Mr Changsha wrote: King_H (who I actually think IS CC's best player) has never hid how he got up so high, though I think he is now playing wonderfully well against all levels and still maintains.
Right, but he did it when it was still okay to do so, and has since stopped. Also, he was really funny about doing it too, so it's hard to hold a grudge against someone with such a good sense of humor about himself. If he was vicious and douchey about it, like KLOBBER, it'd be a completely different story.
And I back 100% that the King_Herpes is a brilliant player.
---
One final comment. Shame is one of the most potent motivators of human behavior. If the mods were to allow such a list, it'd certainly cut down on the amount of time they have to spend chasing down allegations. Of course, this could become internet McCarthyism.
There are problems either way, but I think it should be given a chance. If it doesn't work, the powers can always remove the list and go back to the way things were.
However, I do think there's value in a "watch list" rather than limiting it to simply "convicted farmers". It could motivate the high ranks to reconsider their methods in filling their games, as well as make it possible for noobs to avoid getting turned off to the site, before they bother with premium.