[Official] HP Mafia - MVP: Aage - Archive

[mtamburini]

actually what do you guys think of mtam claiming Hairy Potter but the scum not targetting him? kind of fishy...

I think we found our lynch for today.

Pixar's on the top of my scum list right now, but I'd still appreciate an explanation for whether you could, or could not be killed in the night.

Regardless if I can or cannot be targeted, this is not a pro town question to be asking.

I don't think refusing to provide answers to questions that are asked of you is a pro-town thing to do - it makes you look suspicious, which leads to more questions, which can lead to a lynch, which would then be a wasted day (at best) if you're town.
So, why do you keep doing it?

sempai

Explain to me the benefit to town if I can or cannot be targeted , vs the benefit to mafia knowing if I can or cannot be targeted.

[StorrZerg]

Tambo what am i?

[degaston]

Explain to me the benefit to town if I can or cannot be targeted , vs the benefit to mafia knowing if I can or cannot be targeted.

You didn't seem to think it was so anti-town when you first mentioned it:

Info I can bring to the town, I can never die in the night because if I do it makes Voldemort vulernarable to night actions (probably means night vigi shots) As long as Im alive Voldemort can only be lynched. Keep that in mind if there is another vigi whos shot does not go through it may not be because there was a medic save or a protection role and could just be voldemort you attacked.

I was just pointing out that your statement contradicts itself, and asked you to explain which part of it was true.

[mtamburini]

Tambo what am i?

Did you not receive a present?

[mtamburini]

Explain to me the benefit to town if I can or cannot be targeted , vs the benefit to mafia knowing if I can or cannot be targeted.

You didn't seem to think it was so anti-town when you first mentioned it:

Info I can bring to the town, I can never die in the night because if I do it makes Voldemort vulernarable to night actions (probably means night vigi shots) As long as Im alive Voldemort can only be lynched. Keep that in mind if there is another vigi whos shot does not go through it may not be because there was a medic save or a protection role and could just be voldemort you attacked.

I was just pointing out that your statement contradicts itself, and asked you to explain which part of it was true.

So you agree I have explained it already and I should not go into more detail then thanks.

[*Pixar*]

I think mtam's role is total BS. He knows if he claims something so powerful he won't get lynched as well as stating he wont get night killed either.

unvote vote mtam

[mtamburini]

Good luck with that Pixar you shall be the lynch for today

VotePixar

[mtamburini]

If we lynch all the people who are "dumb" we will have a really good shot of winning this game.

[StorrZerg]

Tambo what am i?

Did you not receive a present?

Nope

[charm]

i totally agree that we should not trust Stor. He is going to play us and the mafia to keep himself alive. However, on a good note, there is much more town then there is mafia, so I would suspect that he is going to keep his alliance with us throughout the day and by the end of the day he will do something to get mafia to not see him as a threat and therefore not get lynched or night killed.

We need to try and find the scum. Anyone have news to report?
Mtam did you do anything last night?

Fp'd by MTam

[degaston]

Mtam did you do anything last night?

Please fill out a form in triplicate stating why you need to know this and how it will help the town.
In any event, your question will remain unanswered.

[Epitaph1]

VOTE COUNT

mtamburini - Pixar
Pixar - mtamburine
Storr - BG

With 22 alive, it takes 12 to lynch.

[HotShot53]

Tempted to vote Storr for creating the bandwagon that cost us a vig.
Anyone have any better ideas?

sempai

Storr obviously was just trying to save his own skin - I'd still be happy to vote for him at the end of the day if there are no other strong candidates, but first I'd like to know why the others jumped on that bandwagon instead of just going after him?

I really don't understand the attention on Storr right now. Where were you people at the end of day 1 when it could have done some good? What use is it to go after him now? He's already claimed.

Don't we need another claim at this point?

I have to agree with deg here, Storr should have been lynched yesterday, except storr convinced enough people that there wasn't time to switch to him being lynched (which it turns out many people were online before the deadline and we could have lynched storr). But at this point on day 2, there is no reason to shut down the day and go all in for a storr lynch already, we can save that for when we again don't have anyone better to lynch, only next time actually switch to storr instead of to following storr lol.

[StorrZerg]

@bg ask to be replaced if you can't keep up

[dazza2008]

I can't tell i Pix is being scummy or retarded. He always plays a bit stupid in clan games but this game he has taken it to another level.

Going after harry potter at this stage is weird play. I get he could have fake claimed but can you really see that with no counter?

[HotShot53]

I think mtam's role is total BS. He knows if he claims something so powerful he won't get lynched as well as stating he wont get night killed either.

unvote vote mtam

It will be very very hard to convince many people that the claimed HP is actually scum... so yeah, mtam can basically do whatever and say whatever and ignore whatever questions he wants to with very little fear of being lynched. And, being mtam, that's exactly what he'll do. So I hope mtam can start leading town more effectively rather than just saying " so and so is scummy, vote him because I say so", but I unfortunately don't have too high of hopes.

As for pIxar... not sure if he's going after mtam because he's a brave (and stupid) scum trying to kill HP, or if he's just a town who is trying to go after someone he sees as scummy, even if it is futile to do so. His logic is a bit faulty either way, since the only likely result from going after harry potter right now is to get lynched himself.

Fp by dazza

[dazza2008]

As much as I hate myself for it I agree with Mtam. Some questions are best left unanswered. I can't even understand why they are being asked. Surely it only helps mafia. No?

fastposted

[StorrZerg]

Tbh, I think a kill was blocked. 1 kp with 24 players seems low.

[BGtheBrain]

*****

[mtamburini]

My reasoning for targeting storr tonight simply stated here, well find out if hes lying or not

So.... I think this post and countless others like it caused many people to back off of storr.

As a result this indirectly lead to Pershy being mislynched instead of us lynching storr....

Mtam, wtf happened?

Storr says he didn't get a present. I used my power on him. I wasn't blocked last night. Storr were you blocked?

I also agree that there may be more kill power that may be hidden. I think it was on me and Pixar is fishing out a medic.

[StorrZerg]

I Got no msg

[dazza2008]

Why would stor being blocked stop it? Surely just you being blocked would.

[madmitch]

Well there you go you knuckleheads we just lost two townies. Pixar and I were right, mtam should have been hung even with the so called HP claim, VOTE MTAM

[charm]

MTam - I'm inclined to vote for you too, unless you bring forward something useful. You said you were taking care of Storr or something to that affect early on in Day 1 (don't ask me to quote it. my computer had a hard drive crash, so I'm limping on here). Then you talk about a present that Storr says he did not receive.

FOS MTam

[Metsfanmax]

Explain to me the benefit to town if I can or cannot be targeted , vs the benefit to mafia knowing if I can or cannot be targeted.

This question would be a fair one to ask if all of us actually believed you and you didn't have a history of making shit up and being intentionally confusing.