Sherwood Forest Mafia - Game Over, Town Wins!

[autoload]

I have to give props to Guilty_Biscuit. He hypothesized that Mandy could be Maid Marian on page 24 of this game. Not following the legends exactly notwithstanding, Maid Marian is very central to the Robin Hood story. Maid Marian was a blue role, and possibly could have converted over to the red side after the archery tournament.

I think my list of people to lynch (in no particular order) are Selin, Aegnor, and AK_iceman.

[AK_iceman]

For a guy who wants discussion about the game so that it doesnt reach another 80 pages....you sure are asking a lot of questions that arent all that relavant to the game.

I was talking about Day 2, where it said Robin Hood swims home to England.

Yes, I just re-read the rules and it does say not to read into the story because it's supposed to be fun and fictional.

But I was just thinking that maybe Robin Hood couldn't even have been killed on Day or Night 1 since he just swam here on Day 2?
Anyway, sorry guys... you're right that I shouldn't be talking about this so I'll just drop it unless anyone else thinks it's worth mentioning.

[got tonkaed]

its not that i really mind the discussion at all if you think we can gain something from it, but im not sure as of yet what we could learn about robin hood from the first two days...its possible robin wasnt killable on day 1, but unless there was some kind of post restriction on him we wouldnt know much about it. For me at least, i think there are more relavant things to discuss...exiles night choice, the possibility of selins lynching today, the possiblity of an argument being put together against AK, along with any other new lines that might emerge. However, i dont mind 80 pages a day if we are going to get something of value somewhere so talk away i suppose.

[dominationnation]

big fos AK and aegnor for the reasons listed above. Exile I think its time for you to tell us is aegnor right about where you went?

[I GOT SERVED]

I haven't even heard anything from exile yet....

I'd like to hear something from him before I vote.

[Aimless]

Also notice

Day 1 - In which there was great strength of feet.

Day 2 - In Which Robin Swims Home To England

Whats that about?

Robin Hood, Men In Tights, scenes one and two. There has to be some humor in this game.

[AK_iceman]

Oh, I guess I would have to watch the movie to understand the humor. I've never seen it.

So anyway... that just about shoots my Day 2 theories to the ground. Anyone else?

[Incandenza]

Okay, I'd be lying if I said I went back and closely read the preceding 83 pages (I promise promise that I will, you guys'll have to cut me a bit of slack here).... so forgive me if this has already been shot down and/or discussed...

but two things:

first, I'd be about 95% inclined to think that Selin is town, mostly because of how a mafia game tends to run. People tend to assume that people that stick out (active posters like wicked, aggressive posters like Ank, whatever) are mafia, and I can't imagine that aimless would've saddled a mafia role with the rhyming thing. I suppose it's possible that Selin is a survivor or a jester (or whatever that role is where you want to get lynched), but I don't buy the scum thing.

And the two methods of nightkill (beaten to death and the mysterious black quarrel) bear looking at. It may not matter, but I would speculate that the shooter of the aforementioned quarrel is Guy of Guisborne, who tends to be something of a sidekick to the Sheriff. (viewers of the costner movie will recall michael wincott's not-too-shabby turn in that role)... I would further speculate that Guy is a Vigilante...

Just a couple of things to work with. I too would like to hear from exile, and I suppose I should buckle down now and read...

[The1exile]

Vote Aegnor

Because I still think he's scum.

And yes, I did target autoload. If I was mafia, don't you think I would have refrained from targeting anyone to prove my innocence?

[Incandenza]

Okay, so you guys had a totally preposterous day 1.

And I'm not even halfway finished.

[Guilty_Biscuit]

I have to give props to Guilty_Biscuit. He hypothesized that Mandy could be Maid Marian on page 24 of this game.

I think my list of people to lynch (in no particular order) are Selin, Aegnor, and AK_iceman.

*Takes a bow* Before the night actions I would have agreed with you on Aegnor and AK but I'm going to have to read back through some of day 1 first. I'll probably get round to it tonight.

[Selin]

Day 2 - In Which Robin Swims Home To England

"Hear ye, hear ye!

