LOST Mafia - Day 5 - cena-rules abducted!

[Sentinel XIV]

I'm not scum. I'm sorry if I appear that way. Like I said, I'm waiting to see if there is a counter-claim for nagerous' claim. As far as cena goes, I'm just questioning his excuse. It just seems weird that he would rush a PM that he didn't feel he should post just because the doorbell rang.

[Sentinel XIV]

I'm not scum. I'm sorry if I appear that way. Like I said, I'm waiting to see if there is a counter-claim for nagerous' claim. As far as cena goes, I'm just questioning his excuse. It just seems weird that he would rush a PM that he didn't feel he should post just because the doorbell rang.

Also, I explained my vote for gimpy and the situation with voting for tests. The vote for tests was an innocent want for more information. That and I thought he may have been a bomb.

[pmchugh]

Also, I explained my vote for gimpy and the situation with voting for tests. The vote for tests was an innocent want for more information. That and I thought he may have been a bomb.

how could you have thought he was a bomb we had a time limit not a hammer as such he could not have been a bomb it doent make any sense and of course you are going to say i only wanted more info!

I am going back to read your reasons for voting gimpy because you are looking very scummy at the moment.

[Sentinel XIV]

I'll tell you my reason for voting gimpy.

I thought his initial "I'm voting for a new player because he's new" vote was scummy. I didn't know that that's how it happens around here on the first day.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Ok I missed the post that cena made, but reality this is pissing me off if someone is breaking the rule and some of the people in the game are gaining advantage of reading that and then having it edited over. AD if cena fucked up with posting it then he should either be modkilled for it or else his post should've been left for EVERYONE else to see. I'll pass on voting at this time until more info comes.

[/]

I missed it too, aww I really like reading role PMs too, mine was good.
but anyways, cena's bandwaggon of nag is still suspicious, especially with those who jumped on it very early with next to no reason, but to confirm "Things".

[Ditocoaf]

Ok I missed the post that cena made, but reality this is pissing me off if someone is breaking the rule and some of the people in the game are gaining advantage of reading that and then having it edited over. AD if cena fucked up with posting it then he should either be modkilled for it or else his post should've been left for EVERYONE else to see. I'll pass on voting at this time until more info comes.

I agree it is quite vexing that some people have seen two role pms now (besides their own), and others haven't seen any. I don't really see any solution, though, other than acknowledging that those two people are ridiculously incompetent.

[Sentinel XIV]

I missed it too, aww I really like reading role PMs too, mine was good.
but anyways, cena's bandwaggon of nag is still suspicious, especially with those who jumped on it very early with next to no reason, but to confirm "Things".

To be honest, I jumped the gun by putting such an early vote on nagerous without allowing him to defend himself. However, since he's made his claim, I'm suspicious of him. Just waiting to see if there is a counter-claim.

[cmckinney]

The claim itself seems to fit, considering Jack was a doctor.

Now all there is to do is to wait and see if somebody counter claims

[rebelman]

his role claim is false

unvote vote nag

[nagerous]

huh? elaborate? There might be two doctors.

[rebelman]

huh? elaborate? There might be two doctors.

here is my logic:

cena suggested voting you because he knew things

cena fecked up his post

ad made him change it

you lost the plot because you thought cena had revealed your identity even though he hadnt !

if cena had posted you were jack and we should lynch you that would be akin to cena admitting he was scum

cena is a dope but not that much of a dope

Q.E.D. - there is no way you could be jack even if noone role claims and they still might roe claim as jack is bound to be in this game

[/]

that's terrible logic, what most of us are assuming right now is that Cena is an Insane cop who got the alignment wrong, he did not, to my knowledge claim Nag's job, You seem to want to lynch a claimed doc.
Vote rebelman

[cmckinney]

well...i quite frankly didn't understand a word that rebelman just said. But either way, odds are that somebody has gotten the role of Jack. And sooner later, they're gonna show up and bust Nagerous's claim (if it is false)

[Neoteny]

Ok I missed the post that cena made, but reality this is pissing me off if someone is breaking the rule and some of the people in the game are gaining advantage of reading that and then having it edited over. AD if cena fucked up with posting it then he should either be modkilled for it or else his post should've been left for EVERYONE else to see. I'll pass on voting at this time until more info comes.

Having seen the post, I do agree with this just in principle.

[Ditocoaf]

Actually, what rebelman said kind of makes sense to me… if nag really was jack, why would he be as upset about cena’s PM quote as he was in this post?:

Cena should be modkilled for that stunt, editing won't do nothing now as you just revealed all he said must be true Nark.

Thanks a ton.

