LOST Mafia - Day 5 - cena-rules abducted!

[Selin]

Mandy, as you have already roleclaimed, may I ask for your name?

.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Selin I forgot if I had voted earlier in the "day" so was just making sure that I had no "current vote".

[nagerous]

Word on the street is Nark's on a forum ban. Not sure when he'll be back, guess we'll just have to wait.

[mandalorian2298]

Mandy and Selin both make good points, but Mandy, you think Nag, and Sential are both scum. For two that seem to be against each other it doesn't make much sense?

There is a reason for me to consider both of them probable scum. Nag has been naimed by Cena, who claimed Cop. Basic Mafia math says that lynching Nag is a good move, since it will, if nothing else, tell us if we can trust Cena's investigations. I accused Sentinel because I have never played a game with more then one Watcher. Also, Watcher is pretty good claim for Scum, since it is often left out by mods.

Mandy, as you have already roleclaimed, may I ask for your name?

.

After Sentinel claims his name I will gladly claim mine. There would be no point for me to make it easy for him.

[Selin]

Mandy and Selin both make good points, but Mandy, you think Nag, and Sential are both scum. For two that seem to be against each other it doesn't make much sense?

There is a reason for me to consider both of them probable scum. Nag has been naimed by Cena, who claimed Cop. Basic Mafia math says that lynching Nag is a good move, since it will, if nothing else, tell us if we can trust Cena's investigations. I accused Sentinel because I have never played a game with more then one Watcher. Also, Watcher is pretty good claim for Scum, since it is often left out by mods.

Mandy, as you have already roleclaimed, may I ask for your name?

.

After Sentinel claims his name I will gladly claim mine. There would be no point for me to make it easy for him.

Mandy, you are pretty much skimming and this is not the first time you do so! That makes me more suspicious about you.

Sentinel already claimed his name.

.

[Sentinel XIV]

Mandy and Selin both make good points, but Mandy, you think Nag, and Sential are both scum. For two that seem to be against each other it doesn't make much sense?

There is a reason for me to consider both of them probable scum. Nag has been naimed by Cena, who claimed Cop. Basic Mafia math says that lynching Nag is a good move, since it will, if nothing else, tell us if we can trust Cena's investigations. I accused Sentinel because I have never played a game with more then one Watcher. Also, Watcher is pretty good claim for Scum, since it is often left out by mods.

Mandy, as you have already roleclaimed, may I ask for your name?

.

After Sentinel claims his name I will gladly claim mine. There would be no point for me to make it easy for him.

Mandy, you are pretty much skimming and this is not the first time you do so! That makes me more suspicious about you.

Sentinel already claimed his name.

.

I was just about to say the same. Check on the last page, I believe.

[Sentinel XIV]

mandalorian, your words are constructed to appear that you are saying, "I know that the person who visited pmchugh is a doctor." Look at your statement:

If you guys don't believe me, I can tell you whom I watch tonight, but I would prefer not tu since, I strongly believe that person might have been the Doc (he protected Pmchugh, hence the mysterious message from the begining of Day 2)."

If you were unsure if he was a doctor or not, you might have said, "I think he protected pmchugh." Perhaps you didn't think it would cause so much confusion, but it appears as if you are stating that they are a doctor, not that you think they are a doctor.

[Fircoal]

Mandy and Selin both make good points, but Mandy, you think Nag, and Sential are both scum. For two that seem to be against each other it doesn't make much sense?

There is a reason for me to consider both of them probable scum. Nag has been naimed by Cena, who claimed Cop. Basic Mafia math says that lynching Nag is a good move, since it will, if nothing else, tell us if we can trust Cena's investigations. I accused Sentinel because I have never played a game with more then one Watcher. Also, Watcher is pretty good claim for Scum, since it is often left out by mods.

Mandy, I see your logic, but together they don't make sense. Sential called Nag out as scum and that his actions were false. If they were scum together it would make no sense. Even if one was 3rd party and the other was scum, it doesn't make much sense for Sent to do that. I find it highly unlikely.

[cmckinney]

Mandy, are you saying that you don't believe Nag's role claim, and that you also believe that Cena is a sane cop?

[mandalorian2298]

Skimming? I? Never! I'm much too responsible and diligent to skimm.

Anyhow, from Wiki articile, Danielle Rousseau seems more like a Vig then like a Watcher to me (wow, I last saw Mira Furlan act in late 80's ).

My character is Miles Straume.

mandalorian, your words are constructed to appear that you are saying, "I know that the person who visited pmchugh is a doctor." Look at your statement:

If you guys don't believe me, I can tell you whom I watch tonight, but I would prefer not tu since, I strongly believe that person might have been the Doc (he protected Pmchugh, hence the mysterious message from the begining of Day 2)."

