Bad Poets Society Mafia - Critics win!

[wicked]

boooo!!! well then don't play with me! but you were scum in the last two games I played! welcome to the Wicked Factor, i.e. "Tappy must be scum, he always is." Have fun with it, it's been a PITA for me.

[Selin]

i enjoyed the game,

thanks aimless and all of you

.

[autoload]

This was the most difficult mafia game for me to follow. Obviously a poet I am not.

Thanks for the high five Inc.

[Fircoal]

It was a good game, but my poems SUCKED!

[LSU Tiger Josh]

sigh i even had told mandy in that last go round don't lynch just b/c of names as we had done false ones before b/c of that and pointed out point blank how all hte evidence showed it as talapus. Kwanton also was a knucklehead by switching as a stalemate would've been better then giving away the game to scum.

[kwanton]

Bah. I just couldn't take it anymore. I was 100% sure that talapus was scum but the poems were rotting away my mind and I cracked under pressure.

[wicked]

kwanton, you ass.

[kwanton]

kwanton, you ass.

lol yep that's me.

[mandalorian2298]

Worst Strategy Evah Award goes to Mandy in his closeminded "out the cop" routine. I wasn't sure whether to even acknowledge that.

And next time I'm going with my gut! Tappy all the way! lol

I didn't KNOW that you are Cop. I knew that you are either Cop or scum. So, I put it to a test.

[Selin]

Worst Strategy Evah Award goes to Mandy in his closeminded "out the cop" routine. I wasn't sure whether to even acknowledge that.

And next time I'm going with my gut! Tappy all the way! lol

I didn't KNOW that you are Cop. I knew that you are either Cop or scum. So, I put it to a test.

...and you got a quick response

.

[mandalorian2298]

Worst Strategy Evah Award goes to Mandy in his closeminded "out the cop" routine. I wasn't sure whether to even acknowledge that.

And next time I'm going with my gut! Tappy all the way! lol

I didn't KNOW that you are Cop. I knew that you are either Cop or scum. So, I put it to a test.

...and you got a quick response

.

Look, I personaly had no chance to find the last scum. Talapus was the only one for whom I was sure is townie.

[Talapus]

Look, I personaly had no chance to find the last scum. Talapus was the only one for whom I was sure is townie.

Thankfully, when it all came down to it, that's all that mattered.....
As long as I had one person convinced, then we'd have a stale mate, Kwaton's vote was just icing on the cake.

[wicked]

that's the thing mandy, and why something like that will get you lynched... townies don't need to go outing the cop, that's just dumb b/c you had no clue who was who, and that was obvious...lol. hell I didn't either, which is why it took me so long to get a "hit"..lol. If I would've survived one more day, we would've won. it would've gotten you lynched here if exile hadn't already shown up as the lead critic.

This game was hard for me b/c I had no desire to go check poem styles and compare against what was written. that and the fact that peeps weren't writing much b/c it took too much effort. at first I really tried, but that only last a few days...lol. plus it was hard to drop clues or pick up on subtleties with the forced verse.

[mandalorian2298]

that's the thing mandy, and why something like that will get you lynched... townies don't need to go outing the cop, that's just dumb b/c you had no clue who was who, and that was obvious...lol. hell I didn't either, which is why it took me so long to get a "hit"..lol. If I would've survived one more day, we would've won. it would've gotten you lynched here if exile hadn't already shown up as the lead critic.

This game was hard for me b/c I had no desire to go check poem styles and compare against what was written. that and the fact that peeps weren't writing much b/c it took too much effort. at first I really tried, but that only last a few days...lol. plus it was hard to drop clues or pick up on subtleties with the forced verse.

I wouldn't have done it, were we not on LYLO. What good is a Cop if she is one of two prime subjects on a LYLO Day?! Anything you said during Day 5 would be considered "True or scum". Say you investigated Talapus and got scum. How could have we checked if you are honest. Lynch you tommorow if you are wrong? There was no tommorow!

