autoload's 19 Player Mafia Game #1 --- Days 2-3 --

[Senfive]

No Lynch was the best option on day 1. No one listened to me. Doc dead at our hands, another townie dead, and the Red Unknown Wicked. We gave them 2 townies at the price of no mafia. How on earth did we get anywhere by throwing darts?

i was thinkin the same thing MB, but the way you've helped us, you are almost definitely town....but i've been wrong before....


who's left with experience? plus, remember our theories, MB?

maybe Xen Hu and Senfive, i haven't seen Senfive post in forever

SEnfive, and Xenhu don't seem to post a lot, and when Senfive does, it seems to be junk.

LOAD OF CRAP!!! I go to sleep at 2 in the afternoon. This thread goes up 5 and half hours later. I wake up at 1 in the morning and find 10 pages to read. Thats Scummy to you. why do you want to know who is experinced or not? You know as well as I know that I have been trying to root out scum. Thanks RK for the seeing that. I now trust you.

k. that's weird that they would kill Wicked, and Ob(whatever) because they were both very suspicious....

I argee

ok, i'm fairly sure that most of the Nyvek bandwagon was not mafia, but hey, i could be wrong....i know im not...

WEll I think that they should be watched over. Mainly the 2-5th voters.

right now RK looks suspicious...

DA!

i think i know what the locked roles are. Backups....

in andy's last game there were backups incase the front runners were killed....that's what i think the locked roles are.

I don't think so, in Auto's last game he said who had a locked role.

Why only the 2-5th voters? is that because your partner in crime is 7th on the list?

10 Nyvek (Master Bush, Wisse, Kokunai, trestain, Roger Dodger, for dummies, P Gizzle, reverend_kyle, supercram, wicked)

My new list of possible mafia

XenHu
SenFive
Trestain
RD

and possibly, RK

Pointing fingers with your Scum buddy I see.

MB, why the early vote?

I have my reasons.

Here are votes 4-8 for Ny:

trestain, Roger Dodger, for dummies, P Gizzle, reverend_kyle

I bolded P Gizzle cause of all the finger pointing he has done tonight. But I dont think he's mafia.....yet.

MB calls you out.

ok, sorry for the finger pointing, im just eager to see what you guys think...

i liked the idea of using lists and logic to find mafia...in the last game i was in, i randomly guessed....

You quickly backpedal and get lost in the discusssion.

I dont think cram or gizzle are mafia, cause no mafia would come out pointing their finger so much.

I have to disagree with you MB.

Nyvek bangwagon(Master Bush, Wisse, Kokunai, trestain, Roger Dodger, for dummies, P Gizzle, reverend_kyle, supercram, Houssam)(I know I'm missing some)

someone in the bolded group needs to get lynched today. there may be other mafia, but one (or more) of these people is DEFINITELY mafia.

I argee, but WIsse, should definteley be added to the list. MAybe, rev too.

i now *almost* trust fircoal. because i know i am right, that there is mafia in there, and fircoal is not trying to steer the discussion away from it.

Incorrect Cram. Fircoal wanted only the 2-5th names so P Gizzle wasn't looked at. I don't trust either.

No worries cram....

And, you know, not to pass the they-haven't-posted-in-awhile baton, but there are a few people on those various lists (kokukai and senfive spring to mind, tho I'm sure there are at least a couple others) that still haven't contributed.

But given the constraints of biology and economics, I'm willing to wait a few hours for everyone to wake up/get out of school/knock off work/amble home from the methadone clinic/whatever... just to make sure we get it right.

Again sorry for being a mortal and needing to sleep sometime.

Oh and FOS Fircoal and P Gizzle

[supercram]

Oh and FOS Fircoal and P Gizzle

so you're thinking P Gizzle over roger dodger?

[Roger Dodger]

just skimmed through the pages. getting ready for work. first off, i was only joking about Wicked. second, i don't hate anyone. so that was really a nasty thing to say Master Bush.

the other thing is, i've never played this game before so, i'm supposed to know things?
all i know is that yes, i did bandwagon on Nyvek but, i tried to unvote but was too late.

I can't suspect everyone here because not everyone has posted.

you guys are so quick to pin stuff on people. last time you killed the towns doctor and, i helped.

anyway just saying my peice before i go to work. i'll be back on line around 6am est connecticut time.

[Senfive]

Oh and FOS Fircoal and P Gizzle

so you're thinking P Gizzle over roger dodger?

Yeah!

[reverend_kyle]

Wow, senfive's theories really make sense.. and judging from his big change from last game he is clearly not mafia. I'm going to have to say right now there are 3 people on my list


RD
PG
FC.

[Incandenza]

I shall be leaving shortly to go to sleep.

I'll try and contribute tomorrow morning from work, but it'll be a bit of an on-again off-again thing.

By then everyone should have weighed in, and we'll see.

We can't get this one wrong.

[Roger Dodger]

okay, i'm back. so why or how the hell did i become the suspect. Why do you keep accusing me ? you people are all crazing. not even my healing powers will save u now.

so go ahead lynch me. you know i can't be mafia. just like before you guys jump the gun and kill for nonsense reasons.

I'd like to know who had the most to gain from the deaths. i gain nothing.

even when i voted for wicked and fos'd her she even knew i was kidding.

the only thing i have to say is that by killing me you will only make the mafia stronger.

[Roger Dodger]

Wicked said:

Nope, not angry at all, was joking around. I know RD's new to this game and has no real basis for that vote, and there seems to be a hint of a joke there anyway. I'm hoping all the new players catch on as we play about what to look for. This is where having experienced players helps, as I was mentioning earlier.

