Sherwood Forest Mafia - Game Over, Town Wins!

[pancakemix]

I'm not. Anyone could come up with a win condition like that. Anyone could come up with a role like that. If you believe his claims, you're being fooled by a madman. He made reference to a mafia roleblocker. Does he know that's a role, or is that just an assumption he made? He's made plenty of bogus assumptions, like the merry men after nobles thing, that could be his scum shining through the facade. That's why I don't believe him.

[AK_iceman]

Sure I can: I know Noble's WC because I received it in my PM and I know that your WC isn't Peasants WC because I am smarter then you.

Mandy if you did receive the noble townie WC, then why don't you believe Aeg's stated WC? I've yet to see any mafia successfully guess the WC in any game I've played... most won't even try b/c they don't know if it's unique this time.

"Seed of Doubt" doesn't work on me wicked. I am a bit offended that you tried it.

As a direct answer to your question: Because he did not quote or acuratly paraphase my WC's. Do I get a cookie?

My point exactly Mandy. It's questionable where your allegiance lies.

No, to the Nobles it ain't.

In the above 3 quotes, Mandy implies that he is a noble. He claims he received the noble win condition, and that his allegiance is with the nobles.

It doesn't matter, You might be a noble, a townie, scum an SK or other independent entity.
Oh and ever thought of the possibility that there might be other factions that you are unaware of?

Frankly no. There aren't. Again, thanks for the cool (however demanding) role, Aimless.

But in this quote he thanks Aimless for the cool and demanding role. Which definately suggests he is NOT a noble.

Care to explain Mandy?

P.S. Thanks for the 20 pages I had to read this morning everyone.
P.S.S. I messed up the last post, read this one.

[wicked]

and here we go again...

IC I asked Mandy the same things yesterday and he couldn't give a satisfactory answer. good luck getting one today. he'll talk you in circles and drag this thread out. hey maybe his WC is to get a 100-page day 1??

[AK_iceman]

Ok, we're all tired of Day 1 by now. Mandy knows that we've caught him lying and he switched his vote to himself because he thought that would be the hammer and would kill him.

unvote
vote mandalorian2298

I think that makes it 13 and I am lynched.

Anyone who isn't voting Mandy now becomes scummy in my book.
We caught him lying and he knows it.

Now in the off-chance that Mandy just really sucks at this game and IS a noble role.... we have a lot of leads to go on thanks to Mandy pointing fingers at half the cast in this game.

[dominationnation]

guys its obvios that mandy is trying to trick us back and forth on what he is. first he says hes a nobel. Then he wants s to think hes not. If we lynch him then we can finally find out what hes alliengence lies (unless he is something like a death miller) and Stop this going around in circles

[XenHu]

*sigh*

I don't know what to think anymore. But I want to get this over with.

Unvote:Aegnor

Vote: Mandy

-X

[pancakemix]

guys its obvios that mandy is trying to trick us back and forth on what he is. first he says hes a nobel. Then he wants s to think hes not. If we lynch him then we can finally find out what hes alliengence lies (unless he is something like a death miller) and Stop this going around in circles

Wow. I didn't know there was a parrot in this game.

[hecter]

FINALLY! A LYNCH! THIS DAY IS OVER! Wait… Should we make moz read all this just to be mean?

[Aegnor]

I'm not. Anyone could come up with a win condition like that. Anyone could come up with a role like that. If you believe his claims, you're being fooled by a madman. He made reference to a mafia roleblocker. Does he know that's a role, or is that just an assumption he made? He's made plenty of bogus assumptions, like the merry men after nobles thing, that could be his scum shining through the facade. That's why I don't believe him.

In a 25 people game, I don't think it's completely wrong to assume there may be a mafia role blocker. I wouldn't call that a crazy assumption.
As for my other assumptions, we've already discussed that matter, I can make mistakes you know.

[wicked]

umm no, he's still at lynch-1.

[mandalorian2298]

It doesn't matter, You might be a noble, a townie, scum an SK or other independent entity.
Oh and ever thought of the possibility that there might be other factions that you are unaware of?

In the above 3 quotes, Mandy implies that he is a noble. He claims he received the noble win condition, and that his allegiance is with the nobles.

Frankly no. There aren't. Again, thanks for the cool (however demanding) role, Aimless.

But in this quote he thanks Aimless for the cool and demanding role. Which definately suggests he is NOT a noble.

Care to explain Mandy?

P.S. Thanks for the 20 pages I had to read this morning everyone.

Np, it's nice to contibute to american "Literacy program".

Explanation: Your post should end with "But in this quote he thanks Aimless for the cool and demanding role. Which definately suggests he is NOT a Vanilla noble."

[pancakemix]

I'm not. Anyone could come up with a win condition like that. Anyone could come up with a role like that. If you believe his claims, you're being fooled by a madman. He made reference to a mafia roleblocker. Does he know that's a role, or is that just an assumption he made? He's made plenty of bogus assumptions, like the merry men after nobles thing, that could be his scum shining through the facade. That's why I don't believe him.

