LOST Mafia - Day 5 - cena-rules abducted!

[Anarkistsdream]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT!

(3) animorpherv1 - LSU Tiger Josh, jnd94, pmchugh
(7) Gimpythewonder - Lord Voldemort, rebelman, william18, animoprherv1, dittoeevee8888, ditocoaf, Sentinel XIV
(1) Mandalorian2298 - Fircoal
(1) ditocoaf - cena-rules
(1) Fircoal - Mandalorian2298


With 21 alive it takes 11 to lynch!

i changed my vote to amino, like that ^^^^

Sorry! Missed that at the top of the page!

[Iliad]

FOS: Everyone who was naming possible scum roles
"oh hey lets give the scum faction a list of names not to claim so they can blend in."

actually this is good for us
because info is good for town. Scum would not claim those names they would check wiki and choose a pro-town character

yeah but this info can just as easily be brought up AFTER a claim, sometimes the town gets lucky and scum claims a scum name with a different role, it's useful trap if a faction is uninformed.

Would you prefer
a) try to accidentally catch scum on the really remote chance that they will claim their name full-knowing their scum
b) find out as much as you can about the setup and then methodically catch scum

[nagerous]

Vote Gimpy


No, lynching people at random doesn't benifet the town.

its what happens every Day 1 anyway, I thought i'd just cut through the red tape

You just seem to be somewhat scummy to me, what with wanting to initiate such an early bandwagon. I don't believe basing your vote on someone being new to be a sound strategy.

Vote: gimpyThewonder

And your not bandwagoning yourself, early in the game?

[/]

Would you prefer
a) try to accidentally catch scum on the really remote chance that they will claim their name full-knowing their scum
b) find out as much as you can about the setup and then methodically catch scum

It seemed to happen in Godfather mafia several times already.
But still even if we do know the exact names of every scum player how does that help us if none of them will claim?
Anyways, what's done is done I suppose, there only so many names anyways.

[Iliad]

Would you prefer
a) try to accidentally catch scum on the really remote chance that they will claim their name full-knowing their scum
b) find out as much as you can about the setup and then methodically catch scum

It seemed to happen in Godfather mafia several times already.
But still even if we do know the exact names of every scum player how does that help us if none of them will claim?
Anyways, what's done is done I suppose, there only so many names anyways.

It will help us if there are role name stuff like in deadwood.

We need to know as much as what are scum names, how many scum there might be. Scum tries to win by covering up info. Town needs to get all the info they can get

[LSU Tiger Josh]

The information is helpful as I have never watched teh show b4 and don't know any of these characters although I don't really play my game off of role names as i've been screwed on this b4 aka nina stickler in dead poet's society.

[cmckinney]

Any info at all that the town can get on the first day is good information. And considering this show will probably have many twists based on the show, why would it be a bad idea to help people who don't watch the show get caught up with it?

[animorpherv1]

that's right, any information can help

[Ditocoaf]

It certainly didn't sound like gimpy was just 'joking' about lynching a noob and getting onto day 2. He didn't even claim that for several pages; if you're going to come up with a rationalization, at least do it quickly.

[/]

It certainly didn't sound like gimpy was just 'joking' about lynching a noob and getting onto day 2. He didn't even claim that for several pages; if you're going to come up with a rationalization, at least do it quickly.

Might that possibly hint that if Gimpy is scum or some other faction, his faction is consisted of mostly older players?

[cmckinney]

It certainly didn't sound like gimpy was just 'joking' about lynching a noob and getting onto day 2. He didn't even claim that for several pages; if you're going to come up with a rationalization, at least do it quickly.

Might that possibly hint that if Gimpy is scum or some other faction, his faction is consisted of mostly older players?

Possibly

[gimpyThewonder]

It certainly didn't sound like gimpy was just 'joking' about lynching a noob and getting onto day 2. He didn't even claim that for several pages; if you're going to come up with a rationalization, at least do it quickly.

Might that possibly hint that if Gimpy is scum or some other faction, his faction is consisted of mostly older players?

a) i made a joke and left for the day
b) many of the newer players jumped on that as if threatened and all of a sudden i come back today and have 5or6 votes, thus leading me to explain what should have been obvious
c) i am a factionless townie, were I scum I wouldn't have made a joke about random lynching

[gimpyThewonder]

Eh, just giving you adivce if you want to stay in the game, that's all.

dude you have 10 posts, thanks for offering advice, but i've been playing for long enough to keep my own council

[/]

It certainly didn't sound like gimpy was just 'joking' about lynching a noob and getting onto day 2. He didn't even claim that for several pages; if you're going to come up with a rationalization, at least do it quickly.

