Sherwood Forest Mafia - Game Over, Town Wins!

[XenHu]

I agree on LSU. If anyone remembers, I had questioned him on why he hopped on a band-wagon, even voted him to see if I could get better info. All he had said was ‘go ahead, lynch me, it’s not going to help the town’(loosing paraphrasing). I’ll see if I can dig up the exact quotes.

-X

I found the argument between myself and LSU:

Being that evidently some people are too dense or else too lazy to see what I said earlier I'll condense it again. I don't know who the heck anyone is in this game other than myself being that the moderator has saw fit to not give me insight to anything. As such, I was willing to go with someone else's vote on the condition that if they were wrong that I was going to vote to lynch them on the 2nd day. Mandi at one point claimed he was about 80% sure so I voted that guy, but when better evidence came up against an actual merry men from historical context that vote was one that I saw as better. At worst, it would prove that just b/c someone in historical context was a merry men isn't in this game while at best it would knock off the rhymes and a real life merry men. While the poet may have admitted to whom that he is, it is not like he had a plausible argument against being that guy. As such, I refuse to change my vote and if some of you do in fact choose to lynch me in your stupidity than at least I know that I went down fighting for the greater good of the crown as my part is a nobody not attatched to the scum of the merry men.

Riiight. Once I got through your wonderfully well-written defense, I realized what a load of bullshit this is.



From what I can gather, you're basically giving an excuse to bandwagon.

Would you care to explain this?:

don't know who the heck anyone is in this game other than myself being that the moderator has saw fit to not give me insight to anything. As such, I was willing to go with someone else's vote on the condition that if they were wrong that I was going to vote to lynch them on the 2nd day.

It sounds like you are blaming Aimless for not thinking.

Vote: LSU Tiger Josh

I'm not buying it.

-X

Nope, I just said Aimless saw fit not to give me insight to anyone's role other than who the scum are. To me the evidence that Mandi presented is clear and since you're voting on me i'm placing a FOS on everyone that has voted me Xenhu and Ehriggn

What do you mean 'Saw fit not to give me insight to anyone's role other than who the scum are'? Either your claiming cop, in which case you'd be lying, because you wouldn't have had the chance to investigate anyone, or, Aimless made a new role.

Unless....

I'll get back to you with the rest of my thought. I want to hear your answer first.

-X

I had asked it way before he posted it in here. It even had some people thinking that I was trying to confuse them by callign the merry men scum. Vote how you wish, but as such I will continue to FOS XENHU

And now, instead of defending yourself(in a way that makes sense), you continue to point fingers at other people who accuse you.

That's not exactly the brightest thing to do.



-X

-X

[LSU Tiger Josh]

No reason for me to post to much being that idiot number 1(Xenhu) will use whatever I say as justification on voting for and then idiots number 2 and more will bandwagon the vote on me. My role is for the crown pure and simple. It places me in danger at night which is why I'm twice as likely to come up dead from the scum. Being that Xenhu is still obsessed with trying to kill me when I'm a nobody in this game FOS at him.


As far as the results of Day 1 showing, we have the Maid Marian accusing 4 individuals specifically on Day 1 of being scum. So far 1 of the 4 has been killed and shown to be scum. While I still have my doubts about lynching Aegner at this time, I would say either of the other 2 accusations that he made would be suitable targets to try to prove if the Maiden did in fact have inside information on the scum.

[Anarkistsdream]

Maid Marion was a roleblocker... She knew jack shit...

Saying that you are a nobody LSU and then saying that you are twice as likely to be killed at night is about the most ridiculous contradiction I have read in a mafia game.

LSU, you are defensive, rude, and your arguments are pretty lame. Why are you so defensive and rude??? Probably because you can not come up with a good argument to defend yourself.

Refusing to answer basic questions is pretty scummy.

[for dummies]

ok heres the thing LSu. You say "oh one of mandy predicitons was right". Ad is right that means nothing. the roleblocker has no info on any of the mafia members. those were guesses and mandy got lucky with one of them.

[Selin]

Selin you are wrong,
if you're town then you are dumb.
Your suspicions must belong,
to someone who is scum.

Friar Wicked defended you,
and played her 'I'm confused' card.
Your rhymes are cool,
but the town should lynch the bard.

FOS Selin

Today I suggest we go for AK as he has been acting very scummy.

vote: AK Iceman

thats a very good point biscuit
that shows how well played wicked
i will explain why it makes sense
understand how she played!

so, i was almost being lynched
that's on day one, yesterday
i had most votes among you all
she defended me on her way

lets think a little together
assuming i'm scum, lets say.
wicked was knowing with high chance
i will be lynched anyway

the question here is, my friend
why would she have risked herself?
by defending me obviously
she would have looked like scum self!

She hoped you lynch me yesterday
and find out that i'm pro-town
then she would have been one of those
who believed me on her own

you would have thought logically
that she is also pro-town
then she could have said easily
she belongs also to town

.