If you were unsure if he was a doctor or not, you might have said, "I think he protected pmchugh." Perhaps you didn't think it would cause so much confusion, but it appears as if you are stating that they are a doctor, not that you think they are a doctor.

When I know something I say that I know something. When I have compeling but inconclusive evidence of something, I say that I strongly believe something.

[cena-rules]

he seems more like a vig/forensic investigator to me

[cmckinney]

And wouldn't the freighter people be a 3rd party?

[cena-rules]

And wouldn't the freighter people be a 3rd party?

you make a good point

fos mandy
ill wait see if there is a counter

[pmchugh]

I am not bulletproof (to the best of my knowledge).

If I were AD there is no way that I would have made the frieghter people pro-town, third party at best. However I am not AD so who knows.

[Sentinel XIV]

Miles certainly doesn't seem to be pro-town, what with his arguments with Kate and threatening Jack with a gun. However, I don't watch the show, so I have no idea.

Man, I'm anxious for some of the weekend people to get back and put in their two cents. Right now, I'm leaning towards mandalorian for my vote, and I'm curious to see what others think about nagerous.

[cmckinney]

Miles certainly doesn't seem to be pro-town, what with his arguments with Kate and threatening Jack with a gun. However, I don't watch the show, so I have no idea.

Man, I'm anxious for some of the weekend people to get back and put in their two cents. Right now, I'm leaning towards mandalorian for my vote, and I'm curious to see what others think about nagerous.

Yeah...lots of people have kind of been on the down low. Possible submariners?

[Sentinel XIV]

Miles certainly doesn't seem to be pro-town, what with his arguments with Kate and threatening Jack with a gun. However, I don't watch the show, so I have no idea.

Man, I'm anxious for some of the weekend people to get back and put in their two cents. Right now, I'm leaning towards mandalorian for my vote, and I'm curious to see what others think about nagerous.

Yeah...lots of people have kind of been on the down low. Possible submariners?

I know a lot of people said they'd be gone for the weekend. No big deal to me. Anarkistsdream isn't back yet anyway.

[cmckinney]

Miles certainly doesn't seem to be pro-town, what with his arguments with Kate and threatening Jack with a gun. However, I don't watch the show, so I have no idea.

Man, I'm anxious for some of the weekend people to get back and put in their two cents. Right now, I'm leaning towards mandalorian for my vote, and I'm curious to see what others think about nagerous.

Yeah...lots of people have kind of been on the down low. Possible submariners?

I know a lot of people said they'd be gone for the weekend. No big deal to me. Anarkistsdream isn't back yet anyway.

Yeah, what'd he get banned 4?

[Sentinel XIV]

Not sure.

[Selin]

First a little background from the real Lost:

Miles Straume is a spiritualist and a member of the heli/boat team. He not only threatened Jack and Kate with a gun, but also entered into an agreement of 3'2 USD with Ben Linus (leader of others) to tell his own team that Ben is dead. He even wanted to take care of Charlotte (another member of heli/boat team) so that nobody can know that Ben is still alive.
The aim of heli/boat group is not %100 clear in the series. Ben Linus claims that their orders are to kill everyone on the island once Ben is captured. Miles know this and didn't argument against Ben when Ben told this in public.

Coming back to our game:

For certain we have the heli/boat team in our game setup. They are either the second mafia group or third party group, i.e. they have their own agenda (not the same as townies). In my opinion the heli/boat team will have 3-4 members, Naomi (leader), Frank (heli pilot), Daniel (physicist), Miles (spiritualist) are possible candidates. If we combine the information from mandy with the background of real Lost, Miles (mandy) is one of the most dangerous characters among them. He even betrays his own team!

My vote stays with Mandy.

PS: I will also write a similar post for Danielle Rousseau (Sentinel) later today.

[lord voldemort]

on that character assesment alone
unvote vote mandy

[nagerous]

Unvote Vote Mandalorian

Even if both sentinel and Mandalorian are beign honest and are both watchers, I'd imagine one of them was aligned with a scum group of some sort.

[Sentinel XIV]

Unvote, just in case.

Vote: mandalorian

Even if his claim his true, his character doesn't appear to be of the best repute, what with making an alliance with Ben Linus and such. I think this is the best move in the end.

[pmchugh]

if I ament already unvote vote mandalorian

[mandalorian2298]

Well, this calls for emergency measures.

Tonka, please confirm that you have visited Pmchugh last night, before these nice people make me dance with a rope.