I replied:

okay you win Wicked.. i was kidding. i am sorry.

UNVOTE: WICKED

VOTE NYVEK

there i have done my duty keep our town street safe.

now i can close the browser and get on with my business.

i'll check in sometime tonight to check on the stats.

then, i joined the bandwagon. which i am not doing again. I thought that the "experienced players" were right. and we lynched the towns doctor. Nice going.

and then ofcourse is the " oooh that's a mafia tell" sentence which was def. not one
I think we should proceed with caution. i read the first day like 4 times yesterday and, the only think i can figure is that RK, Master Bush and supercram are tied together in some way.
they have been sticking together and the first 2 were the ones that were pushing hard to get Nyvek lynched.
SuperCram because i hate his avatar
yet, until i see or read something significant i will not fos or vote for anyone.

[Senfive]

Wicked said:

Nope, not angry at all, was joking around. I know RD's new to this game and has no real basis for that vote, and there seems to be a hint of a joke there anyway. I'm hoping all the new players catch on as we play about what to look for. This is where having experienced players helps, as I was mentioning earlier.

I replied:

okay you win Wicked.. i was kidding. i am sorry.

UNVOTE: WICKED

VOTE NYVEK

there i have done my duty keep our town street safe.

now i can close the browser and get on with my business.

i'll check in sometime tonight to check on the stats.

then, i joined the bandwagon. which i am not doing again. I thought that the "experienced players" were right. and we lynched the towns doctor. Nice going.

and then ofcourse is the " oooh that's a mafia tell" sentence which was def. not one
I think we should proceed with caution. i read the first day like 4 times yesterday and, the only think i can figure is that RK, Master Bush and supercram are tied together in some way.
they have been sticking together and the first 2 were the ones that were pushing hard to get Nyvek lynched.
SuperCram because i hate his avatar
yet, until i see or read something significant i will not fos or vote for anyone.

Did you miss my post? So they accused you, Big Deal. You didn't have that many votes on you. Why bring this huge defense when one wasn't warnted? You jumped just like they thought you would. You sprung their trap. All they wanted to know was a post of who you think is guilty and why, not a defense.

[for dummies]

for anyone ho was suspicious of me sorry. i just woke up right now FOS: Senfive just that he went to so much trouble to accuse P Gizzle and Fircoal makes him suspicious.

[Roger Dodger]

has nothing to do with traps. It just makes me mad that first time out I get accused. as a female, i have the right to speak my mind. so there

[XenHu]

for anyone ho was suspicious of me sorry. i just woke up right now FOS: Senfive just that he went to so much trouble to accuse P Gizzle and Fircoal makes him suspicious.

Why would that mean anything? Everybody's throwing FOS's out there anyway..


Major FOS:For dummies

His last post made no sense...


-X

[Roger Dodger]

so, fine


FOS P.Gizzle

because started the game accusing people right away and, his theory is BS

[Kokunai]

I would like to say that I after reading what Nyvek posted I was gonna remove my vote but by the time I read it it was over. But, RK still seems suspicious to me. Due, mostly in part to his joking. But, I need to read the posts my work/sleep means I miss out on the crucial bits.

[trestain]

geez 10 pages already let me catch up and i will post again after that

[Kokunai]

Alright gonna withhold voting this time. But, I think the argument against Fircoal and P.Gizzle is sound. Against RD seems weak. RK, hasn't said anything that removes my suspicion. For Dummies throwing out a FOS on senfive seems strange. That pretty much sums up my thinking.

[XenHu]

You have plenty of reasons for why you should vote..

Why wouldn't you? Unless it doesn't matter..

Un-FOS: Dummies


FOS: Kokunai

FD, I still have my eye on you, but right now, your the lesser of two evils..


-X[/b]

[trestain]

fIrst up i AM certain wicked wAs not killeD by the mafia last night, the Other kill was. CanT say why yet but i knOw this is tRue.

which means we have a vigilante, one thing NO MORE STABS IN THE DARK WHOEVER YOU ARE.

[XenHu]

Is dead...




-X

[Kokunai]

You have plenty of reasons for why you should vote..

Why wouldn't you? Unless it doesn't matter..

Un-FOS: Dummies


FOS: Kokunai

FD, I still have my eye on you, but right now, your the lesser of two evils..


-X[/b]

Sorry, my wording was off. I meant I was going to withhold early voting, as last time I got back too late to remove my vote and change it. Sorry, for the misunderstanding.

[Roger Dodger]

well, i'm sticking to my fos and adding


VOTE- P.GIZZLE


i have nothing more to say. not changing it. not nothing.

[XenHu]

Sorry, my wording was off. I meant I was going to withhold early voting, as last time I got back too late to remove my vote and change it. Sorry, for the misunderstanding.

Ok then,

Un FOS: Kokunai

FOS: For Dummies


-X

[Roger Dodger]

just wanted to add, i will not post the rest of the day & so with that said i request that my vote be counted. i have work to do here and, i can't be playing around online today

and, i would like to add one more thing to my vote


Yes to lynching

hangem high baby!

[P Gizzle]

geez, RD, don't be sour that i think ur mafia, because my theories aren't BS, otherwise, MB would be lynched, he came up with most of it. as for you senfive, i was just suspicious of you because you A) were on ALL 3 lists b.) haven't posted....but since you INSIST you were sleeping i believe you...



FOS RD

she's pointing fingers and making BS theories if you ask me

[trestain]

right i am read up,

Roger Dodger i do not like the way that you have swung so quickly from refusung to even finger of suspicion anyone, to voting and even adding "Yes to lynching", in bold. In less than 2 pages.

FOS-Roger Dodger