Loose Canon wrote:PMC, Vot what exactly does my theory give away - because I don't think it gives away anything.
Lets say for example - I am Town Odd Night which gives me +6 to my number 7 - that means I would use my ability on Charle.
If I'm eliminated D2 onwards everyone would know I was Town Odd Night and had used my ability on Charle.
Which is information for Town.
But Scum can't use the system to work out roles.
So go on, stop being armchair know it alls - what is wrong with my theory if you really do know it all?
Because charle may be a bad choice to protect? What if he is one of the most sussed players? Are you still going to protect him with your altenating Night Power?
It's taking all of town moves and ensuring they are used randomly, surely we can do better than random?
Also, it provides predcitability for mafia. Say that me and vot were both mafia (that would be fun), we would know vot wouldn't be tracked (except by joat) because I am not the tracker but I am the name before him in the list.