Puss In Boots C9 Mafia, Mafia Wins, Safari + Ghost

[new guy1]

i know, and i wish more people were active, cause everyone else looks like they are submarining -_-... could we get a prod, mod?

[ghostly447]

uphill because its slow slow is what you do when you go up hill
do we need an investigation roll to comforward and say whom they investigated last knight to get this going i dont know not been in this situation before what happens when theres no activity no lynch day one the way its going the same thing will happen today

The last game I played similar to this set up, our doctor claimed. But after night 1, we were positive that we had a doctor and a cop. Now we are not sure what set up we have, which makes it difficult.

To me, I dont think we should have anyone come out unless 1 of the following conditions happens:

Cop investigates and the player turns up guilty
Doctor defends someone, can go back, find who may have wanted them dead (or even who didnt care if they were dead, therefore setting up a frame) and backing it with a claim if necessary.

Honestly, option 1 is the only decent way to do it.

[drake_259]

i know, and i wish more people were active, cause everyone else looks like they are submarining -_-... could we get a prod, mod?

some7hing has been prodded,

If activity doesn't rise in the next 48 hours a deadline will be put in place.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Hey sorry guys im here and will read and get back with something later my night is crazy busy

[safariguy5]

uphill because its slow slow is what you do when you go up hill
do we need an investigation roll to comforward and say whom they investigated last knight to get this going i dont know not been in this situation before what happens when theres no activity no lynch day one the way its going the same thing will happen today

The last game I played similar to this set up, our doctor claimed. But after night 1, we were positive that we had a doctor and a cop. Now we are not sure what set up we have, which makes it difficult.

To me, I dont think we should have anyone come out unless 1 of the following conditions happens:

Cop investigates and the player turns up guilty
Doctor defends someone, can go back, find who may have wanted them dead (or even who didnt care if they were dead, therefore setting up a frame) and backing it with a claim if necessary.

Honestly, option 1 is the only decent way to do it.

ghostly is right, if we do have a power role (cop or doc or both), the cop should only come forward if he gets a guilty investigation. Doc should only come forward if a nightkill was prevented. That's really the only times I would say they should claim (to either clear or implicate a living player). I suppose if it comes down to endgame, claiming wouldn't be a bad idea either.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Ok so I actually kinda like safaris idea of having a cop or doc come out so we can find out if someone who is guilty

[ghostly447]

Ok so I actually kinda like safaris idea of having a cop or doc come out so we can find out if someone who is guilty

Amazing skimming skills there. I actually brought up that we should only have our power roles claim if they have good reason. And you just now came out and said they should claim. I think if they had any results they would have already claimed.

Vote CLEVER. Its time to put the pressure on.

[codierose]

Hey sorry guys im here and will read and get back with something later my night is crazy busy

vote some7CRAZY skimming

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Hey sorry guys im here and will read and get back with something later my night is crazy busy

vote some7CRAZY skimming

uhhh... how is that skimming its posted right above that post i posted
i realy dont see how thats skimming...can one of you explain

[dazza2008]

I missed the skimming too what ae you guys talking about?

CLEVER said something that others have said but this is not skimming. It seems he is just agreeing with what others have said. The cop should only claim if he gets a guilty result.

[safariguy5]

I missed the skimming too what ae you guys talking about?

CLEVER said something that others have said but this is not skimming. It seems he is just agreeing with what others have said. The cop should only claim if he gets a guilty result.

Must be the poor wording and sentence structure. The cop should only claim if he got guilty on someone or it is endgame and he can clear someone alive (although if it's endgame, he's probably going to claim anyways). And the doc should only claim if nobody died due to a night kill because then the doc can clear the targeted person as being town. Or endgame obviously.

Also if scum fakeclaim doc or cop, counterclaiming would be advisable too.

[dazza2008]

I missed the skimming too what ae you guys talking about?

CLEVER said something that others have said but this is not skimming. It seems he is just agreeing with what others have said. The cop should only claim if he gets a guilty result.

Must be the poor wording and sentence structure. The cop should only claim if he got guilty on someone or it is endgame and he can clear someone alive (although if it's endgame, he's probably going to claim anyways). And the doc should only claim if nobody died due to a night kill because then the doc can clear the targeted person as being town. Or endgame obviously.

Also if scum fakeclaim doc or cop, counterclaiming would be advisable too.

What did I say wrong?

[new guy1]

so wouldnt that make ghostly the skimmer? just saying it makes sense in my mind...