The bandits have struck again! Fircoal was found on the road outside Nottingham, beaten to death! But the Sheriff had his revenge; the infamous wicked was slain, a mysterious black quarrel protruding from her chest!"

Dead are :
Fircoal, Nobleman, beaten to death.
wicked, Friar Tuck, shot with a black quarrel.

Let me start with this post at first
there is a hint given there
firco was shot with a crossbow
you need skill archery here!

this may help us at day three
where we will have archery
hope competition show us who
are the best, and are there many?


.

[Selin]

THIS POST WAS MISTAKENLY OVERWRITTEN BY ME. PLEASE READ MY POST ABOUT THIS ISSUE ON PAGE 87.

.

[Selin]

I have to give props to Guilty_Biscuit. He hypothesized that Mandy could be Maid Marian on page 24 of this game. Not following the legends exactly notwithstanding, Maid Marian is very central to the Robin Hood story. Maid Marian was a blue role, and possibly could have converted over to the red side after the archery tournament.

I think my list of people to lynch (in no particular order) are Selin, Aegnor, and AK_iceman.

want to analyse this post too
first your suspect on aegnor
same arguments for exile
makes you scummy auto, or?

you posted very few yesterday
not wanting in foreground?
typical scummy behavior
looks like another scum found

i did claim my role on day one
scums can't kill me on their own
only way they can manage this
is getting me lynched by town

day two: what i see on your post
you like lynch me most of all
that makes sense if you are mafia
because you can't kill me at all


SFOS: Autoload


.

[Selin]

Aegnor....out of curiosity why exile?

He seemed the most scummy to me, pancake was 2nd on my least.

However, the fact that he visited Autoload can teach us a lot.

There are many posibilities:

Exile might be a cop, investigating auto.
He could be a scum roleblocker , who took a guess and went for Auto.
He could be a doc who protected auto (low probablity, since Auto stayed low most of the game)

I'm sure you can add other posibilities.

First thought that came to my mind that he was some kind of hider role and maybe hid with me since it was low probablility of me being night killed. Plus my butt is sore...

following all my above posts
one more possibility
exile being mafia doctor
protecting auto-guilty

.

[autoload]

Also notice

Day 1 - In which there was great strength of feet.

Day 2 - In Which Robin Swims Home To England

Whats that about?

Robin Hood, Men In Tights, scenes one and two. There has to be some humor in this game.

Haha! I love that movie! For some reason it didn't dawn on me that the real Robin Hood didn't do that!

[autoload]

two things:

first, I'd be about 95% inclined to think that Selin is town, mostly because of how a mafia game tends to run. People tend to assume that people that stick out (active posters like wicked, aggressive posters like Ank, whatever) are mafia, and I can't imagine that aimless would've saddled a mafia role with the rhyming thing. I suppose it's possible that Selin is a survivor or a jester (or whatever that role is where you want to get lynched), but I don't buy the scum thing.

FoS: Incandenza

And the two methods of nightkill (beaten to death and the mysterious black quarrel) bear looking at. It may not matter, but I would speculate that the shooter of the aforementioned quarrel is Guy of Guisborne, who tends to be something of a sidekick to the Sheriff. (viewers of the costner movie will recall michael wincott's not-too-shabby turn in that role)... I would further speculate that Guy is a Vigilante...

Agreed. This character was also in Men in Tights in an exaggerated role of course like everyone else in that movie. I like the Sheriff of Rottingham's reaction when he is shown all of his medals.

[autoload]

Dead are :
Fircoal, Nobleman, beaten to death.
wicked, Friar Tuck, shot with a black quarrel.

Let me start with this post at first
there is a hint given there
firco was shot with a crossbow
you need skill archery here!

this may help us at day three
where we will have archery
hope competition show us who
are the best, and are there many?


.

Excuse me? Fircoal was beaten to death. wicked was shot by the crossbow. You so intent on defending your scum buddies that you overlooked this basic piece of info?