[Incandenza]

The farther I get through day one, the more I want to punch mandy in the face. I'm sure by about page 80 I'm going to be going down to the store, buying a boba fett action figure, and lighting the thing on fire.

Anyway.

If there's additional evidence against AK other than 'he agreed with wicked', then I'd like to hear it. Because when I see this:

Final Vote Count
Aegnor - 6 (got tonkaed, pancakemix, The1exile, jnd, XenHu, Guilty_Biscuit)
mandalorian - 13 (wicked, AK_Iceman, spinwizard, hecter, Aegnor, willis, Selin, dominationnation, Anarkistsdream, for dummies, LSU Tiger Josh, mandalorian, XenHu)
Selin - 5 (spiesr, dwightschrute, autoload, Ehriggn, moz)

I don't get a scum vibe from AK. I can't imagine that an experienced player like AK would allow himself to be even mentioned in the same sentence as wicked if they were both mafia. Plus, as auto mentioned a few posts ago, it would make sense for wicked to try and ally herself with AK, as I've done the exact same thing in other games.

As far as Selin goes, he makes an excellent point in his last post. It makes total sense for wicked to back a scummy-looking townie, so when he hangs she can plaintively cry "ZOMG I was right you lynchers are scum!" The mafia knows who is and is not scum. And to think that wicked would risk exposure on day bloody one to help out a fellow mafia is patently absurd.

Plus, correct me if I'm wrong, but this game started on day one, so it's not like the mafia had a night of PMs to game-plan day one.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

Maid Marion was a roleblocker... She knew jack shit...

Saying that you are a nobody LSU and then saying that you are twice as likely to be killed at night is about the most ridiculous contradiction I have read in a mafia game.

LSU, you are defensive, rude, and your arguments are pretty lame. Why are you so defensive and rude??? Probably because you can not come up with a good argument to defend yourself.

Refusing to answer basic questions is pretty scummy.

Thank you anark for becoming idiot number 2 in this game. Like I said idiots like this is why I won't post much b/c even though most of yall are intelligent enough to comprehend why I "might" be twice as likely to die at night for the crown some scumbags such as anark ir xanhu are stupid enough to still go after a townie.

[spiesr]

1. I am not purposely subamrining, I was gone for the last 40 pages of day 1...
2. My FOS didn't have much proof with it. I just found him suspcious...

[The1exile]

It doesn't make sense that The1exile would vote for Aegnor after Aegnor was right about his night actions, but he did say he will come back and answer why. In the mean time I think we should all work towards who to agree on for today's Lynch.

Heres the thing though.

Mandy said that either Aegnor or he was scum. Aegnor also had a pretty decent vote following. And, his defence didn't convince me.

His role can easily be a mafias - hey, think about it, who is likely to be the best rangers, the merry men right? After all, they live out in those woods on the run from the sheriff.

Not to mention that I flipping asked Aegnor to track me to prove I was protown when I targeted someone and they actually didn't die. Amazing, no?

If you lynch me then you just save the mafia the trouble of killing me, because they can't afford to let a doc live. And I think Aegnor is scum, and he hasn't changed my mind.

Annie, can you stop changing votes?

Josh, quit calling everyone an idiot, it doesn't make you look any more innocent.

Lastly I'm staying at a mates over the weekend and have limited internet access as my laptop is still not fixed.

Hope this helps.

Your friendly neighbourhood doc.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

It doesn't make sense that The1exile would vote for Aegnor after Aegnor was right about his night actions, but he did say he will come back and answer why. In the mean time I think we should all work towards who to agree on for today's Lynch.

Heres the thing though.

Mandy said that either Aegnor or he was scum. Aegnor also had a pretty decent vote following. And, his defence didn't convince me.

His role can easily be a mafias - hey, think about it, who is likely to be the best rangers, the merry men right? After all, they live out in those woods on the run from the sheriff.

Not to mention that I flipping asked Aegnor to track me to prove I was protown when I targeted someone and they actually didn't die. Amazing, no?

If you lynch me then you just save the mafia the trouble of killing me, because they can't afford to let a doc live. And I think Aegnor is scum, and he hasn't changed my mind.

Annie, can you stop changing votes?

Josh, quit calling everyone an idiot, it doesn't make you look any more innocent.

Lastly I'm staying at a mates over the weekend and have limited internet access as my laptop is still not fixed.

Hope this helps.

Your friendly neighbourhood doc.

Like I said I'm not convinced yet on Aegner but at this point I'm willing to wait til we see one of the other 2 that were fingered by the Maid. She may have been a "role blocker" but she also may have had inside knowledge on who was who being that she was kind of a double agent. I do agree with you on the Merry Men more likely having a ranger type.


As far as calling people an idiot when the shoe fits they'll wear it because like I said most of the intelligent people in this town should be able to know what I am by now from my prior posts and why I'm twice as likely to die as anyone else at night. If anyone can't figure that out then they are an idiot as I have given enough info to guess my job.

[Colaalone]

Hey people. I have a shit ton to read. I'll post something relevant once I've gone through everything. But until then...

