Lord of the Rings mafia [Town wins]

[Iliad]

So we are mass-claiming. Still wondering why didn't we do this day 1, if it is inevitable.

[william18]

Lol galadrial. Im pretty confident Iliad is scum aswell

[Iliad]

God I love this. No need for an explanation, no, that's not necessary.

People seem to assume that all of the fellowship is in the game. It may be very likely that there is only 6 or 5 people from the fellowship, just so the game isn't broken by a mass-claim.

[karelpietertje]

you're right, we cannot know for sure which roles are there...
however, sam_levi and you both fail to put any extra info with your claim...
what are your special powers, what have you been up to from the beginning?

[Iliad]

you're right, we cannot know for sure which roles are there...
however, sam_levi and you both fail to put any extra info with your claim...
what are your special powers, what have you been up to from the beginning?

No-one has been doing that, except for gimli. Throughout the entire game everyone claimed by simply posting a pic. The fact that you suddenly demand information that you previously didn't care about seems scummy.

[karelpietertje]

you're right, we cannot know for sure which roles are there...
however, sam_levi and you both fail to put any extra info with your claim...
what are your special powers, what have you been up to from the beginning?

No-one has been doing that, except for gimli. Throughout the entire game everyone claimed by simply posting a pic. The fact that you suddenly demand information that you previously didn't care about seems scummy.

lol it's good that you defend yourself, but no reason to get into attack as well

the reason we want this info is because we do not really think that your role would be included in the game...
and of course you are right that we don't know the roles, but why couldn't you just explain the role and give some specifics, so we can identify the bad guys?

when I think somebody is not telling something I quickly start thinking that they are doing that because they have something to hide

[Simon Viavant]

I forget, who all has claimed so far?

Galadriel seems a bit of a suspicious claim as she doesn't really do anything action-wise.
And the whole fellowship has claimed except for Aragorn and Boromir, and I'm sure Aragorn at least is in it.

[AceArtemis]

you're right, we cannot know for sure which roles are there...
however, sam_levi and you both fail to put any extra info with your claim...
what are your special powers, what have you been up to from the beginning?

No-one has been doing that, except for gimli. Throughout the entire game everyone claimed by simply posting a pic. The fact that you suddenly demand information that you previously didn't care about seems scummy.

Trying to "blend in" by posting a picture? I find it interesting how you completely shifted your stance on picture-posting.

I did not fos him for the claim, but for the picture. Simply put I felt posting pictures instead of actual names could lead to degradation of the game. As I posted and explained in later posts. But hey, don't let that stop you.

I didn't want posting pictures to set a precedent and detract from the game later on
Player 1: I'm frodo
Player 2: Yeah-well post the picture in your pm
Player 1: *Picture*
Player 2: Aha! The size is wrong/you got it from google images/whatever. Lynch

I was afraid posting pictures instead of saying would start things like that. Instead of people playing mafia, people would be playing say the win condition word for word and post the picture in perfectly. Feel free to try and twist that.

Practice what you preach. If you don't like posting pictures because they detract from the game, don't post a picture. You won't be lynched just because you claim with words rather than a picture. I claimed with words and no picture, and I am still here.

I forget, who all has claimed so far?

-Claim List-
Clive- Legolas
AceArtemis- Merry
william18- Aragorn
Simon Viavant- Gimli
sam_levi_11- Eowyn
Iliad- Galadriel

-Unclaimed-
karelpietertje
Mr. Squirrel
Falkomagno

[Iliad]

Still feel it can lead to the wrong kind of game, but since everyone ignored that anyway, and we're playing Guess what role Stroop put in, I figured might as well.

[Clive]

Sam and Iliad's absolute refusal to roleclaim makes it probable they are the last 2 mafiates here.

I will go now.

I am a Tracker.

Night 1: Roleblocked
Night 2: Simon --> Suspect
Night 3: Sam --> Karelpietertje

Simon was telling the truth about his action and is probably town.

Vote: Sam

[Iliad]

Sam and Iliad's absolute refusal to roleclaim makes it probable they are the last 2 mafiates here.

I will go now.

I am a Tracker.