[ghostly447]

Ok so I actually kinda like safaris idea of having a cop or doc come out so we can find out if someone who is guilty

It was his poor wording. To me, it sounded like we should have the doc or cop claim now and then in doing so it would somehow find out someone who was guilty. That is what I read, I did not skim. It just sounded this way to me.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

Ok so I actually kinda like safaris idea of having a cop or doc come out so we can find out if someone who is guilty

It was his poor wording. To me, it sounded like we should have the doc or cop claim now and then in doing so it would somehow find out someone who was guilty. That is what I read, I did not skim. It just sounded this way to me.

Ya I see that sometimes I hardly understand myself lol

[Some7hingCLEVER]

ok i see that we are going nowhere with this day
honestly i would hate to see another no lynch
so in every possible way the game is set up there will be two mafia
so i think we need to lynch someone tonight
cause the way i see it if we go no lynch
the mafia kill a vt and then that leaves three vt and two mafia and if we lynch someone that day then there are two ways this goes
1) we lynch town and then there is two mafia and two town and town loses for sure
2) or we lynch mafia and then its 3 town vs. 1 mafia and that seems a little better to me
so i think we have to find a case on anyone including myself if you have one cause to me a no lynch is not an option

[ghostly447]

first case lets get this going
unvote vote ghost for
lying no.1
for being to serious no.2
skimming no.3
joking around no. 4
oh and for being tiny no.5
and we are only on page 2

vote ghost

2. I need to go remember why I lied. I believe I informed you (covering 3 as well) that I was on my phone, so I didnt get to see whatever it was.

2 is a bs reason. 4 is a bs reason. 5 is a bs reason.

weak case in my mind.

CLEVER, you have obviously Skimmed, shown inactivity, and attempted to bandwagon on a weak case with a weak case. Therefore, my vote stands whether I am to be lynched or not.

wow that is actually a good case...hmmm
well then you might wanna claim so you dont get lynched

So, I do not recall actually getting to the bottom of this terrible case. Since Day 2 is going as slow as molasses in January, I will go ahead and bring this back up. CLEVER, mind explaining yourself as to why you brought up this terrible, already disproven case, against me Day 1? All I saw in your case was "Bandwagon Bandwagon Bandwagon" after your inactivity (or I would prefer to call it, scumarining) and your skimming (obvious because you had not quite read that I had already gone through and answered the case point by point, and did not feel it was a strong case).

Fast posted by CLEVER

[ghostly447]

ok i see that we are going nowhere with this day
honestly i would hate to see another no lynch
so in every possible way the game is set up there will be two mafia
so i think we need to lynch someone tonight
cause the way i see it if we go no lynch
the mafia kill a vt and then that leaves three vt and two mafia and if we lynch someone that day then there are two ways this goes
1) we lynch town and then there is two mafia and two town and town loses for sure
2) or we lynch mafia and then its 3 town vs. 1 mafia and that seems a little better to me
so i think we have to find a case on anyone including myself if you have one cause to me a no lynch is not an option

Umm, yes, I beleive we all know what will happen if we lynch a townie today. The mafia will just stall until a deadline is thrown up and left, then mafia win unless a doctor defends the target, or we get a no lynch and somehow pull a cop claim (and guilty result) out of our ass.

Thanks for the additional fluff though, but I am afraid that doesnt help. The only lead I personally have is your argument about a case against me Day 1, where you were continuing to bandwagon against me with a weak case, then you hushed up when I claimed and the pressure stopped on me. So I will begin to apply a bit of pressure.

vote CLEVER

[Some7hingCLEVER]

first case lets get this going
2. I need to go remember why I lied. I believe I informed you (covering 3 as well) that I was on my phone, so I didnt get to see whatever it was.

2 is a bs reason. 4 is a bs reason. 5 is a bs reason.

weak case in my mind.[/quote]

CLEVER, you have obviously Skimmed, shown inactivity, and attempted to bandwagon on a weak case with a weak case. Therefore, my vote stands whether I am to be lynched or not.[/quote]

wow that is actually a good case...hmmm
well then you might wanna claim so you dont get lynched[/quote]


So, I do not recall actually getting to the bottom of this terrible case. Since Day 2 is going as slow as molasses in January, I will go ahead and bring this back up. CLEVER, mind explaining yourself as to why you brought up this terrible, already disproven case, against me Day 1? All I saw in your case was "Bandwagon Bandwagon Bandwagon" after your inactivity (or I would prefer to call it, scumarining) and your skimming (obvious because you had not quite read that I had already gone through and answered the case point by point, and did not feel it was a strong case).
sorry this looks wierd but i had to many quotes in there

Fast posted by CLEVER[/quote]


well you missed the messages in between in between you had stated that i was band wagoning and made a case on me therefore i said

wow that is actually a good case...hmmm
well then you might wanna claim so you dont get lynched

