WWI Ottoman Empire [Quenched]

[cairnswk]

Could you maybe put the words British Egypt and Constantinople in the insert where their respecitve arrows come from? And on the main map, maybe make the box around the insert a bit thicker?

Zeak, can we revisit that one later....i just tried putting those words in there...from Alexandria fits...
but Constantinople doesn't (nicely anyways) <- and it looks like a complete double up
so i'd like to revisit that later again please.

Sure thing. I can bug you about this once you're in the main foundry if you want

If they don't fit nicely, then I think the map is better without them.

OK.

I'm thinking, why not instead of having separate bonuses for Britain, France, and Italy, you give one large blanket bonus for all of their colonies. Because right now, holding all three will yield a bonus of eight while you only have to protect three borders. I think that is a bit over powered. Instead just call the bonus "European colonies" or something like that and give it a bonus of 6 or so.

Yes i waas thinking along those lines also, and will think more on that one. Thanks for the suggestion, and of you have any more thoughts on the configuration, let me know.

[Juan_Bottom]

Took a minute to load, but I'm diggin the update Carnswk!

[MrBenn]

This one is definitely in need of a stamp...

All you need to do now is wait to be moved...

[Juan_Bottom]

I agree MrBenn, My only quibble is the bonuses for the Italian, French, and H. of Mecca terts.

[cairnswk]

Took a minute to load, but I'm diggin the update Carnswk!

Nice

I agree MrBenn, My only quibble is the bonuses for the Italian, French, and H. of Mecca terts.

Attending to that later. Thanks

This one is definitely in need of a stamp...

All you need to do now is wait to be moved...

And thanks for that stamp also.

[whitestazn88]

i like the inset, but i'd prefer the top area of the inset to reflect the top part of the map that it is in...

ie. the inset has the top that has the whole point at it, much like the regular map, but i think it should just have the slanted top that is the same as where it is in the map

[cairnswk]

i like the inset, but i'd prefer the top area of the inset to reflect the top part of the map that it is in...

ie. the inset has the top that has the whole point at it, much like the regular map, but i think it should just have the slanted top that is the same as where it is in the map

How's this?

Version 9

[ZeakCytho]

I preferred the insert from the last version, without the curve from the map border cutting part off. Also, is it just me or does it look more pixely in this new version than before?

[cairnswk]

Option A - for the top of the inset -> Ottoman Dome


Option B - for the top of the inset -> Slanted top as per map

[cairnswk]

I preferred the insert from the last version, without the curve from the map border cutting part off. Also, is it just me or does it look more pixely in this new version than before?

Zeak...yes it is more pixely, but i will fix that...place your preference for top of inset in the poll, thanks

[ZeakCytho]

I preferred the insert from the last version, without the curve from the map border cutting part off. Also, is it just me or does it look more pixely in this new version than before?

Zeak...yes it is more pixely, but i will fix that...place your preference for top of inset in the poll, thanks

Done

Btw, you put the same image up twice. I think the bottom image needs to change

[cairnswk]

....
Zeak...yes it is more pixely, but i will fix that...place your preference for top of inset in the poll, thanks

Done
Btw, you put the same image up twice. I think the bottom image needs to change

Fixed. thanks, i did that one page 1 too, but caught that....didn't catch this oops

[Juan_Bottom]

I could care less about the inset.... looks fine either way, so no vote from me.... = )

[lt_oddball]

I don't think giving Italy and France a +1bonus IMMEDIATELY for having that ONE territory is such a good idea.

For a player to control Great Britain or Russia , it would take at least 5 rounds depending on competition. All that time having NO extra bonus.
Whereas the Italian and French "player" (both close together in the side of the British "player" ONLY(!) can hold it and expand and make it impossible for the british player to collect/conquer his zone. Thereby giving advantage to players around british empire zone to expand without worries.

And what can or did France /Italy do in that Ottoman sphere , really ?

So please leave that +1 bonus out .


Also another unfairness; ALL bonuszones are a wellconnected collection of territories EXCEPT Kuwait of the British empire.
To make up for this obvious imbalance you should give a direct seaconnection between Kuwait and Aden.
You may even consider giving a direct seaconnection between Br. Somaliland and Sudan (thereby avoiding the need to conquer France an Italy from the earliest onset).

[cairnswk]

I don't think giving Italy and France a +1bonus IMMEDIATELY for having that ONE territory is such a good idea.

For a player to control Great Britain or Russia , it would take at least 5 rounds depending on competition. All that time having NO extra bonus.
Whereas the Italian and French "player" (both close together in the side of the British "player" ONLY(!) can hold it and expand and make it impossible for the british player to collect/conquer his zone. Thereby giving advantage to players around british empire zone to expand without worries.