Night 1: Roleblocked
Night 2: Simon --> Suspect
Night 3: Sam --> Karelpietertje

Simon was telling the truth about his action and is probably town.

Vote: Sam

I can roleclaim, I've hardly seen anyone asking for a ful lrole. In fact you have insisted there won't be a full role-claim. Everyone is claiming vie pictures and so did I. The fact that I'm being singled out for some reason, is pretty damn weird.

Want me to claim, sure I would. Hell I didn't even know why we started with the mass-claim in the first place while mostly people seemd against it.

[Clive]

If Iliad had been reading my posts, he would know the only thing i'm interested in is a role claim. More evidence against him.

[Iliad]

Jesus, guys. Do you really think Stroop is going to have been incompetent enough to make the game breakable by a massclaim?

If you're that worried it's going to ruin the game, then we can forego character claiming, but there's no way in hell i'm allowing this game to be played to its conclusion without mass role claiming.

I expect Simon to claim in his next post.

William: Both effect and affect have a verb form and a noun form. In this context you are using the plural noun form of effect. "The ring affects hobbits less..." Would be a use of "affects".

You wanted to forego character claiming. And then everyone went along and claimed characters anyway.

Don't go all mob mentality, people. The people who have been accusing me and openly, instead of subjective post about how they thought I was scummy and immediately disappearing into the woodwork, when I asked why , have been pmchugh and Clive. Pmchugh who led the town, when I warned you guys that he was acting all scummy, and clive who claimed day 1, and then disappeared. Disappeared and then returned and is now trying to run town, just like pmchugh. The man who claimed with only a picture and is now trying to accuse other people for doing the same. The man who lurks half the game, and tries to accuse others of skimming.

Let's not follow another pmchugh.

[Clive]

Hahaha.

And still Iliad refuses to roleclaim.

[Iliad]

Hahaha.

And still Iliad refuses to roleclaim.

I'm a joat.

I blocked pmchugh night 1, and tried to investigate him and failed night 3.

[william18]

Hahaha.

And still Iliad refuses to roleclaim.

I'm a joat.

I blocked pmchugh night 1, and tried to investigate him and failed night 3.

What about night 2?

[Mr. Squirrel]

Hahaha.

And still Iliad refuses to roleclaim.

I'm a joat.

I blocked pmchugh night 1, and tried to investigate him and failed night 3.

What about night 2?

He probably didn't do anything. Probably decided to save his abilities for another night.

[spiesr]

So, I finally return, only to find that I have been dead all along...

[Simon Viavant]

We know Sam is in this, and I think Boromir probably would be too, or if he wasn't Eowyn and Galadriel aren't the choices I'd expect for the only two non-fellowship characters, so basically, we know either sam or Iliad or both are lying. Eowyn seems much more plausible to me.

Vote Iliad

Looks way more suspicious than sam to me. If he's town we can lynch sam tomorrow and I'll block him tonight.

[william18]

Yeah, im sure Iliad is The Black captian.

Vote Iliad

[Mr. Squirrel]

We know Sam is in this, and I think Boromir probably would be too, or if he wasn't Eowyn and Galadriel aren't the choices I'd expect for the only two non-fellowship characters, so basically, we know either sam or Iliad or both are lying. Eowyn seems much more plausible to me.

Vote Iliad

Looks way more suspicious than sam to me. If he's town we can lynch sam tomorrow and I'll block him tonight.

Yeah, im sure Iliad is The Black captian.

Vote Iliad

I'll wait until I hear a bit more from both Iliad and Sam before I place my vote. I'm finding sam's recent silence especially scummy. He might just be giving up as fircoal did when he took over for thez.

Who's next?

[Simon Viavant]

Iliad, what exactly does your role do?

[william18]

Iliad, what exactly does your role do?

he says he's a jack-of-all-trades.

[Iliad]

Yes I am a jack of all trades. However you guys realise, that clive has already hammered right?

[Mr. Squirrel]

Yes I am a jack of all trades. However you guys realise, that clive has already hammered right?

Wow. There hasn't been a vote count in so long that I didn't even notice it. Looking back you are right. Sam was lynched when clive voted for him.