[/quote]
when i said this i meant the case against me was good not that the case against you was good
so i think that was a misunderstanding

[new guy1]

ok i see that we are going nowhere with this day
honestly i would hate to see another no lynch
so in every possible way the game is set up there will be two mafia
so i think we need to lynch someone tonight
cause the way i see it if we go no lynch
the mafia kill a vt and then that leaves three vt and two mafia and if we lynch someone that day then there are two ways this goes
1) we lynch town and then there is two mafia and two town and town loses for sure
2) or we lynch mafia and then its 3 town vs. 1 mafia and that seems a little better to me
so i think we have to find a case on anyone including myself if you have one cause to me a no lynch is not an option

Umm, yes, I beleive we all know what will happen if we lynch a townie today. The mafia will just stall until a deadline is thrown up and left, then mafia win unless a doctor defends the target, or we get a no lynch and somehow pull a cop claim (and guilty result) out of our ass.

Thanks for the additional fluff though, but I am afraid that doesnt help. The only lead I personally have is your argument about a case against me Day 1, where you were continuing to bandwagon against me with a weak case, then you hushed up when I claimed and the pressure stopped on me. So I will begin to apply a bit of pressure.

vote CLEVER

the way i see it, you seem to be putting a lot of time into this case which is days old and you completely ignored the case that i brought up about safari having a reason to kill trini. sure you put a couple posts, but the case i brought up is better then this. you havent been posting too much, and its only when a case is brought on you that you really come back and post something of substance which is just to save your own ass. FOS new guy1

[new guy1]

ok i see that we are going nowhere with this day
honestly i would hate to see another no lynch
so in every possible way the game is set up there will be two mafia
so i think we need to lynch someone tonight
cause the way i see it if we go no lynch
the mafia kill a vt and then that leaves three vt and two mafia and if we lynch someone that day then there are two ways this goes
1) we lynch town and then there is two mafia and two town and town loses for sure
2) or we lynch mafia and then its 3 town vs. 1 mafia and that seems a little better to me
so i think we have to find a case on anyone including myself if you have one cause to me a no lynch is not an option

Umm, yes, I beleive we all know what will happen if we lynch a townie today. The mafia will just stall until a deadline is thrown up and left, then mafia win unless a doctor defends the target, or we get a no lynch and somehow pull a cop claim (and guilty result) out of our ass.

Thanks for the additional fluff though, but I am afraid that doesnt help. The only lead I personally have is your argument about a case against me Day 1, where you were continuing to bandwagon against me with a weak case, then you hushed up when I claimed and the pressure stopped on me. So I will begin to apply a bit of pressure.

vote CLEVER

the way i see it, you seem to be putting a lot of time into this case which is days old and you completely ignored the case that i brought up about safari having a reason to kill trini. sure you put a couple posts, but the case i brought up is better then this. you havent been posting too much, and its only when a case is brought on you that you really come back and post something of substance which is just to save your own ass. FOS ghostly447

EBWOP

im sorry. hes my twin, he has the name that i usually use on other games but i got to this one first... as in other sites not this one, we have been cleared by a mod so that we can both play this site together. im usually ghostly447 on other sites but im new guy1 on this one. hope it doesn cause much commotion -_-

[Some7hingCLEVER]

ok i see that we are going nowhere with this day
honestly i would hate to see another no lynch
so in every possible way the game is set up there will be two mafia
so i think we need to lynch someone tonight
cause the way i see it if we go no lynch
the mafia kill a vt and then that leaves three vt and two mafia and if we lynch someone that day then there are two ways this goes
1) we lynch town and then there is two mafia and two town and town loses for sure
2) or we lynch mafia and then its 3 town vs. 1 mafia and that seems a little better to me
so i think we have to find a case on anyone including myself if you have one cause to me a no lynch is not an option

Umm, yes, I beleive we all know what will happen if we lynch a townie today. The mafia will just stall until a deadline is thrown up and left, then mafia win unless a doctor defends the target, or we get a no lynch and somehow pull a cop claim (and guilty result) out of our ass.

Thanks for the additional fluff though, but I am afraid that doesnt help. The only lead I personally have is your argument about a case against me Day 1, where you were continuing to bandwagon against me with a weak case, then you hushed up when I claimed and the pressure stopped on me. So I will begin to apply a bit of pressure.

vote CLEVER

i think its fine as long as your not talking about it outside the game

the way i see it, you seem to be putting a lot of time into this case which is days old and you completely ignored the case that i brought up about safari having a reason to kill trini. sure you put a couple posts, but the case i brought up is better then this. you havent been posting too much, and its only when a case is brought on you that you really come back and post something of substance which is just to save your own ass. FOS ghostly447

EBWOP

im sorry. hes my twin, he has the name that i usually use on other games but i got to this one first... as in other sites not this one, we have been cleared by a mod so that we can both play this site together. im usually ghostly447 on other sites but im new guy1 on this one. hope it doesn cause much commotion -_-

[new guy1]

i see what you said there, that its fine so long as its not talked about outside of the game. i agree, thanks.

