and post accordingly.

.

[Anarkistsdream]

Well, I'll say this... I am pro-town.

I would tell you my role, but the way Skittles made it sound it may actually be important.

I can say that I am looking for a specific character, and that character is scum.

I am not posting because I am trying to figure out who this person is...

Maybe a vig will kill him or he'll get lynched first. *shrug*

[militant]

1.

I'm enjoying this day 1 squabble. That alone is reason enough not to vote Mando.

6 more to lynch Militant. Go go go!

2.

There's a deadline all of a sudden? I don't see militant getting lynched in under 20 hours, but I'm also opposed to rushing a mandy-lynch. After he gives us a claim, we would need to discuss whether it's believable or if we should lynch him, and I don't see that happening with that little time. We would still have a no-lynch in the end. I will vote mandy if the deadline gets postponed for 2 or 3 days.

Unvote. Vote deadline extension.

3.

Dude, how long have you played mafia with me? I almost never claim! Of course, I have claimed in Godfather, butI think that we can all agree that that claim prooves I shouldn't claim. I'm certainly not going to claim on Day 1 while I'm pressed with powerful proofs against me that consist of the fact that Militant likes my name, Skoffin is ashamed to admit that she likes all things pink&fluffy and Flores likes to scream 'Yeee bandwagon'.

P.S. Ditocoaf needs replacing since he hasn't posted anything so far.

I'm looking forward to see how you'll be avoiding your lynch this time, if not by claiming.

Vote mandy

4.

Sorry I'm late in posting.
Actually I agree, the claim does seem rather unlikely given the size of the game.
it's not even listed on wikipedia.

Are you using the fact that it's not listed on wikipedia as a point against mandy? Because this argument actually supports his claim. Where else do people look when coming up with a fake claim?

I'm joining ga7 and going back to voting the sad victim of an inevitable day 1 random lynch. Vote militant.

Now, I was suspicious of Sierra at the beginning of the day, he was extremely persistent in getting me lynched (see quote 1), upon the deadline being kinda shorter than he first expected, he would rather lynch a good player who just happens to be getting bandwagoned for no real reasons, then lynching me, the person he has been banging on about lynching, a sudden change of heart made me a little suspicious of him then. Then he votes Mandy, once again just giving up on me to see how he will defend himself As soon as Iliad claims it is back to me, I am the "inevitable random day 1 lynch", now forgetting Mandy. For now Fos Sierra for all this mind changing and throwing his vote around a lot.

[militant]

Well, I'll say this... I am pro-town.

I would tell you my role, but the way Skittles made it sound it may actually be important.

I can say that I am looking for a specific character, and that character is scum.

I am not posting because I am trying to figure out who this person is...

Maybe a vig will kill him or he'll get lynched first. *shrug*

What brought on the claim?

Regarding the last line, you make it sound like your objective is not to kill your target, so what is your objective?, do you just have to select him or something, and also, even though you may have a extra objective to complete on top of the normal win condition everybody has, why does that stop you posting a lot, you could still post and look for your target, it may even make it easier, asking certain questions to get information, not posting much does not seem like a very good thing for you to do at this point

[sheepofdumb]

Because I forgot to FOS Sierra.

Well, I'll say this... I am pro-town.

I would tell you my role, but the way Skittles made it sound it may actually be important.

I can say that I am looking for a specific character, and that character is scum.

I am not posting because I am trying to figure out who this person is...

Maybe a vig will kill him or he'll get lynched first. *shrug*

Ummmm... Ok? I want to know what brought on this. No one was asking about your role nark. Saying stuff like this will just get you killed faster by people who have the power to do so.

[Anarkistsdream]

And I can't help but notice Narkyboy is following along with it and not saying a great deal, certainly not the Nark we all know and love eh?

That, gentleman... and Sheep... is what brought it on...

Maybe if you wouldn't skim Skoffins post, you'd see I was replying to her implied question...