In a 25 people game, I don't think it's completely wrong to assume there may be a mafia role blocker. I wouldn't call that a crazy assumption.
As for my other assumptions, we've already discussed that matter, I can make mistakes you know.

But why assume it? I've come across that role only twice in all the games I've played, and those games are many. I'm not saying it's out of the question, I'm saying it's a pretty random assumption, one that I find too suspicious.

[mandalorian2298]

*sigh*

I don't know what to think anymore. But I want to get this over with.

Unvote:Aegnor

Vote: Mandy

-X

1. You were right in assuming that I am pro-town. I have just given up on explaining and am hoping that my death and the voting record will help you guys (pro-towns) to win this game.

2. I am not Sir Richard at the Lee. (although I tried to give that impression back when I was still trying to survive till Day 2).

And a message for Robin Hood.

3. I hope that my hopes about my role's abillities are true.

[Aegnor]

But why assume it? I've come across that role only twice in all the games I've played, and those games are many. I'm not saying it's out of the question, I'm saying it's a pretty random assumption, one that I find too suspicious.

It could be a noob mistake, I haven't been in many mafia games, but that role was in the only one that I've finished.

[pancakemix]

But why assume it? I've come across that role only twice in all the games I've played, and those games are many. I'm not saying it's out of the question, I'm saying it's a pretty random assumption, one that I find too suspicious.

It could be a noob mistake, I haven't been in many mafia games, but that role was in the only one that I've finished.

Please. n00b mistake? You're just trying to cover your tracks now. I was there your first game. It was NV3, where everyone was an SK. The other is Tombstone, and even if you did die twice, it's still going. Face it. You're full of crap.

[The1exile]

Please. n00b mistake? You're just trying to cover your tracks now. I was there your first game. It was NV3, where everyone was an SK. The other is Tombstone, and even if you did die twice, it's still going. Face it. You're full of crap.

QFT.

[Aegnor]

But why assume it? I've come across that role only twice in all the games I've played, and those games are many. I'm not saying it's out of the question, I'm saying it's a pretty random assumption, one that I find too suspicious.

It could be a noob mistake, I haven't been in many mafia games, but that role was in the only one that I've finished.

Please. n00b mistake? You're just trying to cover your tracks now. I was there your first game. It was NV3, where everyone was an SK. The other is Tombstone, and even if you did die twice, it's still going. Face it. You're full of crap.

*Cough* You keep picking at me? Check Tombstone mafia game, look at Wicked's role there. I'm not making up crap. But you sure are acting scummy, both you and your buddy-boy Exile.

[AK_iceman]

Aimless... due to your repeated incorrect vote-counts I did my own vote-count starting from my last one on page 40 and on page 79 XenHu dropped the hammer on Mandy. Please double check this.

Vote Count

• [5] Selin -- (spiesr, dwightschrute, autoload, Ehriggn, moz976)
• [4] Aegnore -- (got tonkaed, pancakemix, the1exile, Guilty_Biscuit)
• [13] mandalorian2298 -- (wicked, AK_iceman, spinwizard, hecter, Aegnore, willis, Selin, dominationnation, Anarkistsdream, for dummies, LSU Tiger Josh, mandalorian2298, XenHu)
  
• [3] Not Voting, Everyone Else

13 Total Votes are needed for a Lynch or No Lynch

[dominationnation]

both aegnor and mandy are full of crap but ask yourself-who sounds stupider. Unless you yourself are stupid then you will say mandy. Just one move vote to lynch!

[pancakemix]

both aegnor and mandy are full of crap but ask yourself-who sounds stupider.

Aegnor. At least Mandy isn't contradictory.

[for dummies]

if Ic is correct. And i suspect he is because he is a trustworthy guy. Then mandy is already lynched

[pancakemix]

But why assume it? I've come across that role only twice in all the games I've played, and those games are many. I'm not saying it's out of the question, I'm saying it's a pretty random assumption, one that I find too suspicious.

It could be a noob mistake, I haven't been in many mafia games, but that role was in the only one that I've finished.

Please. n00b mistake? You're just trying to cover your tracks now. I was there your first game. It was NV3, where everyone was an SK. The other is Tombstone, and even if you did die twice, it's still going. Face it. You're full of crap.

*Cough* You keep picking at me? Check Tombstone mafia game, look at Wicked's role there. I'm not making up crap. But you sure are acting scummy, both you and your buddy-boy Exile.

I didn't say it wasn't there. I said just because it came up once doesn't mean you can expect it to come up all the time. I didn't say you're making up crap, I said you were full of crap.

Tell you what, Aegnor, let's settle this. If you are a ranger, target me tonight. I'd like to test your roleclaim out.

[Aegnor]

But why assume it? I've come across that role only twice in all the games I've played, and those games are many. I'm not saying it's out of the question, I'm saying it's a pretty random assumption, one that I find too suspicious.

You are 2nd on my list, If I see Day3, it will be you. Exile is top priority.

[pancakemix]

Do you accept my challenge?

[The1exile]

He can follow me if he prefers.