jnd94 wrote:i also dont think that you should vote for someone just cuz they are acting different than other games. Sure, thats important, but if you let it cloud your judgement, you wont make a good choice.
I've played lots of mafia games by now, and it is a good way to get a lead, as I hope some of the other expeienced mafia players will agree with. Sure, there are other ways, but not in the early days without much knowledge of voting patterns, roles and cop investigations. In short, saying I won't make a good choce is not neccesarily true.
got tonkaed wrote:hey aimless, i know most of the roles...but what does a janitor do?
The Mafia Janitor cleans up the body after a kill - basically, they make it so that only the mafia knows the role of the dead guy. Mandalorian died as an unknown role, ergo the mafia have a janitor, and mandalorian was killed by the mafia.
No i understand the idea behind it exile, im just not sure if its helpful to the town in the games where they are not scummy. I actually remember aimless being scum in the film noir mafia game which is why i dont necesarily agree with your hes not acting as normal, he played that one similiarily to this one so far, being active and out in the open where people could see him. Theres certainly time to vote for him still, im just not quite sure that im there yet.
jnd sometimes you can pick up on a players style if they have played long enough, if exile thinks this is aimless's mafia style i dont really have that much of a complaint, everyones reads of each others style is somewhat subjective.
The1exile wrote:Also, the odds are that by now aimless should have hada mafia role, yet I can't find a game where he was mafia to compare his behaviour. He's not acting the same as normal, which makes me a bit suspicious. Finally, when I'm mafia the first person I usually target is aimless beause he's so skilled at mafia - the fact that he's still alive looks even more scummy.
that could be true jnd we just wont know much more about it unless there is some night that a sk/vig doesnt get blocked thats all. It would seem pretty likely that there is one of the two if not both in the game, at least i would think there is given the size.
The1exile wrote:Also, the odds are that by now aimless should have hada mafia role, yet I can't find a game where he was mafia to compare his behaviour. He's not acting the same as normal, which makes me a bit suspicious. Finally, when I'm mafia the first person I usually target is aimless beause he's so skilled at mafia - the fact that he's still alive looks even more scummy.
I was mafia in the Film Noir game.
Bah, I knew I shoulda looked harder.
Still, as Incandenza proved conclusively, the best mafia players can look helpful, and still be scum.
Aegnor wrote:Do we have more than one cop in games like these? Because we lynched one..
Probably. Although, we might just have a deputy with no investigative powers (deputies receive the cop's investigations after he dies), which wouldn't help us here.
jnd94 wrote:
mandalorian being killed was a shock to me. I thought that others would be killed by the mafia before him. Or maybe there is a sk or vigilante?
Well, thank you for being shocked by my death. I found it something quite sudden, as well. And unpleasant.
Mishuk gotal'u meshuroke, pako kyore.
Talapus wrote:
I'm far more pissed that mandy and his thought process were right from the get go....damn you mandy.
Well I see two sides to mandys death. Aimless could have done it so people would think that he couldn't have done it because he'd have to be an idiot to do something like that. Like they are now. Or someone framed him. Like everyone is saying. I think I'm just summing it all up.
It seems to me that Mandalorian was killed not only to frame another player, i.e. Aimless, but that the doctor was roleblocked from trying to save him...
virus90 wrote: I think Anarkist is a valuable asset to any game.