Might that possibly hint that if Gimpy is scum or some other faction, his faction is consisted of mostly older players?

a) i made a joke and left for the day
b) many of the newer players jumped on that as if threatened and all of a sudden i come back today and have 5or6 votes, thus leading me to explain what should have been obvious
c) i am a factionless townie, were I scum I wouldn't have made a joke about random lynching

that's a very vague claim, anything else you want to offer? like Name, perhaps?

[Neoteny]

Is it me or is it a tradition to bandwagon gimpy early? I'm new at this but am beginning to see a pattern...

[cmckinney]

directed to /: Are you telling gimpy to role claim? On day 1? That is really scummy.

[/]

directed to /: Are you telling gimpy to role claim? On day 1? That is really scummy.

No, just role Name what difference does it make if he already claimed townie? it just backs up his claim unless he is unable to because he has an important name, then I won't push it unless he's about to be lynched. (he is getting up there though)

[Anarkistsdream]

OFFICIAL VOTE COUNT!

(3) animorpherv1 - LSU Tiger Josh, jnd94, pmchugh
(7) Gimpythewonder - Lord Voldemort, rebelman, william18, animoprherv1, dittoeevee8888, ditocoaf, Sentinel XIV
(1) Mandalorian2298 - Fircoal
(1) ditocoaf - cena-rules
(1) Fircoal - Mandalorian2298


With 21 alive it takes 11 to lynch!

[cmckinney]

directed to /: Are you telling gimpy to role claim? On day 1? That is really scummy.

No, just role Name what difference does it make if he already claimed townie? it just backs up his claim unless he is unable to because he has an important name, then I won't push it unless he's about to be lynched. (he is getting up there though)

ahhhhh i see...

[gimpyThewonder]

why would I claim? b/c of a bogus wagon? i think it unnecessary. I'd be more apt to look at those who jumped on my wagon so easily and put some presure there. but hey i'm just the guy w/ a herd of noobs around his neck

[gimpyThewonder]

directed to /: Are you telling gimpy to role claim? On day 1? That is really scummy.

No, just role Name what difference does it make if he already claimed townie? it just backs up his claim unless he is unable to because he has an important name, then I won't push it unless he's about to be lynched. (he is getting up there though)

for those that know the show claiming a name would be the same as claiming a role. come on people, is this really where we are going?

[lord voldemort]

I'm pretty sure there could be up to six factions, based on the show (which I've watched all the way through):

Jack's survivors (want to leave)
The 'Others' (the natives who want to protect the island)
Ben (protect the island, but by season 4, he's no longer leading the others)
Locke's survivors (want to stay)
The 'boat people,' (kill everything on the island)
Dharma Initiative? (they might be a faction, but they were all killed before season 1 started by ben (who was part of the dharma initiative) when he joined the others.)

And then even other people playing the parts of some of the weird phenomena of the island. I think there's probably only thee or four of these, but it probably wouldn't be just six.

The fact that LoVo insists that there can only be two groups implies that either he's never watched the show, or he's in one of the other groups.

SKIMMAH
i never insisted on 2 groups. i said these will be 2 main groups...i also said there can be no way we will know exactly what the setup is


unvote wow that got out of hand. my vote was just a joke
dont claim gimpy there is no need.


i agree with wat iliad says on page 7 about getting info
there is a remote chance we catch scum on a bogus name claim yet town learning stuff is extremely helpful

and whats with all the noobs trying to give advice to the experienced players lmao

[rebelman]

unvote

[Sentinel XIV]

I'm pretty sure there could be up to six factions, based on the show (which I've watched all the way through):

Jack's survivors (want to leave)
The 'Others' (the natives who want to protect the island)
Ben (protect the island, but by season 4, he's no longer leading the others)
Locke's survivors (want to stay)
The 'boat people,' (kill everything on the island)
Dharma Initiative? (they might be a faction, but they were all killed before season 1 started by ben (who was part of the dharma initiative) when he joined the others.)

And then even other people playing the parts of some of the weird phenomena of the island. I think there's probably only thee or four of these, but it probably wouldn't be just six.

The fact that LoVo insists that there can only be two groups implies that either he's never watched the show, or he's in one of the other groups.

SKIMMAH
i never insisted on 2 groups. i said these will be 2 main groups...i also said there can be no way we will know exactly what the setup is


unvote wow that got out of hand. my vote was just a joke
dont claim gimpy there is no need.


i agree with wat iliad says on page 7 about getting info
there is a remote chance we catch scum on a bogus name claim yet town learning stuff is extremely helpful

and whats with all the noobs trying to give advice to the experienced players lmao

Just because a player is new here doesn't mean they've never played before.

[lord voldemort]

if you havent played on this site you are a noob simple as that
we do things differently than mafia scum
to not be a noob you gotta earn that respect
thats how it is