[Some7hingCLEVER]

ok i see that we are going nowhere with this day
honestly i would hate to see another no lynch
so in every possible way the game is set up there will be two mafia
so i think we need to lynch someone tonight
cause the way i see it if we go no lynch
the mafia kill a vt and then that leaves three vt and two mafia and if we lynch someone that day then there are two ways this goes
1) we lynch town and then there is two mafia and two town and town loses for sure
2) or we lynch mafia and then its 3 town vs. 1 mafia and that seems a little better to me
so i think we have to find a case on anyone including myself if you have one cause to me a no lynch is not an option

Umm, yes, I beleive we all know what will happen if we lynch a townie today. The mafia will just stall until a deadline is thrown up and left, then mafia win unless a doctor defends the target, or we get a no lynch and somehow pull a cop claim (and guilty result) out of our ass.

Thanks for the additional fluff though, but I am afraid that doesnt help. The only lead I personally have is your argument about a case against me Day 1, where you were continuing to bandwagon against me with a weak case, then you hushed up when I claimed and the pressure stopped on me. So I will begin to apply a bit of pressure.

vote CLEVER

i think its fine as long as your not talking about it outside the game

the way i see it, you seem to be putting a lot of time into this case which is days old and you completely ignored the case that i brought up about safari having a reason to kill trini. sure you put a couple posts, but the case i brought up is better then this. you havent been posting too much, and its only when a case is brought on you that you really come back and post something of substance which is just to save your own ass. FOS ghostly447

EBWOP

im sorry. hes my twin, he has the name that i usually use on other games but i got to this one first... as in other sites not this one, we have been cleared by a mod so that we can both play this site together. im usually ghostly447 on other sites but im new guy1 on this one. hope it doesn cause much commotion -_-

EBWOP
i think its fine as long as your not talking about it outside the game
fastposted by new guy

[ghostly447]

ok i see that we are going nowhere with this day
honestly i would hate to see another no lynch
so in every possible way the game is set up there will be two mafia
so i think we need to lynch someone tonight
cause the way i see it if we go no lynch
the mafia kill a vt and then that leaves three vt and two mafia and if we lynch someone that day then there are two ways this goes
1) we lynch town and then there is two mafia and two town and town loses for sure
2) or we lynch mafia and then its 3 town vs. 1 mafia and that seems a little better to me
so i think we have to find a case on anyone including myself if you have one cause to me a no lynch is not an option

Umm, yes, I beleive we all know what will happen if we lynch a townie today. The mafia will just stall until a deadline is thrown up and left, then mafia win unless a doctor defends the target, or we get a no lynch and somehow pull a cop claim (and guilty result) out of our ass.

Thanks for the additional fluff though, but I am afraid that doesnt help. The only lead I personally have is your argument about a case against me Day 1, where you were continuing to bandwagon against me with a weak case, then you hushed up when I claimed and the pressure stopped on me. So I will begin to apply a bit of pressure.

vote CLEVER

the way i see it, you seem to be putting a lot of time into this case which is days old and you completely ignored the case that i brought up about safari having a reason to kill trini. sure you put a couple posts, but the case i brought up is better then this. you havent been posting too much, and its only when a case is brought on you that you really come back and post something of substance which is just to save your own ass. FOS new guy1

Im sorry? This case is stronger than any in my eyes buddy. PS you FOS'ed yourself. I beleive that someone would try to target the more experienced players, and woudnt be so careless as to target someone that could be linked to them. That is yet another poor case, because this is how I feel. -Why would someone attack someone else who brought up a case that could be directly linked to them. The town would just simply go against them using that, even though safari has claimed VT, which could be a fake claim, but still we cannot go against a possible VT and expect to pull a win out.-

I have posted as much as anyone here, being 1 of the more active players in fact. That accusation holds no weight. And I came back against someone other than you, and got fast posted. Why is it somehow that you say when a case is brought agaisnt me, I come back, because right now I personally feel that I came back to the CLEVER case, not my own. If I feel it is a strong enough case, I will defend myself, but you do not hold any weight here, and if I had to leave this argument with only a few words, it would be "You are looking very scummy right now, pulling up a case which holds no weight".

FOS new guy1.

Fastposted by New guy1 and CLEVER.