I'm willing to wait til we see one of the other 2 that were fingered by the Maid.

[pancakemix]

I'm almost ready to vote LSU for calling everyone an idiot.

[Anarkistsdream]

I'm almost ready to vote LSU for calling everyone an idiot.

Me too... I expect an apolgy right now, LSU... I don't give a flying f*ck if this is a game or not... You'ld better fucking apologize. I don't care about how 'offended' you are or how big of an 'idiot' everyone is for not getting what you are talking about. You are acting like a 13 year old child and it is reasons like this that cause newbie jack-offs to this site like you to be black-balled from future games.

As it is, I guarantee the people on this site would rather have me play than you, and if you don't start acting a little more considerately, this will be your last game here, motherfucker.

[AK_iceman]

*Starts chanting "FIGHT! .... FIGHT! .... FIGHT!"*

[dominationnation]

right now Im thinking about voteing either LSU or Selin. Both are annoying. Both are stupid. Ak is also extreamly suspecious but I bieleve what was said above. If both Ak and wicked were scum they would know better then to associate themselves with each other.

[I GOT SERVED]

HAY WOAH WOAH.

Seriously, lets just take this down a notch.


Now that that's being said, LSU isn't exactly getting along with my point of view. There's nothing wrong game-wise with what he said, hence no vote or FOS. Just letting you know that I have my eye on you now.....

[pancakemix]

right now Im thinking about voteing either LSU or Selin. Both are annoying. Both are stupid. Ak is also extreamly suspecious but I bieleve what was said above. If both Ak and wicked were scum they would know better then to associate themselves with each other.

Can you actually think for yourself?

[Anarkistsdream]

right now Im thinking about voteing either LSU or Selin. Both are annoying. Both are stupid. Ak is also extreamly suspecious but I bieleve what was said above. If both Ak and wicked were scum they would know better then to associate themselves with each other.

Can you actually think for yourself?

*** Fight Fight Fight Fight!!!!***

[LSU Tiger Josh]

I'm almost ready to vote LSU for calling everyone an idiot.

Me too... I expect an apolgy right now, LSU... I don't give a flying f*ck if this is a game or not... You'ld better fucking apologize. I don't care about how 'offended' you are or how big of an 'idiot' everyone is for not getting what you are talking about. You are acting like a 13 year old child and it is reasons like this that cause newbie jack-offs to this site like you to be black-balled from future games.

As it is, I guarantee the people on this site would rather have me play than you, and if you don't start acting a little more considerately, this will be your last game here, motherfucker.

I'm not apoligizing your idiot butt especially being that you have saw fit to start cursing and calling me a lot worse then an idiot. The only ones that have been called idiot were you and Xanhu although I'll say this much for Xanhu he at least thought for himself instead of you bandwagoning on to what he said.


VOTE ANARKISTSDREAM FOR CUSSING

[Anarkistsdream]

HAHAHAHA... That's gonna stand up real nice... Voting me for cussing.... HAHAHAHAHAHAHA

We'll see how that attitude works out for you and your 12 year old ass.

[dominationnation]

right now Im thinking about voteing either LSU or Selin. Both are annoying. Both are stupid. Ak is also extreamly suspecious but I bieleve what was said above. If both Ak and wicked were scum they would know better then to associate themselves with each other.

Can you actually think for yourself?

I can but everything that I had to say was already said. Lsu hasnt put up an actual defense yet and Selins post are too anoying to actually figure out so if he did make a defence i might not of even realized it

[Anarkistsdream]

Hey hey hey... Selin has English as his second language, and then he was forced to talk in rhyme... Cut him some slack.

[Incandenza]

Selins post are too anoying to actually figure out so if he did make a defence i might not of even realized it

Seriously? For having to speak in rhyme, I've found selin's posts to be highly informative and not annoying in the slightest. C'mon, this ain't the work of sylvia plath.

And LSU, you need to chill out a bit, bro. If you're implying what I suspect you're implying, you VERY much need to chill out. Please.

[LSU Tiger Josh]

You probably are right Incan being that it isn't rocket science, but until I get a message back from the complaint I've lodged I'm done posting in this tread.

[got tonkaed]

Alright all you e thugs out there, we all know you guys are pretty tough customers lol.

Anywho to some game type business. Lsu, part of the issue that i have with your hinting so far is that, although some of us may have a decent clue, you really havent said much of anything other than that your likely to be killed if you reveal your information. Well, the majority of power protown roles work like that, and the fact of the matter is, when suspicion is brought upon you, if you make a reasonable defense, trackers can follow you or doctors can protect you. Instead, by not saying very much, a cop may investigate you, wasting an investigation if you are in fact town. And even if your charcter died, if it helped directly lynch one scum it would be worth it, since any individual townie life is not worth more than the towns success itself. you could do better to clear yourself at the moment.

Im not quite so sure what to think at the moment about exile/aegnor. Though its quite possible that they are both town, it certainly seems possible that a trade line between two. Either way theres probably other lines that need to be opened up today to keep us moving in the right direction.