Also, Aegnor's claim to track The1exile either clears Aegnor or makes both of them guilty by reason of simple plan between two mafia. I'm inclined to now believe Aegnor is innocent. Nothing yet set in stone though.

following all my above posts
one more possibility
exile being mafia doctor
protecting auto-guilty

You are reaching pretty far now. As I said earlier, I was pretty low on the priority list of people to kill on both the Merry Men and the Noble side of the game last night. I think almost everybody can dismiss this possibility as you put it.

you posted very few yesterday
not wanting in foreground?
typical scummy behavior
looks like another scum found

I think I posted above average content yesterday, so that can not be used to help your case about me being scum.

i did claim my role on day one
scums can't kill me on their own
only way they can manage this
is getting me lynched by town

day two: what i see on your post
you like lynch me most of all
that makes sense if you are mafia
because you can't kill me at all.

The problem with this is that we can not verify your claim. We can only take your word for it. So to say that I'm trying to get you lynched because I am afraid that you can not be night killed is preposterous. Even if I was mafia and you weren't I think your case does not hold water. Either we have 2 killing roles and no one targeted you, we have 3 killing roles and the one on you failed last night, we have 3 or more killing roles and some targets were doubled up (which I don't think so because of the singular method of death with each victim), or you are mafia and whoever killed wicked thinks very highly of her abilities. Probably more possibilities, but I have to read back to think of more.



By the way, your poems are getting much better!

[spiesr]

FOS dominationnation you creepy little scum...

[Selin]

Vote Aegnor

Because I still think he's scum.

And yes, I did target autoload. If I was mafia, don't you think I would have refrained from targeting anyone to prove my innocence?

Also, Aegnor's claim to track The1exile either clears Aegnor or makes both of them guilty by reason of simple plan between two mafia. I'm inclined to now believe Aegnor is innocent. Nothing yet set in stone though.

the1exile it's your turn now
tell us what you've done at night
at the place where autoload lives
have you seen a mafia light?

it's a must in my opinion
to explain about your role
otherwise i'll stuck with my vote
and FOS auto as a whole

.

[Guilty_Biscuit]

Selin you are wrong,
if you're town then you are dumb.
Your suspicions must belong,
to someone who is scum.

Friar Wicked defended you,
and played her 'I'm confused' card.
Your rhymes are cool,
but the town should lynch the bard.

FOS Selin

Today I suggest we go for AK as he has been acting very scummy.

vote: AK Iceman

[Anarkistsdream]

So far, Speisr and AK seem like they may be Wickeds partners. Spiesr is submarining, and just poking his head up long enough to vote or FOS without any reasoning.

But, I will agree with Guilty... Vote: AK_Iceman

[moz976]

After the events of last night I think my biggest suspicion is still on Selin. Immune to night kills is a new one for me in mafia games. And it would be very easy for a mafia member to claim since he would not likely be targeted at night.
I am curious what AK has to say about the accusations against him. He and wicked we fighting hard for selin and wicked turned up a s mafia.

Also this is a pretty big game and we only seem to have a few active posters. We need to hear more from a lot of people. You should have some leads/ideas with all the information that has been put out there.

[The1exile]

following all my above posts
one more possibility
exile being mafia doctor
protecting auto-guilty.

Congratulations master bard,
Open your mouth and put your foot in,
For you paint a target on the doc,
Surely the scum's next victim.

And now for those that do not speak in verse...

I'm the doc, and I protected auto, because he's who I would have killed (on the first day when I'm mafia, I always kill a reasonably experienced player but very rarely the most experienced player since he's the most logical target for the doc, as well.)

I believe Mandy had a damn good set of suspicions, and the turning up with wicked as scum should confirm his accusations.

[The1exile]

After the events of last night I think my biggest suspicion is still on Selin. Immune to night kills is a new one for me in mafia games. And it would be very easy for a mafia member to claim since he would not likely be targeted at night.
I am curious what AK has to say about the accusations against him. He and wicked we fighting hard for selin and wicked turned up a s mafia.

Also this is a pretty big game and we only seem to have a few active posters. We need to hear more from a lot of people. You should have some leads/ideas with all the information that has been put out there.

Immune to nightkills can be bulletproof townie, I believe.