[SPECIAL] Surprise Mafia - Over - Mafia Wins - MVP Aladdin

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I'm on vacation with no internet.

Wings decided due to someone's action in game that all of a sudden out gifts can't be used during the day.

Bengals gift I told him to use on me to try to see what it comes up with. That way I can determine if I'm insane or if just random.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I received a blood testing kit. Benga was suppose to receive a free investigation to use. The blood testing kit gives off a color depending on what result it gives. Without knowing who sent it I won't be using it since it could be a bomb to me.

[degaston]

Vote benga

Because:

• He reported blood on IB's hands when he used LSU's glasses. This result may have actually been about him if LSU's inventions flip the user and the target.
• He said he investigated whatsausage during day because he was concerned about tainted results, then he investigated Rage during night.
• He claimed to receive a blood testing kit from LSU. Now LSU claims to have received one also, but says he gave benga an investigation, which benga hasn't mentioned.
• He would not say why he was unable to use the blood testing kit during the day. Now LSU answers for him.

It may not be terribly convincing, but there doesn't seem to be a more convincing argument against anyone else at this point. So perhaps the best reason to lynch benga is that whether he is town or scum, it would provide more information than any other lynch.

• If benga flips scum, then it's more likely that Rage is also scum, that rish and I are town, and that LSU's inventions flip the user and the target.
• If he's town, then that would confirm that his accusation against rish and I was sincere, that Rage is probably town, and his inventions work as described, and that we either don't understand LSU's inventions, or IB is a killer of some sort.

If I am lynched, I will flip town, and you will have learned nothing about whether you can trust benga, rish, rage, IB or LSU, or who you should lynch next. Same thing would be true if rish is lynched and flips town. I don't think the votes on Mitch, Mets, LSU or Aladdin are helpful, either. Almost nothing will be learned from lynching any of them. Unless Rage was able to make an invention that lied to its user, then you know that either benga, rish or I are scum, so the best chance for either lynching scum, or at least confirming some useful information, is to lynch benga.

[benga]

vote me and end this shit
game over soon anyway

[AladdinSane]

It's amazing what a good long sleep can do fer yer tinking processes. Yesterdee (my time) we saw a wagon of four form on me out of nowear in just about 9 hours. Apart from Mitch, who obviusly has his own reesons, CM, DJP, and Player all voted for me in what has to be a coordinamated attack. Orl thee have gone right through the game offering littul or no orijinal analisis. Orl tree remain untested by any investimagashuns or invenchuns. Orl tree failed to ofer eny solid reeson fer voting me. CM sed it was becorse I had corled fer him to say who we wanted to linch - but I did dat becorse he was criticol of my vote on Mitch, so it was nacherol for me to ask him who I shood vote fer insted. DJP just rambuled on about sum kind of trap and den voted fer me out of tin air. Player just sed it was becorse time was short and I had votes awreddy - eggsackly teh kind of ting she critisied peepul fer after teh Falko linch.

Teh ting dat was eluding me last night, but witch I now see, is teh WHY of it? Cleerly it has to be to protekt Deg by diverting attenshun to me and splitting teh vote in teh hope of either linchiing me or getting a no linch. I dont see eny other eggsplanashun dat makes sense. It orso eggsplains why teh vote is so diffuse dis time wen it hasent been before. I gave wot I tink were solid reesons fer voting Mitch, but sevral others have scatered votes about witout giving adekwate reesons.

My other thorts are dat IB is rite - orl dese votes scattered around is going to give Mafia a no linch unless we get it together reel soonish. Orso, I see Deg has voted Benga, witch is orso helping to diffuse teh vote. I'm now seeing CM, DJP, Player, and Deg as moor likely than not Mafia. Finorly, I dont see eny enthusiasm fer a Mitch linch, and littul fer a DJP linch (only TWR is advokating it rite now, and even he hasent voted fer DJP yet), so...

UNVOTE VOTE DEG

[rizky_biznezz]

i don't know what to do or who to vote... but we are running out of time... looks like benga has given up even though he isn't even close to being lynched right now...
anyone want to claim responsibility for LSUs gift and shed some light on it?

[madmitch]

UNVOTE VOTE DEG

[PLAYER57832]

vote me and end this shit
game over soon anyway

Afraid I agree, but i am trying to limp along to not ruin what is left for those still playing.
How long left until the deadline? I will try to pop back in and evaluate my vote before then, hoping we get a lynch.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Rish (1) - benga,
Deg (6) - Mets, LSU, Rage, IB, Mitch, Aladdin (L-2)
Mets (1) - /,
Benga (2) - TWR, Deg
Aladdin (3) - Catcher Mitt, DJ, Players
No lynch (1) - rish,

Not Voting (1) - Rizky,

8 to lynch. Deadline monday 29th 12:00 CC time

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I just received a message from the mod that I did NOT receive the item. It was a bcc of what the mod sent benga when I told them that I wanted benga to receive a free investigation to use at any time.

[the white rose]

2 things LSU, why can't he use it now then?

second why give it to benga? he has had the lions share of the gifts from both inventors, clearly there is fos on him, so the gift his useless, as benga himself (if scum) could give a fictional read, you could have doctored it, or it could flip like all your inventions seem to do.

much better to give it to someone he is more likely to be town, such as me.

