First off, I'd like to say that we cannot trust any agenda saxlad tries to push against me.. this is illustrated by a simple analysis of the few actions that pmchugh took in day one, which were all an unbalanced focus lynch on me and it can definitely be argued that since replacing saxlad has followed a very similar agenda and he is not cleer enough at mafia to play a faux-lyncher to avoid suspicion. However, this puts TheSaxLad directly in the category of lyncher - a 3rd party but a harmless one for sure.
We are approaching end-game ish here so I thought it was time to do a run-down of who is alive and who isn't, what people have claimed and who is scummiest. This way it will be very easy to start pin-pointing the remaining town and finish the game. From what I can figure out, I don't think we can trust victor sullivan's allusions about there being 2 scum groups - from the scenes and the descriptions there seems to be only one team of mafia and there must only be a couple of core members remaining. I would say that we also however have an SK on the go somewhere.
Here is the list of alive players, those who are town/probably town I've put in blue and those who are still questionable are displayed in a scummy red.
ga7 - some form of teacher?
Theherkman - leader of a power group of sorts?
saxlad (revived to replace pmcshugh) - lyncher (do not trust)
TA1LGUNNER - town/role unknown
Floresdelmal - town/role unknown
commander - local gunsmith - proved himself to be town
karelpieterje - unknown
nagerous - pro-town hero!
/ - unknown
stefunny - unknown gun carrier (very suspicious)
naxus - some form of watcher? helped on the VS lynch
thezzaruz - unknown
strike wolf - some kind of actor, appears to be town
Now here is the karelpieterje post that I found ultra-scummy the previous day:
karelpietertje wrote:theherkman wrote:karelpietertje wrote:herk? I thought you promised to have Jace killed?
Did you change your plan, did you get busdriven, or do you not want to give away this info?
I'll put my vote on jace in case your answer is one of the latter two.
The CPR doc is a member of "Team Rocket". We discussed using him to NK Jace and that is what we decided on. So there are a number of things that could be going on.
1. My CPR doc is somehow not town aligned and chose to not target Jace.
2. My CPR doc didn't listen and chose not to target Jace.
3. Someone else targeted Jace and my CPR doc saved him...
4. My CPR doc was roleblocked.
He wasn't busdriven because nobody else died of a CPR doc. I'm leaning toward 3 or 4. More likely 3.
So now on another note: With the death of Flow my group only has enough protects to save important townies who have already claimed + 1. That means we can protect a townie who has a lead on scum and needs to claim today.
So you're saying Jace was scum, being targetted by a pro-town killing role? A vigilante then?
I myself think that a pro-town killing role wouldn't have targetted Jace because you kind of made it clear that you were going to have him killed.
So I think that if Jace has been attacked tonight, it must have been scum. This would mean he isn't part of the scum right?
There's so many possibilities right now of what happened, and we don't have any extra leads from the past night; a kill that seems to be the work of the poisoner that is already dead, a knife-kill on on FBI agent which doesn't seem to be anything but regular mobsters, and a revival that has been explained already.
Could our CPR actually be a crazy doctor? (I admit the defibrillator wounds indicate the CPR but I could still fit the insane doctor in I think)
Anyway, I just think theherkman wanting to lynch Jace off when the Night indicates that he has been targeted by a nightkill and saved by a doc is scummy.
FoS theherkman
He is involved in an irrelevant dispute with herkman over whether someone tried to kill off jace in the last night, this suggests to me he is not part of herk's 'power team' and he is also a jace defender having been skimming and not realised that jace had been caught in a lie. I would not be surprised if he is the final member of the mafia.
However, stefunny should be priority no.1 for the lynch today. Him carrying a gun is very suspicious, he also doesn't appear to be a member of theherkman's 'power group.' He is also not our resident cop.