He then proceeded to vote himself, and claimed to be quitting.
It seems to me that nag gave up at one point, then thought of a way to defend himself and so recovered. I’m not ready to vote him for it, but it does make a lot of sense.

[lord voldemort]

huh? elaborate? There might be two doctors.

here is my logic:

cena suggested voting you because he knew things

cena fecked up his post

ad made him change it

you lost the plot because you thought cena had revealed your identity even though he hadnt !

if cena had posted you were jack and we should lynch you that would be akin to cena admitting he was scum

cena is a dope but not that much of a dope

Q.E.D. - there is no way you could be jack even if noone role claims and they still might roe claim as jack is bound to be in this game

vote rebel

everyone doubts cena's sanity i mean desmond as sane cop highly unlikely.
and cena would not have learnt nags role
i think nag flipped off because he hasnt been lynched since september lol
a lil dissapointed it went that far. if we logically talked about it then we could of avoided a claim
im interested in what mandy knows to make him go along with cena

[lord voldemort]

huh? elaborate? There might be two doctors.

here is my logic:

cena suggested voting you because he knew things

cena fecked up his post

ad made him change it

you lost the plot because you thought cena had revealed your identity even though he hadnt !

if cena had posted you were jack and we should lynch you that would be akin to cena admitting he was scum

cena is a dope but not that much of a dope

Q.E.D. - there is no way you could be jack even if noone role claims and they still might roe claim as jack is bound to be in this game

vote rebel

everyone doubts cena's sanity i mean desmond as sane cop highly unlikely.
and cena would not have learnt nags role
i think nag flipped off because he hasnt been lynched since september lol
a lil dissapointed it went that far. if we logically talked about it then we could of avoided a claim
im interested in what mandy knows to make him go along with cena

EBWOP

[Fircoal]

First off I agree with LSU, Cena should be modkilled. It's not fair otherwise.

ok, as for Nag's claim, while I had Rebel's thoughts at first there are two things that make me think that Nag is town, first of the the fact that no one counter claimed Jack yet, which I have another idea about that which would make Nag scum, and that William claimed Nag as scum when he was a "cop." If Nag is Jack maybe William would know and wanted to get rid of him. Really that seems like the most plausible idea.

Also Sent was caught, he was going after Nag and Cena for relevity no reason compared to the fact they are both likely town. Unvote Vote: Sent I agree your whole ideas aren't good and reek of scumminess. #4...

AD I feel bad for you...

[Fircoal]

First off I agree with LSU, Cena should be modkilled. It's not fair otherwise.

ok, as for Nag's claim, while I had Rebel's thoughts at first there are two things that make me think that Nag is town, first of the the fact that no one counter claimed Jack yet, which I have another idea about that which would make Nag scum, and that William claimed Nag as scum when he was a "cop." If Nag is Jack maybe William would know and wanted to get rid of him. Really that seems like the most plausible idea.

Also Sent was caught, he was going after Nag and Cena for relevity no reason compared to the fact they are both likely town. Unvote Vote: Sent I agree your whole ideas aren't good and reek of scumminess. #4...

AD I feel bad for you...

EBWOP

[Sentinel XIV]

I have a question:

nagerous claimed he protected Selin, right? So, if he did so, wouldn't that count as a visit to Selin's house, in terms of being a Watcher?

[Neoteny]

I have a question:

nagerous claimed he protected Selin, right? So, if he did so, wouldn't that count as a visit to Selin's house, in terms of being a Watcher?

I would imagine so, under regular mafia circumstances, which I don't think this game would deviate too far from.

[Neoteny]

I have a question:

nagerous claimed he protected Selin, right? So, if he did so, wouldn't that count as a visit to Selin's house, in terms of being a Watcher?

I would imagine so, under regular mafia circumstances, from which I don't think this game would deviate too far.

EBWOP: never end a sentence with a preposition...

[Sentinel XIV]

I have a question:

nagerous claimed he protected Selin, right? So, if he did so, wouldn't that count as a visit to Selin's house, in terms of being a Watcher?

I would imagine so, under regular mafia circumstances, which I don't think this game would deviate too far from.

Well, if so, then that is why I question nagerous' claim. He did not visit Selin last night, according to Anarkistsdream.

[Neoteny]

I have a question:

nagerous claimed he protected Selin, right? So, if he did so, wouldn't that count as a visit to Selin's house, in terms of being a Watcher?

I would imagine so, under regular mafia circumstances, from which I don't think this game would deviate too far.

EBWOP: never end a sentence with a preposition...

Really, this whole sentence was terrible. I give up on it. I'm going to let it die.

Of course, I'm interested in hearing another response from nag.