And what can or did France /Italy do in that Ottoman sphere , really ?

So please leave that +1 bonus out .


Also another unfairness; ALL bonuszones are a wellconnected collection of territories EXCEPT Kuwait of the British empire.
To make up for this obvious imbalance you should give a direct seaconnection between Kuwait and Aden.
You may even consider giving a direct seaconnection between Br. Somaliland and Sudan (thereby avoiding the need to conquer France an Italy from the earliest onset).

Thanks for your comments It_oddball, i will consider your thoughts on the bonuses.
in all fairness the map does say that british ports * connect to each other.

[lt_oddball]

in all fairness the map does say that british ports * connect to each other.

I didnot see the message of the stars...aha..ok , so that is covered


But..that means that Cyprus cannot attack or be attacked directly from south turkey or Beirut ? hmmmm
And doesn't that port system mean that someone just having conquered Kuwait from Basrah can jump to Akbah and then onwards to Jeruzalem ?
hmmmm ..
I don't like this lightning speed...

[Qwert]

I dont know who is your Names Advisor,but you have many names mistakes-
Anadolu
Gelibolu
Dayr az Zog
Konya-antep
Kutais-Batum
Elizavetpol
Crimea-Kuban
AKbah(do you mean Aqaba)
Siyas(i can not find these names)
Izmir(these is modern tyrkish name for Smyrna)
Constantinople(here you have location mistake,because Contantinople cover Part of euproe and asia)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I belive that you want to all names been in english translation,not to have mix,but i must say that you here dont have mix of names,you have mistake names-who dont supose to be in these area.

[cairnswk]

I dont know who is your Names Advisor,but you have many names mistakes-
Anadolu
Gelibolu
Dayr az Zog
Konya-antep
Kutais-Batum
Elizavetpol
Crimea-Kuban
AKbah(do you mean Aqaba)
Siyas(i can not find these names)
Izmir(these is modern tyrkish name for Smyrna)
Constantinople(here you have location mistake,because Contantinople cover Part of euproe and asia)
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I belive that you want to all names been in english translation,not to have mix,but i must say that you here dont have mix of names,you have mistake names-who dont supose to be in these area.

Yes thanks Qwert. If you look at the first map, you will see names i put there from English map at the time.

This is post viewtopic.php?f=241&t=59540&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&start=30#p1521266
where cdkutusu (who is turkish) advised of the different names.

I don't want this to get into a battle over naming rights, but am happy to accept (most of) cdkutusu's names on this since it is his country.
Elizavetpol -> this is only one region on old maps, Elizavetpol-Baku on my map is two regions.

I am aware that Constantinople spans two continents, but for reasons of space on the map Qwert, it can only be one here.

If you have some link of "authority" that shows these names should be what you state they should be, please advise me.

[whitestazn88]

voted for my suggestion

[wcaclimbing]

here you go, good luck with the map.


Now one of the CAs needs to move this thread to the main foundry.

[Qwert]

Yes thanks Qwert. If you look at the first map, you will see names i put there from English map at the time.

This is post viewtopic.php?f=241&t=59540&st=0&sk=t&sd=a&start=30#p1521266
where cdkutusu (who is turkish) advised of the different names.

I don't want this to get into a battle over naming rights, but am happy to accept (most of) cdkutusu's names on this since it is his country.
Elizavetpol -> this is only one region on old maps, Elizavetpol-Baku on my map is two regions.

I am aware that Constantinople spans two continents, but for reasons of space on the map Qwert, it can only be one here.

If you have some link of "authority" that shows these names should be what you state they should be, please advise me.

I whas to say that you have mix english and turkish all over map,and that why is not correct,you must use english translation for all map,because these is not only Ottoman Empire,you have parts of africa,europe and asia.
If you want i can give you more apropriate names.
Cdkutus is from turkey,but can not be two mix of turkey terittory-half in english and half in turkey .

[cairnswk]

here you go, good luck with the map.


Now one of the CAs needs to move this thread to the main foundry.

Ooh...2 ideas stamps (there is one back on P7)...i wonder what that could mean?

[oaktown]

Ooh...2 ideas stamps (there is one back on P7)...i wonder what that could mean?

means gimil and I have to do a better job of keeping up with what needs to be moved!

[wcaclimbing]

here you go, good luck with the map.


Now one of the CAs needs to move this thread to the main foundry.

Ooh...2 ideas stamps (there is one back on P7)...i wonder what that could mean?

wait.... what?


lol. I forgot that this map already had one.
O well. you get to be the first map Ideas Stamped twice.
At least my stamp got the thread moved.

[Juan_Bottom]