I understend that you don't like being the scape goat and I know that I lost us the game. Feel free to complain, but looking at it only from the strategic point of view, I stand by my decision. I haven't fucked up untill the last Day, or rather (since Talapus was the one I trusted the most) I was completly outplayed by Talapus. That's all.

[wicked]

you were the only one that suspected me Mandy. I investigated Tap the night I was killed, and I'm damn sure I could've gotten a lynch on him the next day. I had already breadcrumbed your "clear" investigation. there's still no good reason to out a cop unless you're scum, at least not in this game.

I've learned in mafia, you can't be closeminded at all... and a guess is just a guess, no matter how much you may believe it.

[mandalorian2298]

you were the only one that suspected me Mandy. I investigated Tap the night I was killed, and I'm damn sure I could've gotten a lynch on him the next day. I had already breadcrumbed your "clear" investigation. there's still no good reason to out a cop unless you're scum, at least not in this game.

I've learned in mafia, you can't be closeminded at all... and a guess is just a guess, no matter how much you may believe it.

Bah, if we continue to argument our opinions, this could become one long and pointless debate so:

I know you are, but what am I.

[wicked]

Vote Mandy

[mandalorian2298]

Vote Mandy

Ha! This proves that you were a Naive Cop. Whew, and I almost started feeling bad.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Night one lasted all of one real night
The other nights also all took
two or less to complete. We
have lost our cop and doc.
Only one to hold
it would be the
scum. You sir
are still
scum

Edit by post

Vote Talapus as critics would stick
together near the end and not
vote for the other scum in
the cafe. Not to mention
Talapus has not
been on much the
last couple
of slow
nights

Mandy unless you are scum you are
VERY mistaken as my role
the whole time has been clear in
going after scum each
time as since I joined
the two dead scum
went with me
voting
each


In regards to wicked yes I was
wrong in thinking she was scum, but
the reasons I laid out could
fit as she had voted
on two townies on
the first two days
Hammers
I have
done.



She changed her investigation two
days ago to me as I was the
second person in this role
to accuse her, which I
understand she got
town as she did
not cast a
vote on
me



Talapus was also the last one
she voted as critic before
I convinced her to vote on
the two proven critics.
She said critic was
he on the page
twenty four.
So Vote
Tal



Mandy is an imbecile in this
game unless he turns out to be
scum. Why would scum come in and
hammer two fellow scum
in two days? The night
was long I was
around as
was our
mod


Mandy, Kwanton Aimless, and myself
were all here the last few days. There
was no reason to have such
a long night unless scum
Talapus had not
been on to choose
who to kill.
Use your
BRAIN.


Disgusted I am over Mandy's
stupidity in this game. Why
would scum use the same case twice
when it did not work the
first time. No more posts
will I do as
I have shown
you the
light.


Should I go ahead and die here that
we have already lynched one false
scum from the name bit. The loss
will fall fully on Mand
for ignoring my
actions in the
game to kill/
hammer
scum

My evidence Mandy. No offense to Talapus, but the loss wasn't due to him outplaying you as you just went braindead at the end. Normally you play a lot more intelligent, but this game you just blew it. These are posts I did on that last day to try to help you not do the stupid thing with the most important evidences I gave being (I hammered scum 2x in a row), Tal not being on hence the extra long night when the other nights were quicker, and pointing out that we had already falsely lynched b/c of names in this game.

[mandalorian2298]

Night one lasted all of one real night
The other nights also all took
two or less to complete. We
have lost our cop and doc.
Only one to hold
it would be the
scum. You sir
are still
scum

Edit by post

Vote Talapus as critics would stick
together near the end and not
vote for the other scum in
the cafe. Not to mention
Talapus has not
been on much the
last couple
of slow
nights

Mandy unless you are scum you are
VERY mistaken as my role
the whole time has been clear in
going after scum each
time as since I joined
the two dead scum
went with me
voting
each


In regards to wicked yes I was
wrong in thinking she was scum, but
the reasons I laid out could
fit as she had voted
on two townies on
the first two days
Hammers
I have
done.



