Moderator: Cartographers
That One Guy wrote:I guess the only note I have to make is that the bonuses for the rose/beer gardens didn't come into play at all until the game was already won. I'm not sure there's any way to change this, but maybe there could be smaller bonuses for holding 2 or 3 beer/rose gardens? like +1 army for 2, +4 for 3? Or something along those lines; I'm not exactly sure but all I know is that it was too hard to get and hold all 4 of one type of garden, all spread out across the map.
That One Guy wrote:The only other thing I'm not exactly sure of, (and I'm sorry if this has been addressed before) but the bike trails count as killer neutrals, right? According to Rules>Game Options, in trench games you should be able to attack through killer neutrals, but I don't think I could do this on this map? I'm not positive on that, but that may be an issue unless you know for sure that it's not.
That One Guy wrote:Thank you for the time you've spent developing and perfecting this map, I really enjoyed it and I'm sure many more people who don't post it here do as well.
thenobodies80 wrote:No, I'm waiting an answer about a thing (not directly related with your map).
As soon as I receive it I will quench some maps, also this one.
Nobodies
iAmCaffeine wrote:Sorry, but how did this get a graphics stamp?
koontz1973 wrote:iAmCaffeine wrote:Sorry, but how did this get a graphics stamp?
Why would it not get the stamp? What in your opinion is wrong with it?
it doesn't stand up to any of the current maps
iAmCaffeine wrote:koontz1973 wrote:iAmCaffeine wrote:Sorry, but how did this get a graphics stamp?
Why would it not get the stamp? What in your opinion is wrong with it?
Such a low standard, it doesn't stand up to any of the current maps, apart from Philadelphia but that's not saying much.
Comment early, see changes made, comment late, see them ignored by map makers.
koontz1973 wrote:iAmCaffeine wrote:koontz1973 wrote:iAmCaffeine wrote:Sorry, but how did this get a graphics stamp?
Why would it not get the stamp? What in your opinion is wrong with it?
Such a low standard, it doesn't stand up to any of the current maps, apart from Philadelphia but that's not saying much.
OK, but again, what is wrong with it?
Considering this one had longer than normal in the foundry and also a long beta, it might come down to a lesson learned.Comment early, see changes made, comment late, see them ignored by map makers.
iAmCaffeine, been noticing you a lot lately over in #GCCM thread , this was the whole point of it. To get payers like you here commenting on the maps. But it would be nice to get you commenting on maps whilst they are being made.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users