[AladdinSane]

Rish (1) - benga,
Deg (6) - Mets, LSU, Rage, IB, Mitch, Aladdin (L-2)
Mets (1) - /,
Benga (2) - TWR, Deg
Aladdin (3) - Catcher Mitt, DJ, Players
No lynch (1) - rish,

Not Voting (1) - Rizky,

8 to lynch. Deadline monday 29th 12:00 CC time

Nit pick, don't know if it matters mutch: I voted Deg before Mitch did, so shood appeer before him in teh list.

[degaston]

vote me and end this shit
game over soon anyway

Classic scummy move.
Now all that townies will think: "We can't vote for benga now - that's just what he wants us to do!"

[Ragian]

Classy scummy move to pin a classy scummy move on someone else.

[Metsfanmax]

vote me and end this shit
game over soon anyway

Classic scummy move.
Now all that townies will think: "We can't vote for benga now - that's just what he wants us to do!"

In my experience when people throw their hands up and say "just lynch me," they're town about as often as they are scum.

[PLAYER57832]

Ok, looks like either its we lynch deg or no lynch. I don't want to intentionally put a break on the game, but I also don't see any gain by having no lynch today... it will only get worse.

So...VOTE DEG I rather think deg might be town, but I guess I am following the crowd, for good or ill. I was utterly wrong about wing, so maybe I am wrong now, too

[degaston]

Well, it looks like the scum are continuing to control the action here. I'm sure that one of them will hammer me shortly. This is what happens when townies don't participate.

Wing said not to lynch me, and town didn't listen to him. So I guess all I have to say is, whatever you do, don't lynch benga! Also, don't listen to TWR, the most confirmed town we have, and don't lynch Mets.

[CatchersMitt14]

I'm going to vote just to make sure there's a lynch today does not seem like a pro town move to me. I understand no lynch is not ideal but in my opinion it's the better option than for lost townies to jump on the scum bandwagoon. As I've stated, I really have no faith in the alignment indicatorator.

My vote is going to stay on Aladdin at the moment as I've already explained by reasoning there and think he's only shown his logic to be more faulty as the day draws to a close. I do think both player and LSU would be better lynches today than deg. I did appreciate and enjoy deg's read on benga and would definitly consider switching my vote there as well.

[benga]

Well, it looks like the scum are continuing to control the action here. I'm sure that one of them will hammer me shortly. This is what happens when townies don't participate.

Wing said not to lynch me, and town didn't listen to him. So I guess all I have to say is, whatever you do, don't lynch benga! Also, don't listen to TWR, the most confirmed town we have, and don't lynch Mets.

Yet another one to jump into his own mouth.

Anyway you have spent entire day giving reasons why i should be scum, cause jailer can't be one.

There is one thing that bothers me, how come storr died during day, it had to be poisoned.

[WingCmdr Ginkapo]

Rish (1) - benga,
Deg (7) - Mets, LSU, Rage, IB, Mitch, Aladdin, players (L-1)
Mets (1) - /,
Benga (2) - TWR, Deg
Aladdin (2) - Catcher Mitt, DJ,
No lynch (1) - rish,

Not Voting (1) - Rizky,

8 to lynch. Deadline monday 29th 12:00 CC time

[AladdinSane]

Rish (1) - benga,
Deg (7) - Mets, LSU, Rage, IB, Mitch, Aladdin, players (L-1)
Mets (1) - /,
Benga (2) - TWR, Deg
Aladdin (2) - Catcher Mitt, DJ,
No lynch (1) - rish,

Not Voting (1) - Rizky,

8 to lynch. Deadline monday 29th 12:00 CC time

Just to avoid posibul confusyun later, I want to point out dat Player fergot to UNVOTE before changing her vote:

Ok, looks like either its we lynch deg or no lynch. I don't want to intentionally put a break on the game, but I also don't see any gain by having no lynch today... it will only get worse.

So...VOTE DEG I rather think deg might be town, but I guess I am following the crowd, for good or ill. I was utterly wrong about wing, so maybe I am wrong now, too

Orso, I'm still listed as voting Deg after Mitch, rather than before.

Wear teh hell is RB? I'm farely shore he is Town, and we cant aford to lose another to Modkill.

[AladdinSane]

Sory, Deg is at L-1 and I'm geting cold feet. I'm witdrawing my vote wile I tink about it moor. Will chek back in before teh dedline, and if my vote is needed to hamer, will do it. I'm uncumfertabul been on a list with Mitch and Player.

I don't want a no linch, dis is just so I have a vote in, in case sumtink happens IRL and I dont make it back before teh dedline.

UNVOTE VOTE NO LINCH

BTW Rish, do you sewiously want no linch today???

[rizky_biznezz]

Been told I have to vote there isn't really any other choice besides a no lynch so vote deg

[the white rose]

well this is disappointing.

Seems that deg is gonna get lynched. I am not saying he is town, but if he flips town, we make no progress whatsoever and will have to decide tomorrow whether we lynch our claimed jailer or benga.

had we lynched benga today, no matter whether he flips town or scum we will learn from it. ie if town, we can believe that deg or rish are scum, if scum then it clears deg and rish.

I do hope we have guessed right, but i fear we may not have.

[the white rose]

my money is still on benga being scum, sigh, i hope i am wrong.