She changed her investigation two
days ago to me as I was the
second person in this role
to accuse her, which I
understand she got
town as she did
not cast a
vote on
me



Talapus was also the last one
she voted as critic before
I convinced her to vote on
the two proven critics.
She said critic was
he on the page
twenty four.
So Vote
Tal



Mandy is an imbecile in this
game unless he turns out to be
scum. Why would scum come in and
hammer two fellow scum
in two days? The night
was long I was
around as
was our
mod


Mandy, Kwanton Aimless, and myself
were all here the last few days. There
was no reason to have such
a long night unless scum
Talapus had not
been on to choose
who to kill.
Use your
BRAIN.


Disgusted I am over Mandy's
stupidity in this game. Why
would scum use the same case twice
when it did not work the
first time. No more posts
will I do as
I have shown
you the
light.


Should I go ahead and die here that
we have already lynched one false
scum from the name bit. The loss
will fall fully on Mand
for ignoring my
actions in the
game to kill/
hammer
scum

My evidence Mandy. No offense to Talapus, but the loss wasn't due to him outplaying you as you just went braindead at the end. Normally you play a lot more intelligent, but this game you just blew it. These are posts I did on that last day to try to help you not do the stupid thing with the most important evidences I gave being (I hammered scum 2x in a row), Tal not being on hence the extra long night when the other nights were quicker, and pointing out that we had already falsely lynched b/c of names in this game.

I didn't belive you any more, because I got the impression that you are trying to avert the lynch from Exile. Your droping the hammer both times didn't help, since mafia usualy are among the last ones to vote their buddy (when they realize that the ship has sunk, they try to buy credibility by joining in).

[LSU Tiger Josh]

perhaps, but at same time I also gave you the reminder of not lynching solely b/c of names and most importantly explained why the night took so long. That was the biggest sign of evidence that you could get other then investigating yourself and getting a reading saying SCUM as you, Kwanton, Aimless, and myself had ALL been around c.c. while Tal had not especially after I pointed out that all of the other nights were "short" so Aimless wasn't just waiting for 36+ hours for the sake of waiting that long. He needed the info. In regards to the hammer two times I would take that as a pretty damn good sign that someone is town as scum at that point was at -0 away from winning the game. Scum would've tried to leave the lynch or go after someone else and not worry about trying to get scum at that juncture.

[mandalorian2298]

perhaps, but at same time I also gave you the reminder of not lynching solely b/c of names and most importantly explained why the night took so long. That was the biggest sign of evidence that you could get other then investigating yourself and getting a reading saying SCUM as you, Kwanton, Aimless, and myself had ALL been around c.c. while Tal had not especially after I pointed out that all of the other nights were "short" so Aimless wasn't just waiting for 36+ hours for the sake of waiting that long. He needed the info. In regards to the hammer two times I would take that as a pretty damn good sign that someone is town as scum at that point was at -0 away from winning the game. Scum would've tried to leave the lynch or go after someone else and not worry about trying to get scum at that juncture.

Speaking of Night: 1) I would never make a decision based on who is or isn't on site. For all I knew, you delayed your vote intetionaly to cast the blame on him. 2) The reason why I would vote Kwanton, had I not set my mind about voting you was:

(kwanton (2) - The2exile, Talapus I wonder who's next lol)

Posted during the Night and your "Bump."
Night is the time to shut up and stay away from the thread.

[Aimless]

You know, to change the topic entirely, and to point out something obvious but also (IMHO) amazing - this game generated thirty three pages of poetry! And maybe half a pages worth was actually good!

Not bad for a game I half expected to die before the end of the first day.

[Fircoal]

You know, to change the topic entirely, and to point out something obvious but also (IMHO) amazing - this game generated thirty three pages of poetry! And maybe half a pages worth was actually good!

Not bad for a game I half expected to die before the end of the first day.

That's refence to my peoms.

[Incandenza]

Are you kidding? My horrific terza rima had Dante rolling in his grave. I never even tried to have any real syllable consistency. I would rate my poesy at about a B-.... Fircoal, you just had a really rough scheme to work with, not to mention the fact that I still have no idea who Jill Laumer is.

(oh, and huzzah for the mafia! )