Moderator: Community Team
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
strike wolf wrote: As far as the execution, I used it as soon as F1fth voted and I got the chance to follow up but Edoc initially hadn't noticed Jak's vote in thread so it was delayed.
Commander9 wrote:Trust Edoc, as I know he's VERY good.
zimmah wrote:Mind like a brick.
edocsil wrote:Yeah. it was only half red, and the "vote" part wasn't colored or anything so I totally missed it.
jak111 wrote: I was surprised to see Violet vote for Rodion though, I thought we would have all had to be out to get a lynch.
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
VioIet wrote:jak111 wrote: I was surprised to see Violet vote for Rodion though, I thought we would have all had to be out to get a lynch.
Well he said that I was lying when I obviously wasn't,
Rodion wrote:VioIet wrote:jak111 wrote: I was surprised to see Violet vote for Rodion though, I thought we would have all had to be out to get a lynch.
Well he said that I was lying when I obviously wasn't,
Except that you did lie (I still do not understand why you said your saint was alive). It's not even like I was threatening you, as I was holding my vote until I felt 100% certain of the path to take. I reckon you could have gotten out of that situation by simply admitting you screwed up. PCM, on the other hand, had some serious explaining to do on why he'd given Yoshi a cop gift after Yoshi fakeclaimed angel. Unfortunately, CC's bad habit of voting too soon did not allow me to continue my inquiry.
Iliad wrote:The upside of calling everyone scum and making 1000 predictions is that statistically you should get a few right.
strike wolf wrote:Jak couldnt win with town. Technically only mafia did count against you but it was 3 v 3 and double voter on our side. Me and PCM had made it abundantly clear that we would simply force your lynch as town couldnt force one and edoc decided to end the game early.
DoomYoshi wrote:Sry 4 double:
Yesterday I softclaimed angel. Rodion can investigate me and I can't claim to be human. That will verify me 100%
DoomYoshi wrote:Ok, I'm not an angel lmao. I am Brigit of Kildare, a saint.
Rodion wrote:VioIet wrote:jak111 wrote: I was surprised to see Violet vote for Rodion though, I thought we would have all had to be out to get a lynch.
Well he said that I was lying when I obviously wasn't,
Except that you did lie (I still do not understand why you said your saint was alive).
edocsil wrote:You are Catherine of Genoa, you are a simple saint trying to live life by your ideals and your faith.
You are a Backup Doc. You will become a full doc if Avitus of Vienne, the Doctor, dies.
To win all the Demons must be dead.
Confirm in the game thread, and PM me if you have any questions.
Rodion wrote:It's not even like I was threatening you
VioIet wrote:Wow Rodion, I still don't get you. And no, I didn't screw up when claiming. I think you just thought too hard about it when nothing was there. Here is my role pm:edocsil wrote:You are Catherine of Genoa, you are a simple saint trying to live life by your ideals and your faith.
You are a Backup Doc. You will become a full doc if Avitus of Vienne, the Doctor, dies.
To win all the Demons must be dead.
Confirm in the game thread, and PM me if you have any questions.
So yes my Saint was still alive as I said. It was you who said/thought/believed my saint to be dead for whatever reason. I remember you bringing up a point about 1512, which didn't even make sense, as it's 2013. All of the characters would be dead, if you think about it like that.
This was a game. It is not real. It's not real life! It's a game! Edoc has the right to bring up characters from all different time periods and put them all in the same universe/world/game if he chooses. You can't let details like that throw you off from the flow of the game.
Wikipedia wrote:Saint Catherine of Genoa (Caterina Fieschi Adorno, 1447 – 15 September 1510) is an Italian Roman Catholic saint and mystic, admired for her work among the sick and the poor.
jak111 wrote:I think what she means is Sam was still alive, that's what I gather from it.
aage wrote:Okay, that's just bullshit. You threw the town off balance by your claim. Want to know why?Wikipedia wrote:Saint Catherine of Genoa (Caterina Fieschi Adorno, 1447 – 15 September 1510) is an Italian Roman Catholic saint and mystic, admired for her work among the sick and the poor.
aage wrote:Obviously all the characters are dead, only dead people are canonized.
Umm, it's a game, not real life. You are thinking too hard. Being canonized in real life had nothing to do with the saints in this game. Once again, you can't compare real life to a game. In the context of this game, the saints were all living, and town aligned. One of the prerequisites of becoming a saint is performing miracles after you died. This meta junk you're defending yourself a posteriori with now is highly confusing and irrelevant.
aage wrote:According to you, we shouldn't even care if the mod confirms someone is God, because who cares about flavour?
In fact, you are the one trying to bring in information from wiki and other sources, when that has absolutely nothing to do with the game.
aage wrote:You're focussing on the "you're trying to live life..."-part, I take it. I was under the impression you were saying that your character, Catherine, was not dead yet in the context of the flavour (like Pope Benedict). Obviously you had not died yet in the game.
aage wrote:In fact, you are the one trying to bring in information from wiki and other sources, when that has absolutely nothing to do with the game.
1) I was scum, so obviously I could have been lying
2) I wasn't lying because it does, it can help you catch a fake claim. Everyone who had claimed saint had claimed someone who has been dead for quite some time. You claimed Catherine was alive. Catherine isn't. You are. This is probably where the miscommunication happened.
VioIet wrote:Me= Alive
Me= Catherine
Catherine= Alive
Or is my reasoning faulty here? Is the above a valid argument, or a fallacy?
Role PM wrote:You're Jack, town vigilante. You've watched the world succumb in chaos until you could no longer stand it. Now you decided to take it upon yourself to cleanse humanity of all evil.
Every night you can target someone to kill him.
You win when all threats to town are eliminated.
VioIet wrote:Hmm, Rodion, I know you aren't a native speaker of English, so perhaps that's where the confusion lies.
Rodion wrote:You're Jack, town vigilante. You watch the world succumb in chaos and you can no longer stand it. You decided to take it upon yourself to cleanse humanity of all evil.
Rodion wrote:You missed the point. The issue is not verbal tenses, but taking an useless flavour piece from your role PM and misleading everyone.
Rodion wrote: It should be obvious that the "trying to live life" bit of your PM was just for flavour, but you managed to make the point that your saint was alive when all catholic saints are, by definition, dead. The expectation was that you were either the Pope or some other really good-hearted contemporary human being, not some lady who died more than 500 years ago.
Rodion wrote:After you fully claimed and I went back to reading every post of yours to see whether the claim was compatible to the way you had been playing (something I always do as it may help see through a fakeclaim), I noticed the contradiction. Sucks that you had to feel threatened and vote me, but I'm not going to let something as fishy as your claim fly just because I had someone else higher in my suspicion list (do notice that nothing kept me from asking multiple questions to multiple people simulteaneously - the fact I asked you a question did not stop me from also interrogating PCM, which I did).
Rodion wrote:Not sure if you'll understand, so I'll agree with the recommendation that you bury it.
aage wrote:VioIet wrote:Hmm, Rodion, I know you aren't a native speaker of English, so perhaps that's where the confusion lies.
No offense but now you're just being spiteful.
aage wrote:Since, to my knowledge, everyone was confused by your claim, you also seem to be suggesting that all the players in this game must be non native speakers, or just suck at their mother tongue
aage wrote:While all that happened was that you just focussed on trivial details in your role pm that had nothing to do with the game. You ignore meta but do choose to go into the flavour of your pm? That is simply hypocritical.
aage wrote:But I am also on the verge of being spiteful so I will stop this battle of having the last word now.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users